Noam and Zellig

Nevin, Bruce E.

doi:10.1075/z.154.05nev

In:Chomskyan (R)evolutions
Edited by Douglas A. Kibbee
[Not in series 154] 2010
► pp. 103–168

Get fulltext

Download Chapter PDF

Noam and Zellig

Bruce E. Nevin

Available under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives (CC BY-NC-ND) 4.0 license.

For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at rights@benjamins.nl.

Published online: 18 February 2010

https://doi.org/10.1075/z.154.05nev

In this paper, we explore when and how the work of Noam Chomsky diverged from that of his mentor, Zellig Harris, and identify the origins and character of their differences. Considering evidence that they never fully understood each other, the rhetorical vehicle for this exploration is speculation as to how much this divergence is due to differences of temperament, to “post-war” generational differences, or, with more importance for the field, to different conceptions of the proper conduct of science. A number of questions are addressed, such as: Is truth attained by winning arguments, or is the appropriate role of argument to do everything possible to prove oneself wrong? Is a theory of language a prerequisite to or an outcome of linguistic analysis? And what are the fundamental data of linguistics?

Cited by (24)

Cited by 24 other publications

Order by:

Pullum, Geoffrey K.

2025. The prehistory of generative grammar and Chomsky’s debt to Emil Post. Historiographia Linguistica

DO, Youngah & Shannon MOONEY

2022. Variation awaiting bias: Substantively biased learning of vowel harmony variation. Journal of Child Language 49:2 ► pp. 397 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. The generativist non-dominance of the field in the 1970s and 1980s. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 298 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. The members of the LSA Nominating Committee in the 1970s and 1980s. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 326 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. Martin Joos’sReadings in Linguisticsas the apogee of American structuralism. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 80 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. The contested LSA presidential election of 1970. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 261 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. The European reception of early transformational generative grammar. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 216 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. The diffusion of generativist ideas. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 183 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. Early transformational generative grammar. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 127 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. American structuralism and European structuralism. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 43 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. American Linguistics in Transition,

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. Grant recipients in American linguistics in the 1970s and 1980s. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 335 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. The members of the LSA Executive Committee in the 1970s and 1980s. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 324 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. The members of the LSA Program Committee in the 1970s and the 1980s. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 333 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. The structuralist ascendancy in American linguistics. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 1 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. Charles Hockett’s attempt to resign from the LSA in 1982. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 282 ff.

Newmeyer, Frederick J.

2022. Associate Editors of and example articles inLanguagein the 1970s and 1980s. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 328 ff.

Stanlaw, James

2020. Harris, Zellig. In The International Encyclopedia of Linguistic Anthropology, ► pp. 1 ff.

Graffi, Giorgio

2016. Harris, Chomsky and the origins of transformational grammar. Lingvisticae Investigationes 39:1 ► pp. 48 ff.

[no author supplied]

2022. Afterword. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. 358 ff.

[no author supplied]

2022. Foreword. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. xi ff.

[no author supplied]

2022. Copyright Page. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. iv ff.

[no author supplied]

2022. Timeline. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. xvi ff.

[no author supplied]

2022. List of Abbreviations. In American Linguistics in Transition, ► pp. xv ff.

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 24 november 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.