Article published In: Sign Language & Linguistics
Vol. 19:1 (2016) ► pp.37–81
Taking meaning in hand
Iconic motivations in two-handed signs
Published online: 15 September 2016
https://doi.org/10.1075/sll.19.1.02lep
https://doi.org/10.1075/sll.19.1.02lep
Traditionally in sign language research, the issue of whether a lexical sign is articulated with one hand or two has been treated as a strictly phonological matter. We argue that accounting for two-handed signs also requires considering meaning as a motivating factor. We report results from a Swadesh list comparison, an analysis of semantic patterns among two-handed signs, and a picture-naming task. Comparing four unrelated languages, we demonstrate that the two hands are recruited to encode various relationship types in sign language lexicons. We develop the general principle that inherently “plural” concepts are straightforwardly mapped onto our paired human hands, resulting in systematic use of the two hands across sign languages. In our analysis, “plurality” subsumes four primary relationship types — interaction, location, dimension, and composition — and we predict that signs with meanings that encompass these relationships — such as ‘meet’, ‘empty’, ‘large’, or ‘machine’ — will preferentially be two-handed in any sign language.
References (116)
Ahlgren, Inger & Brita Bergman. 2006. Det svenska teckenspråket. Teckenspråk och teckenspråkiga: Kunskaps- och forskningsöversikt (SOU 2006:291), 11–70. Statens offentliga utredningar.
Al-Fityani, Kinda & Carol Padden. 2010. Sign languages in the Arab world. In Diane Brentari (ed.), Sign languages: A Cambridge language survey, 433–450. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Aronoff, Mark, Irit Meir, Carol Padden & Wendy Sandler. 2008. The roots of linguistic organization in a new language. Interaction Studies 9(1). 133–153. .
Aronoff, Mark, Irit Meir & Wendy Sandler. 2005. The paradox of sign language morphology. Language 811. 301–344.
Battison, Robbin. 1978. Lexical borrowing in American Sign Language. Silver Spring, MD: Linstok Press.
Benedicto, Elena & Diane Brentari. 2004. Where did all the arguments go?: Argument-changing properties of classifiers in ASL. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 22(4). 743–810.
. 1982a. Teckenspråkstranskription (Forskning om teckenspråk X). Stockholm: Department of Linguistics, Stockholm University.
. 1982b. Sign typology (Forskning om teckenspråk XI). Stockholm: Department of Linguistics, Stockholm University.
. 1983. Verbs and adjectives: Morphological processes in Swedish Sign Language. In Jim Kyle & Bencie Woll (eds.), Language in sign: An international perspective on sign language, 3–9. London: Croom Helm.
Bergman, Brita & Elisabeth Engberg-Pedersen. 2010. Transmission of sign languages in the Nordic countries. In Diane Brentari (ed.), Sign languages: A Cambridge language survey, 74–94. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Bergman, Brita & Johanna Mesch. 2004. ECHO data set for Swedish Sign Language (SSL). Department of Linguistics, Stockholm University.
Björkstrand, Thomas. 2016. Swedish Sign Language dictionary online. Stockholm: Sign Language Section, Department of Linguistics, Stockholm University. teckensprakslexikon.su.se.
Blevins, James P., Farrell Ackerman & Robert Malouf. 2016. Morphology as an adaptive discriminative system. In Heidi Harley & Daniel Siddiqi (eds.), Morphological metatheory, 271–302. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Brentari, Diane & John A. Goldsmith. 1993. Secondary licensing and the nondominant hand in ASL phonology. In Geoffrey R. Coulter (ed.), Current issues in ASL phonology: Phonetics and phonology 31, 19–41. New York, NY & San Francisco, CA: Academic Press.
Bybee, Joan L., Revere Perkins & William Pagliuca. 1994. The evolution of grammar: Tense, aspect, and modality in the languages of the world. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Crasborn, Onno. 2011. The other hand in sign language phonology. In Marc van Oostendorp, Colin J. Ewen, Elizabeth Hume & Keren Rice (eds.), The Blackwell companion to phonology, Vol. 11, 223–240. Malden, MA & Oxford: Blackwell.
Crasborn, Onno, Johanna Mesch, Dafydd Waters, Els van der Kooij, Bencie Woll & Brita Bergman. 2007. Sharing sign language data online. Experiences from the ECHO project. International Journal of Corpus Linguistics 12(4). 535–562.
Delbrück, Berthold. 1893. Vergleichende Syntax der Indogermanischen Sprachen: Erster Teil. Strassburg: Trübner.
Dingemanse, Mark. 2012. Advances in the cross-linguistic study of ideophones. Linguistics and Language Compass 6(10). 654–672. .
Emmorey, Karen. 2002. Language, cognition, and the brain: Insights from sign language research. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
(ed.). 2003. Perspectives on classifier constructions in sign languages. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
. 2014. Iconicity as structure mapping. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 369(1651).
Fischer, Susan D. 1973. Two processes of reduplication in the American Sign Language. Foundations of Language 91. 469–480.
Friedman, Lynn A. 1977. On the other hand: New perspectives on American Sign Language. New York, NY: Academic Press.
Frishberg, Nancy. 1975. Arbitrariness and iconicity: Historical change in American Sign Language. Language 51(3). 696–719.
Guerra Currie, Anne-Marie P., Richard P. Meier & Keith Walters. 2002. A crosslinguistic examination of the lexicons of four signed languages. In Richard P. Meier, Kearsy Cormier & David Quinto-Pozos (eds.), Modality and structure in signed and spoken language, 224–237. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hay, Jennifer B. & R. Harald Baayen. 2005. Shifting paradigms: Gradient structure in morphology. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 9(7). 342–348. .
Hopper, Paul J. & Sandra A. Thompson. 1980. Transitivity in grammar and discourse. Language 56(2). 251–299.
Johnston, Trevor & Adam Schembri. 1999. On defining lexeme in a signed language. Sign Language & Linguistics 2(2). 115–185.
Kastner, Itamar, Irit Meir, Wendy Sandler & Svetlana Dachkovsky. 2014. The emergence of embedded structure: Insights from Kafr Qasem Sign Language. Frontiers in Psychology 5(525). 1–15.
Kisch, Shifra. 2008. “Deaf discourse”: The social construction of deafness in a Bedouin community. Medical Anthropology 27(3). 283–313.
. 2012. Demarcating generations of signers in the dynamic sociolinguistic landscape of a shared sign language: The case of the Al-Sayyid Bedouin. In Ulrike Zeshan & Connie de Vos (eds.), Sign languages in village communitites: Anthropological and linguistic insights, 87–126. Berlin & Nijmegen: Mouton de Gruyter & Ishara Press.
Klima, Edward S. & Ursula Bellugi. 1979. The signs of language. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Kooij, Els van der. 2002. Phonological categories in Sign Language of the Netherlands: The role of phonetic implementation and iconicity. Amsterdam: University of Amsterdam PhD dissertation. Utrecht: LOT.
Koptjevskaja-Tamm, Maria & Bernhard Wälchli. 2001. The Circum-Baltic languages. In Östen Dahl & Maria Koptjevskaja-Tamm (eds.), Circum-Baltic languages. Volume 2: Grammar and typology, vol. 551, 615–750. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Kyle, Jim G. & Bencie Woll (eds.). 1985. Sign language: The study of deaf people and their language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lepic, Ryan. 2015. Motivation in morphology: Lexical patterns in ASL and English. San Diego, CA: University of California PhD dissertation. (Retrieved from [URL]).
Liddell, Scott K & Robert E. Johnson. 1989. American Sign Language: The phonological base. Sign Language Studies 641. 195–278.
Liddell, Scott K. 2003. Grammar, gesture, and meaning in American Sign Language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Meir, Irit. 2002. A cross-modality perspective on verb agreement. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 201. 413–450.
. 2010. Iconicity and metaphor: Constraints on metaphorical extension of iconic forms. Language 86(4). 865–896.
Meir, Irit, Mark Aronoff, Wendy Sandler & Carol Padden. 2004. Sign languages and compounding. In Sergio Scalise & Irene Vogel (eds.), Cross-disciplinary issues in compounding, 301–322. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Meir, Irit, Assaf Israel, Wendy Sandler, Carol Padden & Mark Aronoff. 2012. The influence of community size on language structure. Linguistic Variation 12(2). 247–291.
Meir, Irit, Carol Padden, Mark Aronoff & Wendy Sandler. 2013. Competing iconicities in the structure of languages. Cognitive Linguistics 24(2). 309–343.
Meir, Irit & Wendy Sandler. 2008. A language in space: The story of Israeli Sign Language. New York, NY & London: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Meir, Irit, Wendy Sandler, Carol A. Padden & Mark Aronoff (eds.). 2012. Al-Sayyid Bedouin Sign Language: A dictionary. Haifa & San Diego, CA: Sign Language Research Lab, University of Haifa & Center for Research in Language, UCSD.
Meir, Irit, Wendy Sandler, Carol Padden & Mark Aronoff. 2010. Emerging sign languages. In Mark Marschark & Patricia E. Spencer (eds.), The Oxford handbook of deaf studies, language and education, 267–280. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Napoli, Donna Jo & Jeff Wu. 2003. Morpheme structure constraints on two-handed signs in American Sign Language. Sign Language & Linguistics 6(2). 123–205.
Nespor, Marina & Wendy Sandler. 1999. Prosody in Israeli Sign Language. Language and Speech 42(2-3). 143–176.
Nilsson, Anna-Lena. 2007. The non-dominant hand in a Swedish Sign Language discourse. In Myriam Vermeerbergen, Lorraine Leeson & Onno Crasborn (eds.), Simultaneity in signed languages: Form and function, 163–185. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
OED. 2013. Oxford English dictionary online. Oxford University Press. [URL] (8 October, 2013).
Özyürek, Aslı, Inge Zwitserlood & Pamela Perniss. 2010. Locative expressions in signed languages: A view from Turkish Sign Language (TİD). Linguistics 48(5). 1111–1145.
Padden, Carol. 1988. Interaction of morphology and syntax in American Sign Language. New York, NY & London: Garland Publishing, Inc.
Padden, Carol, So-One Hwang, Ryan Lepic & Sharon Seegers. 2015. Tools for language: Patterned iconicity in sign language nouns and verbs. Topics in Cognitive Science 71. 81–94.
Padden, Carol, Irit Meir, So-One Hwang, Ryan Lepic, Sharon Seegers & Tory Sampson. 2013. Patterned iconicity in sign language lexicons. Gesture 13(3). 181–202.
Padden, Carol, Irit Meir, Wendy Sandler & Mark Aronoff. 2010. Against all expectations: Encoding subjects and objects in a new language. In Donna Gerdts, John Moore & Maria Polinsky (eds.), Hypothesis A/hypothesis B: Linguistic explorations in honor of David M. Perlmutter, 383–400. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Padden, Carol & David M. Perlmutter. 1987. American Sign Language and the architecture of phonological theory. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 51. 335–375.
Perniss, Pamela, Robin L. Thompson & Gabriella Vigliocco. 2010. Iconicity as a general property of language: Evidence from spoken and signed languages. Frontiers in Psychology 11 (December 2010). 227.
Pfau, Roland & Enoch O. Aboh. 2012. On the syntax of spatial adpositions in sign languages. In Evan Cohen (ed.), Proceedings of IATL 27 (MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 65), 83–104. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Pfau, Roland & Markus Steinbach. 2006. Pluralization in sign and in speech: A cross-modal typological study. Linguistic Typology 10(2). 135–182.
Pizzuto, Elena & Serena Corazza. 1996. Noun morphology in Italian Sign Language (LIS). Lingua 98(1). 169–196.
Prillwitz, Siegmund, Regina Leven, Heiko Zienert, Thomas Hanke & Jan Henning. 1989. HamNoSys: Version 2.0. Hamburg: Signum Verlag.
Rosch, Eleanor. 1978. Principles of categorization. In Eleanor Rosch & Barbara B. Lloyd (eds.), Cognition and categorization, 27–48. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Sandler, Wendy. 1989. Phonological representation of the sign: Linearity and nonlinearity in sign language phonology. Dordrecht: Foris.
. 1993. Hand in hand: The roles of the nondominant hand in sign language phonology. The Linguistic Review 101. 337–390.
. 1995. Markedness in the handshapes of sign language: A componential analysis. In Jeroen van der Weijer & Harry van der Hulst (eds.), Leiden in last: Holland Institute of Linguistics phonology papers, 369–399. The Hague: Holland Academie Graphics.
. 1999a. Cliticization and prosodic words in a sign language. In Tracy Hall & Ursula Kleinhenz (eds.), Studies on the phonological word, 223–255. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 2006. Phonology, phonetics, and the nondominant hand. In Louis Goldstein, D.H. Whalen & Catherine Best (eds.), Papers in laboratory phonology: Varieties of phonological competence, 185–212. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
. 2012. The phonological organization of sign languages. Language and Linguistics Compass 6(3). 162–182.
Sandler, Wendy, Mark Aronoff, Irit Meir & Carol Padden. 2011. The gradual emergence of phonological form in a new language. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 29(2). 503–543.
Sandler, Wendy, Mark Aronoff, Carol Padden & Irit Meir. 2014. Language emergence: Al-Sayyid Bedouin Sign Language. In Nick Enfield, Paul Kockelman & Jack Sidnell (eds.), Cambridge handbook of linguistic anthropology, 250–284. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sandler, Wendy & Diane Lillo-Martin. 2006. Sign language and linguistic universals. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sandler, Wendy, Irit Meir, Carol Padden & Mark Aronoff. 2005. The emergence of grammar: Systematic structure in a new language. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 102(7). 2661–2665.
Saussure, Ferdinand de. 1959. Course in general linguistics. Translated, with an introduction and notes by Wade Baskin. (ed.) Charles Bally & Albert Sechehaye. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Savir, Hava. 1992. Gateway to Israeli Sign Language (First Version). Tel Aviv: The Association of the Deaf in Israel.
Schlenker, Philippe, Jonathan Lamberton & Mirko Santoro. 2013. Iconic variables. Linguistics & Philosophy 36(2). 91–149.
Scott, Daryl A., Rivka Carmi, Khalil Eldebour, Geoffrey M. Duyk, Edwin M. Stone & Val Sheffield. 1995. Nonsyndromic autosomal recessive deafness is linked to the DFNB1 locus in a large inbred Bedouin family from Israel. American Journal of Human Genetics 57(4). 965–968.
Siple, Patricia. 1978. Visual constraints for sign language communication. Sign Language Studies 191. 95–110.
Stokoe, William C. 1960. Sign language structure: An outline of the visual communication system of the American Deaf (Studies in linguistics: Occasional papers 8). Buffalo, NY: Dept. of Anthropology and Linguistics, University of Buffalo.
Supalla, Ted. 1986. The classifier system in American Sign Language. In Collette G. Craig (ed.), Noun classification and categorization, 181–214. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Talmy, Leonard. 1978. Figure and Ground in complex sentences. In Joseph H Greenberg (ed.), Universals of human language, vol. 4, Syntax, 625–649. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
. 2003. The representation of spatial structure in spoken and signed language. In Karen Emmorey (ed.), Perspectives on classifier constructions in sign languages, 169–195. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Taub, Sarah F. 2001. Language from the body: Iconicity and metaphor in ASL. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tennant, Richard A. & Marianne Gluszak Brown. 2010. The American Sign Language handshape dictionary, 2nd ed. Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press.
Valli, Clayton & Ceil Lucas. 1995. The linguistics of American Sign Language: A resource text for ASL users. Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press.
Van Cleve, John Vickrey & Barry A. Crouch. 1989. A place of their own: Creating the Deaf community in America. Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press.
Vermeerbergen, Myriam, Lorraine Leeson & Onno Crasborn (eds.). 2007. Simultaneity in signed languages: Form and function. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Wallin, Lars. 1996. Polysynthetic signs in Swedish Sign Language. Stockholm: Stockholm University, Dept. of Linguistics PhD dissertation.
Wierzbicka, Anna. 1988. Oats and wheat: Mass nouns, iconicity, and human categorization. In Anna Wierzbicka (ed.), The semantics of grammar, 499–560. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Wilbur, Ronnie B. 2008. Complex predicates involving events, time and aspect: Is this why sign languages look so similar? In Josep Quer (ed.), Signs of the time: Selected papers from TISLR 2004, 217–250. Hamburg: Signum Verlag.
Wilcox, Sherman. 1992. The phonetics of fingerspelling. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 2004. Cognitive iconicity: Conceptual spaces, meaning, and gesture in signed languages. Cognitive Linguistics 15(2). 119–147.
Wilson, Margaret. 2002. Six views of embodied cognition. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 9(4). 625–636.
Wisniewski, Edward J. 2010. On using count nouns, mass nouns, and pluralia tantum: What counts? In Francis Jeffry Pelletier (ed.), Kinds, things, and stuff: Mass terms and generics, 1–24. Oxford Scholarship Online.
Woll, Bencie, Onno Crasborn, Els van der Kooij, Johanna Mesch & Brita Bergman. 2010. Extended Swadesh list for signed languages. [URL].
Cited by (42)
Cited by 42 other publications
Bisnath, Felicia, Hannah Lutzenberger, Marah Jaraisy, Rehana Omardeen & Adam Schembri
Power, Justin M., David Quinto‐Pozos & Danny Law
Napoli, Donna Jo & Nathan Sanders
Pleyer, Michael, Ryan Lepic & Stefan Hartmann
Źywiczyński, Przemysław & Jordan Zlatev
Bradley, Chuck & Ronnie Wilbur
Cohen-Koka, Shirit, Bracha Nir & Irit Meir
2023. Variation of sign parameters in narrative and expository discourse. Sign Language & Linguistics 26:2 ► pp. 218 ff.
Moita, Mara, Ana Maria Abreu & Ana Mineiro
Zwitserlood, Inge, Els van der Kooij & Onno Crasborn
Bradley, Chuck, Evie A. Malaia, Jeffrey Mark Siskind, Ronnie B. Wilbur & Marcus Perlman
Brentari, Diane, Rabia Ergin, Ann Senghas, Pyeong Whan Cho, Eli Owens & Marie Coppola
Lepic, Ryan
2021. From letters to families. In Constructions in Contact 2 [Constructional Approaches to Language, 30], ► pp. 267 ff.
Pouw, Wim, Mark Dingemanse, Yasamin Motamedi & Aslı Özyürek
Tkachman, Oksana, Gracellia Purnomo & Bryan Gick
Żywiczyński, Przemysław, Sławomir Wacewicz & Casey Lister
ANIBLE, BENJAMIN
Börstell, Carl & Ryan Lepic
2020. Spatial metaphors in antonym pairs across sign languages. Sign Language & Linguistics 23:1-2 ► pp. 112 ff.
Börstell, Carl & Ryan Lepic
Donazzan, Marta & Luciana Sanchez-Mendes
Haluts, Neta, Massimiliano Trippa, Naama Friedmann & Alessandro Treves
MAKAROĞLU, Bahtiyar
OCCHINO, CORRINE, BENJAMIN ANIBLE & JILL P. MORFORD
Gu, Shengyun
2019. The feature system of handshapes and phonological processes in Shanghai Sign Language. Sign Language & Linguistics 22:1 ► pp. 118 ff.
Krebs, Julia, Ronnie B. Wilbur, Phillip M. Alday & Dietmar Roehm
Napoli, Donna Jo & Stephanie Liapis
SEVCIKOVA SEHYR, ZED & KAREN EMMOREY
Żywiczyński, Przemysław
Lepic, Ryan & Corrine Occhino
Nyst, Victoria
2018. Cross-linguistic variation in space-based distance for size depiction in the lexicons of six sign
languages. Sign Language & Linguistics 21:2 ► pp. 350 ff.
Perlman, Marcus, Hannah Little, Bill Thompson & Robin L. Thompson
Östling, Robert, Carl Börstell & Servane Courtaux
HWANG, SO-ONE, NOZOMI TOMITA, HOPE MORGAN, RABIA ERGIN, DENIZ İLKBAŞARAN, ARON SEEGERS MARIE, RYAN LEPIC & CAROL PADDEN
Sandler, Wendy
Sandler, Wendy
2021. Signs and words. In All Things Morphology [Current Issues in Linguistic Theory, 353], ► pp. 57 ff.
Sandler, Wendy
Sandler, Wendy & Diane Lillo‐Martin
Börstell, Carl, Ryan Lepic & Gal Belsitzman
2016. Articulatory plurality is a property of lexical plurals in sign language. Lingvisticae Investigationes 39:2 ► pp. 391 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 4 december 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
