Article In: Writing/Reading Interface
Edited by Terry Joyce and Constanze Weth
[Written Language & Literacy 28:1] 2025
► pp. 44–84
Heterophonic homography in African and Semitic languages
Comparing the functions of tones and vowels
This content is being prepared for publication; it may be subject to changes.
Abstract
Bird (Bird, Steven%. (1999a). Strategies
for representing tone in African writing systems. Written Language and
Literacy 2:1.1–44. , . (1999b). When
marking tone reduces fluency: An orthography experiment in Cameroon. Language and
Speech 421.83–115. ) was one
of the first linguists to draw attention to the similarities between the newly emerging Roman script orthographies of African
languages, where tone is often under-represented, and Semitic orthographies, where most vowels are typically under-represented.
This paper demonstrates that it is not only the orthographies but the linguistic functions of tone in African languages and vowels
in both Modern Hebrew and Modern Standard Arabic that are similar; not just at a general level but also in their details. In
seeking to illustrate the similarities between a wide range of African languages and the two Semitic language, the paper
catalogues pairs of heterophonic homographs as being either lexical (Section 3.1) or
grammatical (Section 3.2) in nature, as well as cases of interaction (Section 3.3). The paper also acknowledges a number of lexical tone distinctions among African languages that
have no parallels in the vowel structures of Hebrew and Arabic (Section 4). Given the
striking similarities in how the linguistic functions of African tone and Semitic vowels are represented (or not) in the different
writing systems, any researchers concerned with developing orthographies for previously unwritten tone languages, such as those in
Africa, would do well to heed the extensive literature on Hebrew and Arabic literacy acquisition and to identify what lessons can
be extracted when developing tone orthographies.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 1.1Aims and motivation
- 1.2Diacritics in African and Semitic orthographies
- 1.3Parallels between African and Semitic languages
- 2.Methodology
- 2.1Data collection
- 2.2Data presentation and transcription
- 3.Similarities between heterophonic homography in African and Semitic languages
- 3.1Lexical pairs
- 3.1.1Same-category pairs
- 3.1.2Cross-category pairs
- 3.2Grammatical pairs
- 3.2.1Person
- 3.2.2Number
- 3.2.3Gender
- 3.2.4Determiners
- 3.2.5Adpositions
- 3.2.6Voice
- 3.2.7Transitivity
- 3.2.8TAM categories
- 3.2.9Derivations
- 3.2.9.1Nominalisations
- 3.2.9.2Agentives
- 3.2.9.3Causatives
- 3.2.9.4Intensives
- 3.2.9.5Inchoatives
- 3.2.9.6Gerunds
- 3.3Interactions between lexical and grammatical functions
- 3.1Lexical pairs
- 4.Dissimilarities between African and Semitic heterophonic homography
- 4.1Case
- 4.2Demonstratives
- 4.3Negation
- 4.4Focus
- 4.5Relative clauses
- 4.6Copula verb phrases vs genitive noun phrases
- 4.7Predicate nominals
- 4.8Derivations
- 4.8.1Singulatives
- 4.8.2Augmentatives
- 4.8.3Prepositions
- 5.Discussion
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
- Abbreviations
- Author queries
References
References (123)
Abu-Rabia, Salim%. (1996). The
role of vowels and context in reading of highly skilled native Arabic speakers. Journal of
Psycholinguistic
Research 251.629–2641.
. (2001). The
role of vowels in reading Semitic scripts: Data from Arabic and Hebrew. Reading and Writing: An
Interdisciplinary
Journal 141.39–59.
Adinyah, John Bequen%. (2012). Grammatical and lexical tone
variations in Nawuri. Paper presented at the Institute of African Studies
and GILLBT Conference, Tamale, Ghana.
Agabi, Nathan%. (2019). The
functional load of tone in Wapan Jukun
language. Bukuru: Theological College of Northern Nigeria. BA thesis.
Ahland, Michael%. (2016). The
development of finite verbs from nominalized structures in Northern
Mao. In (eds) Doris L. Payne, Sara Pacchiarotti & Mokaya Bosire, Diversity
in African
languages, 467–492. Berlin: Language Science Press.
Ameka, Felix K. (1991). Ewe: Its grammatical constructions
and illocutionary devices. Canberra: Australian National University. Unpublished PhD dissertation.
Anonymous (1994). Kpéé ráŋã dĩ grö’dõ ádá
ká lëmë gbäyä (Learning to reading in Kresh: Book
1). Juba: SIL South Sudan.
Bar-On, Amalia%. (2015). Reading
in the shadow of homography: The problem is the solution [Translation of Hebrew
title]. Oriyanut
VeSafa 51.99–120.
Bar-On, Amalia, Elitzur Dattner & Dorit Ravid. (2017). Context
effects on heterophonic-homography resolution in learning to reading Hebrew. Reading &
writing 301.463–487.
Bar-on, Amalia & Victor Kuperman. (2019). Spelling
errors respect morphology: A corpus study of Hebrew orthography. Reading &
writing 321.1107–1128.
Bar-On, Amalia, Tal Oron & Orna Peleg. (2021). Semantic
and syntactic constraints in resolving homography: A developmental study in Hebrew. Reading
& writing 341.2103–2126.
Beerle-Moor, Marianne & Vitaly Voinov (eds) (2015). Language
vitality through Bible translation (Berkeley Insights in Linguistics and Semiotics
95). New York: Peter Lang.
Berent, Iris & Joseph Shimron. (1997). The
representation of Hebrew words: Evidence from the obligatory contour
principle. Cognition 641.39–72.
Berman, Ruth A. (2012). Revisiting roots in Hebrew: A
multi-faceted view. In (eds) Malka Muchnik & Tsani Sadan, Studies
on modern Hebrew and Jewish languages in honor of Ora (Rodriguez) Schwarzwald [English translation of Hebrew
title], 132–158. Jerusalem: Carmel.
Bird, Steven%. (1999a). Strategies
for representing tone in African writing systems. Written Language and
Literacy 2:1.1–44.
. (1999b). When
marking tone reduces fluency: An orthography experiment in Cameroon. Language and
Speech 421.83–115.
Cahill, Michael%. (2021). Marking
grammatical tone in orthographies: Issues and
challenges. In (eds) Akinbiyi Akinlabi, Lee Bickmore, Michael Cahill, Michael Diercks, Laura J. Downing, James Essegbey, Katie Franich, Laura McPherson & Sharon Rose, Celebrating
50 years of ACAL: Selected papers from the 50th Annual Conference on African
Linguistics, 23–34. Berlin: Language Science Press.
Clements, George N. & John A. Goldsmith. (1984). Autosegmental
studies in Bantu tone. Dordecht, Netherlands and Cinnaminson NJ: Foris.
Connell, Bruce A., Richard J. Hayward & John Abraha Ashkaba. (2000). Observations
on Kunama tone. Studies in African
Linguistics 29:1.1–42.
Dosman, Obede%. (2022). Búkũ
Lị̃fị́ îcî ‘bá pã kâ: Í’dígówá zị̃zị̃ íyî drị̃ sĩ (Avokaya Primer part 2: Teacher’s guide, 3rd
edition). Juba: SIL South Sudan and Avokaya Language Committee.
. (2018). Coordination
and Subordination in Sandawe Clauses. SIL Electronic Working Papers
2018-001. Dallas: SIL International.
Essien, Udo E. (1977). To end ambiguity in a tone
language. In (eds) Paul F. A. Kotey & Haig Der-Houssikian, Languages
and linguistics problems in Africa. Proceedings of the 7th conference on African
linguistics, 155–167. Columbia, South Carolina: Hornbeam Press.
Frost, Ram%. (1994). Prelexical
and postlexical strategies in reading: Evidence from a deep and a shallow orthography. Journal
of Experimental Pschology: Learning, Memory and
Cognition 201.116–129.
Frost, Ram & S. Bentin. (1992). Reading
consonants and guessing vowels: Visual word recognition in Hebrew
orthography. In (eds) Ram Frost & Leonard Katz, Orthography,
phonology, morphology and
meaning, 27–44. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Gblem-Poidi, Honorine%. (1995). Description
systématique de l’igo, langue du sud-oeust du
Togo. Grenoble: Université Stendhal, Grenoble III. Thèse de doctorat.
Goldsmith, John%. (1976). Autosegmental
and metrical phonology: MIT. PhD
dissertation. Published by
Blackwell, Oxford 1990.
Gonzales, Ashleigh%. (2009). Intrinsic
F0 in Shona vowels: A descriptive
study. In (eds) Akinloye Ojo & Lioba Moshi, Selected
proceedings of the 39th Annual Conference on African
Linguistics, 145–155. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.
Grainger, Jonathan, Maryline Nguyen van Kang & Juan Segui. (2001). Cross-modal
repetition priming of heterographic homophones. Memory &
Cognition 29:1.53–61.
Güldemann, Tom%. (2014). ‘Khoisan’
linguistic classification today. In (eds) Tom Güldemann & Anne-Maria Fehn, Beyond
‘Khoisan.’ Historical relations in the Kalahari Basin [Current issues in linguistic theory
330], 1–41. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Harley, Matthew (ms). Notes
on the E̱da grammar (ed.) SIL-Nigeria.
Harry, Otelemate & Larry Hyman. (2014). Phrasal
construction tonology: the case of Kalabari. Studies in
Language 38:4.649–689.
Hayward, Richard J. (2000). Afroasiatic. In (eds) Bernd Heine & Derek Nurse, African
languages: An
introduction, 74–98. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
. (2014). Grammar
of Humburi Senni (Songhay of Hombori, Mali). Language Description Heritage
Library. Leipzig: Max-Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology.
. (2017). A
grammar of Jalkunan (Mande, Burkina Faso): Language Description Heritage Library (online). Ann Arbor MI: University of Michigan.
Heine, Bernd & Henry Honken. (2010). The
Kx’a family: A new Khoisan genealogy. Journal of Asian and African
Studies 791.5–36.
Hoberman, Robert D. (1988). Local and long-distance
spreading in Semitic morphology. Natural Language & Linguistic
Theory 6:4.541–549.
Hunziker, Daniel A., Elisabeth Hunziker & Helen Eaton (ms). A
description of the phonology of the Sandawe language. SIL International.
Hyman, Larry%. (2001). Privative
tone in Bantu. In (ed.) Shigeki Kaji, Cross-linguistic
studies of tonal
phenomena, 237–257. Tokyo: Institute for the Study of Languages and Cultures.
. (2007). Tone:
Is it different? UC Berkeley Phonology Lab Annual
Report 3:3.483–528. Later
published as Hyman, L. (2011). Tone:
Is it different? In J. Goldsmith, J. Riggle, & A. Yu (Eds.), The
Handbook of Phonological Theory, 2nd
edition (pp. 197–239). Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
. (2009). How
(not) to do phonological typology: The case of pitch-accent. Language
Sciences 311.213–238.
. (2013). Issues
in the phonology-morphology interface in African
languages. In (eds) Olanike Ola Orie & Karen W. Sanders, Selected Proceedings
of the 43rd Annual Conference on African
Linguistics, 16–25. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.
Hyman, Larry & Charles Kisseberth (eds) (1998). Theoretical
aspects of Bantu tone. Stanford: Center for the Study of Language and Information.
Hyman, Larry & William R. Leben. (2008). Suprasegmental
processes, Morphologie: Ein Internationales Handbuch zur Flexion und
Wortbildung, 11, 587–594. The Hague: Mouton.
. (2017). Word
prosody II: Tone systems. UC Berkeley Phonology Lab Annual
Report 13:1.178–209. Later
published as Hyman, L., & Leben, W. R. (2021). Word
Prosody II: Tone systems. In C. Gussenhoven & A. Chen (Eds.), Oxford
handbook of language
prosody p. 45–65. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
ILA (1979). Une orthographe pratique des
langues ivoiriennes. Abidjan: Institut de Linguistique Appliquée, Université d’Abidjan.
Jenewari, Charles E. W. (1977). Studies in Kalabari
syntax. Ibadan: University of Ibadan. Doctoral dissertation.
(1985). Kalaḅarị
orthography. In (ed.) A. Banjo, Orthographies
of Nigerian languages: Manual
III, 83–107. Lagos: National Language Center, Federal Ministry of Education (Nigeria).
Jungraithmayr, Herrmann & Philibus Diyakal. (2013). Mushere,
a Chadic language of five level tones. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen
Gesellschaft 163:2.297–307.
Katz, Leonard & Ram Frost. (1992). The
reading process is different for different orthographies: The orthographic depth
hypothesis. In (eds) Leonard Katz & Ram Frost, Orthography,
Phonology, Morphology and
Meaning, 67–84. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers. Also appears in Haskins Laboratories Status Report on Speech
Research, 111–112, pages 147–160.
Koffi, Ettien%. (1994). The
representation of tones in the orthography. Notes on
Literacy 20:3.51–59.
Konoshenko, Maria%. (2017). Tone
in grammar: What we already know and what we still don’t. Voprosy
Jazykoznanija 41.101–114.
Kordow, H. Moubashir%. (2007). Tem Ŋmáádɩ Kpɛlɛḿ
tákárɩɖá sɩ́ɩ́lɛ́ ńgɩ: Apprendre l’écriture en Tem — lettres Romains et
Arabes. Sokodé: Publisher unspecified.
Kutsch Lojenga, Constance%. (1986). Some
experiences in writing and teaching tone in Africa. Notes on
Literacy Special
issue 11.59–65.
. (2014). Orthography
and tone: A tone system typology with implications for orthography
development. In (eds) Michael Cahill & Keren Rice, Developing
orthographies for unwritten
languages, 49–72. Dallas: SIL International.
. (2015). La
fonction du ton (Handout sur le ton grammatical utilisé au séminaire sur l’orthographe du ton des langues centrafricaines, du
5 au 23 janvier 2015 à Yaoundé au
Cameroun). (ed.) SIL-International.
Laks, L. (2018). Verb
innovation in Hebrew and Palestinian Arabic: The interaction of morpho-phonological and thematic-semantic
criteria. Brill’s Annual Afroasiatic Languages and
Linguistics 10:2.238–284.
Laks, L. & E. Saiegh-Haddad. (2022). Variety
and modality distinctions in language use in Arabic
diglossia. In (eds) E. Saiegh-Haddad, L. Laks & C. McBride, Handbook
of literacy in diglossia and dialectal contexts: Psycholinguistic, neurolinguistic and educational
perspectives, 247–271. Cham: Springer Nature.
Laks, Lior, Ibrahim Hamad & Elinor Saiegh-Haddad. (2019). Verbal
patterns in Palestinian Arabic. The Mental
Lexicon 14:2.209–236.
Levie, R., O. Ashkenazi, S. Eitan Stanzas, R. Zwilling, E. Raz, L. Hershkovitz & D. Ravid. (2020). The
route to the derivational verb family in Hebrew: A psycholinguistic study of acquisition and
development. Morphology 301.1–60.
Malgwi, Yunana Inuwa%. (2018). A critical analysis of the Bura
sound system by a mother tongue
speaker. Bukuru: Theological College of Northern Nigeria. BA thesis.
Markus, Shiri%. (2021). Morpho-syntactic
features of Hebrew heterophonic-homographic words [in
Hebrew]. Tel-Aviv: University of Tel-Aviv. Unpublished Masters thesis.
McCarthy, John J. (1979). Formal problems in Semitic phonology
and morphology. Cambridge, MA: MIT. PhD
dissertation. Distributed by Indiana University Linguistics Club. Published
by Garland Press, New York NY, 1985.
Meier, Ingeborg%. (1983). Making
tone markings acceptable and easy: a lesson for literacy from linguistics. Notes on
Linguistics: 271.4–8.
Mfonyam, Joseph Ngwa%. (1996). Reading and writing tone
in African languages. In (ed.) Emmanuel Nges Chia, Guide to readability in African
languages Linguistics
edition, 111. München: Lincom Europa.
Miller-Naudé, Cynthia, Jacobus Naudé, Tanya Beelders & Luna Bergh. (2017). Visual
grammar: An eye-tracking perspective on cognitive complexity in Biblical Hebrew
pronunciation. In (eds) Frederick Greenspahn & Gary Rendsburg, Le-ma’an
Ziony: Essays in honor of Ziony
Zevit, 316–344. Eugene, OR: Cascade.
Mumin, Meikal%. (2014). The
Arabic script in Africa : Understudied
literacy. In (eds) Meikal Mumin & Kees Versteegh, The
Arabic script in Africa: Studies in the use of a writing
system, 41–78. Leiden: Brill.
Navon, David & Joseph Shimron. (1984). Reading
Hebrew: How necessary is the phonemic representation of
vowels? In (ed.) Leslie Henderson, Orthographies
and Reading. Hillsdale, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Newman, Paul%. (2000). The
Hausa language: An encyclopedic reference grammar. New Haven & London: Yale University Press.
. (2022). A
history of the Hausa language: Reconstruction and pathways to the
present. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ngukas, Gabriel Micah%. (2022a). Deixis of Mushere language: A
property of tone and vowel length? Paper presented at the Jos Linguistics
Circle, Jos.
. (2022b). An evaluation of tone in
Mushere language. Bukuru: Theological College of Northern Nigeria. MA thesis.
Nilsson, Morgan%. (2018). Grammatical
gender and number in Somali nouns. In (ed.) Martin Orwin, Papers
from the linguistics workshop: Somali language and literature at the Haraeysa Cultural Centre, December
2015, 27–51. Hargeysa: REDSEA Cultural Foundation.
Nkuruna, John, Jeremiah Liaram & Peter Sentero. (2013). Nánú
opény! [All by myself!]. Nairobi: Women Educational Researchers of Kenya.
Norton, Russell%. (2012). Non-concatenative
morphology in Dinka and Arabic: Augmentation and
replacement. In (eds) Matthias Brenzinger & Anne-Maria Fehn, Proceedings
of the 6th World Congress of African Linguistics, Cologne 17–21 August
2009, 169–179. Cologne: Rüdiger Köppe.
. (2020). Ama
verbs in comparative perspective. Dotawo: A Journal of Nubian
Studies 71: Comparative Northern East Sudanic Linguistics.
xx-xx.
Norton, Russell (ms). Cam
tone findings summary (October 2007 discourse
workshop) (ed.) SIL-Sudan. Juba.
Odden, David%. (1981). Problems
in tone assignment in Shona. Urbana-Champaign IL: University of Illinois. Doctoral
dissertation.
. (1995). Tone
in African languages. In (ed.) John Goldsmith, The
handbook of phonological
theory, 444–475. Oxford: Blackwell.
. (2019). Tone. In (eds) Mark Van de Velde & Koen Bostoen, The
Bantu Languages, 2nd
edition. London: Routledge.
. (2020). Tone. In (eds) Rainer Vossen & Gerrit Dimmendaal, The
Oxford handbook of African
languages, 30–47. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pasch, Helma%. (2008). Competing
scripts: the introduction of the Roman alphabet in Africa. International Journal of the
Sociology of Language: special issue on script and
orthography 1911.65–109.
Perfetti, Charles A. & Lesley Hart. (2001). The
lexical basis of comprehension
skill. In (ed.) David S. Gorfein, On the consequences of meaning
selection: Perspectives on resolving lexical ambiguity. Washington DC: American Psychological Association.
Porkhomovsky, Victor%. (2021). Afro-Asiatic
overview. In (eds) Rainer Vossen & Gerrit Dimmendaal, Oxford
handbook of African
languages, 269—274. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Rappaport, Malka%. (1984). Issues
in the phonology of Tiberian Hebrew. Cambridge, MA: MIT. PhD
dissertation.
Ravid, Dorit%. (2005). Hebrew
orthography and literacy. In (eds) R. M. Joshi & P. G. Aaron, Handbook
of orthography and literacy, 339–363. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
. (2020). Derivation. In (ed.) R. A. Berman, Usage-based
studies in modern Hebrew: Background, morpho-lexicon and
syntax, 203–263. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Ravid, Dorit & Sarit Haimowitz. (2006). The
vowel path: Learning about vowel representation in written Hebrew. Written Language &
Literacy 9:1.67–93.
Ravid, Dorit & Rachel Schiff. (2004). Learning
to represent vowels in written Hebrew: Different factors across development. First
Language 24:2.185–208.
Ravid, Dorit & Lizzy Vered. (2017). Hebrew
verbal passives in later language development: The interface of register and verb
morphology. Journal of Child
Language 44:6.1309–1336.
Revell, Ernest John%. (1975). The diacritical dots and
the development of the Arabic alphabet. Journal of Semitic
Studies 20:2.178–190.
Roberts, David%. (2015a). Laying
a foundation for tone orthography research and decision-making: the Kabiye homograph
corpus. Scripta 71.151–189.
. (2015b). Vers
une orthographe appropriée pour le kabba: rapport de fin de séminaire sur l’orthographe du ton des langues centrafricaines, à
Yaoundé au Cameroun, du 5 au 23 janvier 2015. Yaoundé, Cameroun: SIL.
. (2023). Roman
script orthography development in Africa: Historical and contemporary
perspectives. In (eds) R. Malatesha Joshi, Catherine A. McBride, Bestern Kaani & Gad Elbeheri, Handbook
of literacy in Africa, 59–78. New York: Springer Nature.
Roberts, David (forthcoming). Multilinear
featurality in Roman script African
orthographies. In (ed.) Heather Winskel, Handbook
of Non-linear writing
systems. Cham: Springer.
Roberts, David, Ginger Boyd, Johannes Merz & Valentin Vydrin. (2020). Quantifying
written ambiguities in tone languages: A comparative study of Elip, Mbelime and Eastern
Dan. Language Documentation and
Conservation 141.108–138.
Saiegh-Haddad, Elinor%. (2018). MAWRID:
A model of Arabic word reading in development. Journal of Reading
Disabilities 51:5.454–462.
Saiegh-Haddad, Elinor & Roni Henkin-Roitfarb. (2014). The
structure of Arabic language and
orthography. In (eds) Elinor Saiegh-Haddad & R. Malatesha Joshi, Handbook of
Arabic
literacy, 3–28. Dordecht: Springer.
Saiegh-Haddad, Elinor & Rachel Schiff. (2016). The
impact of diglossia on voweled and unvoweled word reading in Arabic: A developmental study from childhood to
adolescence. Scientific Studies of
Reading 20:4.311–324.
Sandjougouma, Yoro Issacar & David Roberts. (2021). Vers
une orthographe appropriée du ton pour le
waama. Kara: SIL Togo-Bénin.
Shigeaki, Amano, Kondo Tadahisa & Kakehi Kazuhik. (1995). Modality
dependency of familiarity ratings of Japanese words. Perception &
Psychophysics 57:5.598–603.
Shimron, Joseph & T. Sivan. (1994). Reading
proficiency and orthography: Evidence from Hebrew and English. Language
Learning 441.5–27.
Shrem, Karni%. (2021). Frequency
characteristics of heterophonic-homographic Hebrew
words. Tel-Aviv: University of Tel-Aviv. Unpublished masters thesis.
SIL (in press). À zɛ nɩ́wɔlɩ: Un
guide de transition pour les adultes scolarisés. Sassandra and Abidjan: SIL Côte d’Ivoire.
. (2021). Floating
tone noun class prefixes in Mada (Nigeria). Linguistique et Langues
Africaines 71.11–41.
Stegen, Oliver%. (2005). Tone
in Eastern Bantu orthographies. Paper presented at the SIL Bantu
orthography meeting, Dallas.
Veiga, Arlindo, Sara Candeias & Fernando Perdigão. (2013). Generating
a pronunciation dictionary for European Portuguese using a joint-sequence model with embedded stress
assignment. Journal of the Brazilian Computer
Society 191.127–134.
Warren-Rothlin, Andy%. (2012). Arabic
script in modern Nigeria. In (eds) Roger Blench & McGill Stuart, Advances
in Minority Language Research in Nigeria Vol. 1. Kay Williamson Educational Foundation African languages monographs
5, 105–21. Cologne: Rüdiger Köppe.
