Article published In: Sign Language & Linguistics
Vol. 18:2 (2015) ► pp.167–204
Rethinking constructed action
Published online: 4 February 2016
https://doi.org/10.1075/sll.18.2.01cor
https://doi.org/10.1075/sll.18.2.01cor
We aim to demonstrate the importance of defining linguistic phenomena by using constructed action or CA (i.e. a stretch of discourse that represents one role or combination of roles depicting actions, utterances, thought, attitudes and/or feelings of one or more referents) as an example. The problem is that different assumptions about CA have led to some apparent contradictions about the nature and characteristics of this phenomenon. Based on observations and analyses of British Sign Language narrative data, we outline criteria and recommendations for defining and annotating CA. We show that, in carefully defining the phenomenon in question and providing criteria for its identification, applying these criteria to usage data leads to emergence of particular types of CA. We also show how identifying these types can help resolve some of the apparent contradictions in the literature.
Keywords: role, constructed action, quotation, referential shift, role shift, nonmanual signals, eyegaze
References (73)
Bahan, Ben. 1996. Non-manual realization of agreement in American Sign Language. Boston, MA: Boston University dissertation.
Bahan, Ben & Samuel Supalla. 1995. Line segmentation and narrative structure: A study of eyegaze behavior in American Sign Language. In Karen Emmorey & Judy Reilly (eds.), Language, gesture, and space, 171–191. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Bavin, Edith L. 2009. Widening the field: The process of language acquisition. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 32(25). 449–450.
Casey, Shannon. 2003. “Agreement” in gestures and signed languages: The use of directionality to indicate referents involved in actions. San Diego, CA: University of California at San Diego dissertation.
Coates, Jennifer & Rachel Sutton-Spence. 2001. Turn taking patterns in Deaf conversation. Journal of Sociolinguistics 2(1). 3–34.
Cormier, Kearsy, Robert Adam, Katherine Rowley, Bencie Woll & Joanna Atkinson. 2012a. The British Sign Language Sentence Reproduction Test: Exploring age-of-acquisition effects in British deaf adults. Paper presented at the workshop “Experimental studies in sign language research” at the Annual Meeting of the German Linguistics Society (DGfS), Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
Cormier, Kearsy, Jordan Fenlon & Adam Schembri. 2015. Indicating verbs in British Sign Language favour motivated use of space. Open Linguistics 1(1). .
Cormier, Kearsy, David Quinto-Pozos, Zdenka Sevcikova & Adam Schembri. 2012. Lexicalisation and de-lexicalisation processes in sign languages: Comparing depicting constructions and viewpoint gestures. Language and Communication 32(4). 329–348.
Cormier, Kearsy, Sandra Smith & Zed Sevcikova. 2013. Predicate structures, gesture and simultaneity in the representation of action in British Sign Language: Evidence from deaf children and adults. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education 18(3). 370–390.
Cormier, Kearsy, Sandra Smith & Martine Zwets. 2013. Framing constructed action in British Sign Language narratives. Journal of Pragmatics 551. 119–139.
de Beuzeville, Louise, Trevor Johnston & Adam Schembri. 2009. The use of space with indicating verbs in Australian Sign Language: A corpus-based investigation. Sign Language & Linguistics 12(1). 52–83.
Earis, Helen. 2008. Point of view in narrative discourse: A comparison of British Sign Language and spoken English. London: University College London dissertation.
Earis, Helen & Kearsy Cormier. 2013. Point of view in British Sign Language and spoken English narrative discourse: the example of ‘The Tortoise and the Hare’. Language and Cognition 5(4). 313–343.
Emmorey, Karen & Judy Reilly. 1998. The development of quotation and reported action: Conveying perspective in ASL. In Eve Clark (ed.), Proceedings of the twenty-ninth Annual Child Language Research Forum, 81–90. Stanford, CA: CSLI Press.
. 1995. Point of view expressed through shifters. In Karen Emmorey & Judy Reilly (eds.), Language, gesture, and space, 133–154. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Goswell, Della. 2011. Being there: Role shift in English to Auslan interpreting. In Lorraine Leeson, Myriam Vermeerbergen & Svenja Wurm (eds.), Signed language interpreting: Preparation, practice and performance, 61–86. St. Jerome.
Hansen, Martje & Jens Heßmann. 2007. Matching propositional content and formal markers: Sentence boundaries in a DGS text. Sign Language & Linguistics 10(2). 145–175.
Herrmann, Annika & Markus Steinbach. 2007. When ‘I’ is not I – Quotation in sign languages. Linguistische Berichte 151. 153–179.
. 2012. Quotation in sign languages. A visible context shift. In Ingrid van Alphen & Isabelle Buchstaller (eds.), Quotatives: Cross-linguistic and cross-disciplinary perspectives, 203–230. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Hosemann, Jana. 2011. Eye gaze and verb agreement in German Sign Language: A first glance. Sign Language & Linguistics 141. 76–93.
Janzen, Terry. 2004. Space rotation, perspective shift, and verb morphology in ASL. Cognitive Linguistics 15(2). 149–174.
Johnston, Trevor, Jane van Roekel & Adam Schembri. 2015. On the conventionalization of mouth actions in Australian Sign Language. Language and Speech.
Johnston, Trevor, Myriam Vermeerbergen, Adam Schembri & Lorraine Leeson. 2007. ‘Real data are messy’: Considering cross-linguistic analysis of constituent ordering in Auslan, VGT, and ISL. In Pamela M. Perniss, Roland Pfau & Markus Steinbach (eds.), Visible variation: Comparative studies on sign language structure, 163–206. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Kegl, Judy. 1995. The manifestation and grammatical analysis of clitics in American Sign Language. Chicago Linguistic Society 31(2). 140–167.
Kooij, Els van der, Wim Emmerik & Onno Crasborn. 2004. Prosodic features of focus in NGT. Paper presented at Theoretical Issues in Sign Language Research 8, Barcelona, Spain.
Lee, Robert G., Carol Neidle, Dawn MacLaughlin, Ben Bahan & Judy Kegl. 1997. Role shift in ASL: A syntactic look at direct speech. In Carol Neidle, Dawn MacLaughlin & Robert G. Lee (eds.), Syntactic structure and discourse function: An examination of two constructions in American Sign Language, 24–45. Boston, MA: American Sign Language Linguistic Research Project, Boston University.
Lentz, Ella Mae. 1986. Teaching role shifting. In Carol A. Padden (ed.), Proceedings of the fourth national symposium on sign language research and teaching, 58–69. Silver Spring, MD: NAD.
Liddell, Scott K. 2003. Grammar, gesture and meaning in American Sign Language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Liddell, Scott K. & Melanie Metzger. 1998. Gesture in sign language discourse. Journal of Pragmatics 301. 657–697.
Lillo-Martin, Diane. 1995. The point of view predicate in American Sign Language. In Karen Emmorey & Judy Reilly (eds.), Language, gesture, and space, 155–170. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
. 2012. Utterance reports and constructed action. In Roland Pfau, Markus Steinbach & Bencie Woll (eds.), Sign language – An international handbook (Handbooks of Linguistics and Communication Science), 365–387. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
Loew, Ruth C. 1984. Roles and reference in American Sign Language: A developmental perspective. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota dissertation.
McKee, Rachel & David McKee. 1992. What’s so hard about learning ASL? Sign Language Studies 21(75). 129–158.
McKee, Rachel, Adam Schembri, David McKee & Trevor Johnston. 2011. Variable ‘subject’ presence in Australian Sign Language and New Zealand Sign Language. Language Variation and Change 23(3). 375–398.
McNeill, David. 1992. Hand and mind: What gestures reveal about thought. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Metzger, Melanie. 1995. Constructed dialogue and constructed action in American Sign Language. In Ceil Lucas (ed.), Sociolinguistics in Deaf communities, 255–271. Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press.
Morgan, Gary. 2002. Children’s encoding of simultaneity in British Sign Language narratives. Sign Language & Linguistics 5(2). 131–165.
Morgan, Gary & Bencie Woll. 2003. The development of reference switching encoded through body classifiers in British Sign Language. In Karen Emmorey (ed.), Perspectives on classifier constructions in sign languages, 297–310. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Neidle, Carol, Judy Kegl, Dawn MacLaughlin, Ben Bahan & Robert Lee. 2000. The syntax of American Sign Language: Functional categories and hierarchical structure. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Padden, Carol A. 1986. Verbs and role shifting in American Sign Language. In Carol Padden (ed.), Proceedings of the fourth national symposium on sign language research and teaching, 44–57. Silver Spring, MD: NAD.
. 1990. The relation between space and grammar in ASL verb morphology. In Ceil Lucas (ed.), Sign language research: Theoretical issues, 118–132. Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press.
Pfau, Roland & Josep Quer. 2010. Nonmanuals: Their grammatical and prosodic roles. In Diane Brentari (ed.), Sign languages, 381–402. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pfau, Roland & Markus Steinbach. 2006. Modality-independent and modality-specific aspects of grammaticalization in sign languages (Linguistics in Potsdam 24). Potsdam: Universitäts-Verlag (available at [URL]).
Poulin, Christine. 1994. Null arguments and referential shift in American Sign Language. MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 231. 267–281.
Poulin, Christine & Christopher Miller. 1995. On narrative discourse and point of view in Quebec Sign Language. In Karen Emmorey & Judy Reilly (eds.), Language, gesture, and space, 117–131. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Pyers, Jennie E. & Ann Senghas. 2007. Reported action in Nicaraguan and American Sign Languages: Emerging versus established systems. In Pamela M. Perniss, Roland Pfau & Markus Steinbach (eds.), Visible variation: Comparative studies on sign language structure, 279–302. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Quer, Josep. 2005. Context shift and indexical variables in sign languages. In Efthymia Georgala & Jonathan Howell (eds.), Proceedings from Semantics and Linguistic Theory 151, 152–168. Ithaca, NY: CLC.
. 2011. Reporting and quoting in signed discourse. In Elke Brendel, Jörg Meibauer & Markus Steinbach (eds.), Understanding quotation, 277–302. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Quinto-Pozos, David. 2005. Factors that influence the acquisition of ASL for interpreting students. In Marc Marschark, Rico Peterson & Elizabeth Winston (eds.), Sign language interpreting and interpreter education: Directions for research and practice, 159–187. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Quinto-Pozos, David, Kearsy Cormier & Claire Ramsey. 2009. Constructed action of highly animate referents: Evidence from American, British and Mexican Sign Languages. Paper presented at
35th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society
(Special Session on Non-Speech Modalities), Berkeley, CA.
Quinto-Pozos, David & Sarika Mehta. 2010. Register variation in mimetic gestural complements to signed language. Journal of Pragmatics 421. 557–584.
Quinto-Pozos, David, Jenny Singleton, Peter Hauser, Susan Levine, Carrie Garberoglio & Lynn Y-S. Hou. 2013. Atypical signed language development: A case study of challenges with visual-spatial processing. Cognitive Neuropsychology 301. 332–359.
Reilly, Judy. 2000. Bringing affective expression into the service of language: Acquiring perspective marking in narratives. In Karen Emmorey & Harlan Lane (eds.), The signs of language revisited: An anthology to honor Ursula Bellugi and Edward Klima, 415–433. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Sandler, Wendy & Diane Lillo-Martin. 2006. Sign language and linguistic universals. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schembri, Adam. 2003. Rethinking “classifiers” in signed languages. In Karen Emmorey (ed.), Perspectives on classifier constructions in sign languages, 3–34. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Schick, Brenda S. 1987. The acquisition of classifier predicates in American Sign Language. West Lafayette, IN: Purdue University dissertation.
Schlenker, Phillipe. In press. Super monsters 1: Attitude and action role shift in sign language. [URL]. Semantics and Pragmatics.
Slobin, Dan, Nini Hoiting, Marlon Kuntze, Reyna Lindert, Amy Weinberg, Jennie Pyers, Michelle Anthony, Yael Biederman & Helen Thurmann. 2003. A cognitive/functional perspective on the acquisition of “classifiers”. In Karen Emmorey (ed.), Perspectives on classifier constructions in sign languages, 271–296. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Supalla, Ted. 1982. Structure and acquisition of verbs of motion and location in American Sign Language. San Diego, CA: University of California at San Diego dissertation.
. 2003. Revisiting visual analogy in ASL classifier predicates. In Karen Emmorey (ed.), Perspectives on classifier constructions in sign languages, 249–257. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Tannen, Deborah. 1986. That’s not what I meant!: How conversational style makes or breaks your relations with others. New York: William Morrow.
. 1989a. Interpreting interruption in conversation. In Bradley Music, Randolph Graczyk & Caroline Wiltshire (eds.),
CLS 25: Papers from the 25th Annual Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society; Part Two: Parasession on language in context
, 266–287. Chicago, IL: Chicago Linguistic Society.
. 1989b. Talking voices: Repetition, dialogue, and imagery in conversational discourse. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Thompson, Robin. 2006. Eye gaze in American Sign Language: Linguistic functions for verbs and pronouns. San Diego, CA: University of California at San Diego dissertation.
Thompson, Robin, Karen Emmorey & Robert Kluender. 2006. The relationship between eye gaze and verb agreement in American Sign Language: An eye-tracking study. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 24(2). 571–604.
. 2009. Learning to look: The acquisition of eye gaze agreement during the production of ASL verbs. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition 12(4). 393–409.
Wilcox, Sherman. 2009. Symbol and symptom: Routes from gesture to signed language. Annual Review of Cognitive Linguistics 71. 89–110.
Winston, Elisabeth. 1992. Space and involvement in an American Sign Language lecture. In J. Plant-Moeller (ed.),
Expanding horizons: Proceedings of the twelfth national convention of the registry of interpreters for the deaf
, 93–105. Silver Spring, MD: RID Publications.
Cited by (88)
Cited by 88 other publications
Hernández, Doris, Anna Puupponen, Jarkko Keränen, Sébastien Vandenitte, Benjamin Anible, Gerardo Ortega & Tommi Jantunen
Kanto, Laura, Anna Puupponen & Doris Hernández
2025. The use of constructed action and its relationship with age and sign language development among children acquiring Finnish Sign Language. Sign Language & Linguistics
Pleyer, Michael, Marcus Perlman, Gary Lupyan, Koen de Reus & Limor Raviv
Puupponen, Anna, Gabrielle Hodge, Benjamin Anible, Juhana Salonen, Tuija Wainio, Jarkko Keränen, Doris Hernández & Tommi Jantunen
Stamp, Rose
2025. Sign language corpora designed for sociolinguistic research. International Journal of Corpus Linguistics
Devika, Methil & Babitha Justin
Gür, Cansu
Hernández, Doris, Anna Puupponen, Jarkko Keränen, Gerardo Ortega & Tommi Jantunen
Horton, Laura & James Waller
Kendon, Adam
Lepeut, Alysson, Clara Lombart, Sébastien Vandenitte & Laurence Meurant
Lepeut, Alysson, Clara Lombart, Sébastien Vandenitte & Laurence Meurant
Puupponen, Anna, Laura Kanto, Antti Kronqvist & Danny De Weerdt
Stamp, Rose, David Cohn, Hagit Hel-Or & Wendy Sandler
Stamp, Rose, Svetlana Dachkovsky, Hagit Hel-Or, David Cohn & Wendy Sandler
Aristodemo, Valentina, Beatrice Giustolisi, Giorgia Zorzi, Doriane Gras, Charlotte Hauser, Rita Sala, Jordina Sánchez Amat, Caterina Donati & Carlo Cecchetto
Ferrara, Lindsay, Benjamin Anible, Gabrielle Hodge, Tommi Jantunen, Lorraine Leeson, Johanna Mesch & Anna-Lena Nilsson
German, Austin
German, Austin
Keleş, Onur, Furkan Atmaca & Kadir Gökgöz
Keränen, Jarkko
Keränen, Jarkko
Napoli, Donna Jo & Rachel Sutton-Spence
Napoli, Donna Jo & Rachel Sutton-Spence
Proctor, Heidi & Kearsy Cormier
Sevgi, Hande & Kadir Gökgöz
2023. Classifiers, argument expression, and age of acquisition effects in Turkish Sign Language (TİD). Sign Language & Linguistics 26:1 ► pp. 1 ff.
Steinbach, Markus
Andries, Fien, Geert Brône & Myriam Vermeerbergen
Beukeleers, Inez & Myriam Vermeerbergen
Gür, Cansu & Beyza Sümer
2022. Learning to introduce referents in narration is resilient to the effects of late sign language exposure. Sign Language & Linguistics 25:2 ► pp. 205 ff.
Hodge, Gabrielle & Lindsay Ferrara
Hou, Lynn
Hou, Lynn
Konrad, Reiner, Gabriele Langer, Anke Müller & Sabrina Wähl
2022. Where frozen signs reclaim iconic ground. In Iconicity in Cognition and across Semiotic Systems [Iconicity in Language and Literature, 18], ► pp. 265 ff.
Martinod, Emmanuella
Puupponen, Anna, Laura Kanto, Tuija Wainio & Tommi Jantunen
Quinto-Pozos, David, Fey Parrill & Caitie Coons
2022. The interface between grammar and bodily enactment in ASL and English. Languages in Contrast 22:2 ► pp. 195 ff.
Sivunen, Nina & Elina Tapio
Vandenitte, Sébastien
Vandenitte, Sébastien
Vandenitte, Sébastien
2023. When referents are seen and heard. In Reference [Studies in Language Companion Series, 228], ► pp. 127 ff.
Abrusán, Márta
Beal, Jennifer S, Jessica A Scott & Kelly Spell
Hsu, Hui-Chieh, Geert Brône & Kurt Feyaerts
Hsu, Hui-Chieh, Geert Brône & Kurt Feyaerts
Luna, Stéphanie, Sven Joubert, Marion Blondel, Carlo Cecchetto & Jean-Pierre Gagné
Morales-López, Esperanza
2021. Form-function dialectics in the analysis of irony in political discourse. Revista Española de Lingüística Aplicada/Spanish Journal of Applied Linguistics 34:2 ► pp. 527 ff.
Omardeen, Rehana, Kate Mesh & Markus Steinbach
Raičević Bajić, Dragana, Myriam Vermeerbergen, Adam Schembri & Mieke Van Herreweghe
Schönström, Krister
Stamp, Rose & Wendy Sandler
Jantunen, Tommi, Danny De Weerdt, Birgitta Burger & Anna Puupponen
Kimmelman, Vadim, Alfarabi Imashev, Medet Mukushev, Anara Sandygulova & Matthew L. Hall
Napoli, Donna Jo & Lorraine Leeson
Slonimska, Anita, Asli Özyürek & Olga Capirci
SLONIMSKA, ANITA, ASLI ÖZYÜREK & OLGA CAPIRCI
Slonimska, Anita, Asli Özyürek & Olga Capirci
Tomasuolo, Elena, Chiara Bonsignori, Pasquale Rinaldi & Virginia Volterra
Ferrara, Lindsay
Hodge, Gabrielle & Kearsy Cormier
Hodge, Gabrielle, Lindsay N. Ferrara & Benjamin D. Anible
Hübl, Annika, Emar Maier & Markus Steinbach
Johnston, Trevor Alexander
2019. Clause constituents, arguments and the question of grammatical relations in Auslan (Australian Sign Language). Studies in Language 43:4 ► pp. 941 ff.
Nordlund, Sanna
Parisot, Anne-Marie & Darren Saunders
Parisot, Anne-Marie & Darren Saunders
2022. Character perspective shift sequences and embodiment markers in signed and spoken discourse. Languages in Contrast 22:2 ► pp. 259 ff.
Puupponen, Anna
Quer, Josep & Markus Steinbach
Ferrara, Lindsay & Gabrielle Hodge
Garcia, Brigitte, Marie-Anne Sallandre & Marie-Thérèse L’Huillier
2018. Impersonal human reference in French Sign Language (LSF). Sign Language & Linguistics 21:2 ► pp. 307 ff.
Garcia, Brigitte, Marie-Anne Sallandre, Marie-Thérèse L’Huillier & Hatice Aksen
Herrmann, Annika & Nina-Kristin Pendzich
2018. Between narrator and protagonist in fables of German Sign Language. In Linguistic Foundations of Narration in Spoken and Sign Languages [Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today, 247], ► pp. 275 ff.
Lu, Jenny C. & Susan Goldin-Meadow
Rinaldi, Pasquale, Maria Cristina Caselli, Tommaso Lucioli, Luca Lamano & Virginia Volterra
Sallandre, Marie-Anne, Camille Schoder & Maya Hickmann
2018. Motion expression in children’s acquisition of French Sign Language. In Sources of variation in first language acquisition [Trends in Language Acquisition Research, 22], ► pp. 365 ff.
Schembri, Adam, Kearsy Cormier & Jordan Fenlon
Ferrara, Lindsay & Rolf Piene Halvorsen
2017. Depicting and describing meanings with iconic signs in Norwegian Sign Language. Gesture 16:3 ► pp. 371 ff.
Green, E. Mara
Frederiksen, Anne Therese & Rachel I. Mayberry
Frederiksen, Anne Therese & Rachel I. Mayberry
Frederiksen, Anne Therese & Rachel I. Mayberry
Stec, Kashmiri, Mike Huiskes & Gisela Redeker
Sümer, Beyza
2016. Scene-setting and referent introduction in sign and spoken languages. In The Acquisition of Turkish in Childhood [Trends in Language Acquisition Research, 20], ► pp. 193 ff.
Davidson, Kathryn
Davidson, Kathryn
[no author supplied]
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 4 december 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
