In:Paradigm Change: In the Transeurasian languages and beyond
Edited by Martine Robbeets and Walter Bisang
[Studies in Language Companion Series 161] 2014
► pp. 141–176
Chapter 7. Comparative consequences of the tongue root harmony analysis for proto-Tungusic, proto-Mongolic, and proto-Korean
Published online: 8 October 2014
https://doi.org/10.1075/slcs.161.13ko
https://doi.org/10.1075/slcs.161.13ko
This paper examines the role of retracted tongue root ([RTR]) harmony in Northeast Asian areal and genetic relationships. Recent research has suggested that at least three of the families grouped together as Altaic by Poppe (1960) – Korean, Mongolic, and Tungusic (KMT) – should be reconstructed with [RTR] vowel harmony. In this paper we reinforce this conclusion, arguing specifically against proposals that [RTR] harmony is secondary, or that [ATR] is the dominant feature. We also argue against the proposal of Starostin et al. (2003) that specific proto-families such as proto-Tungusic should be reconstructed without vowel harmony. We then compare the status of [RTR] harmony in Northeast Asia to the status of tongue root harmony in the Central Sudanic Zone, extending our discussion to the vowel harmony found in Chukchi, Yukaghir, Nivkh, and Ainu. We discuss whether KMT-style [RTR] harmony should be viewed as an innovation or a retention, and examine the particular issue of the Korean vowel inventory.
References (97)
Ahn, Sang-Cheol. 2002. A dispersion account on Middle Korean vowel shifts. In Japanese/Korean Linguistics 10, Noriko M. Akatsuka & Susan Strauss (eds), 237–250. Stanford, CA: CSLI.
Aralova, Natalia, Grawunder, Sven & Winter, Bodo. 2011. The acoustic correlates of tongue root vowel harmony in Even (Tungusic). Proceedings of the 17th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences (ICPhS XVII): 240–243.
Archangeli, Diana B. & Pulleyblank, Douglas G. 1994. Grounded Phonology. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Ard, Josh. 1981. A sketch of vowel harmony in the Tungusic languages. In Studies in the Languages of the USSR, B. Comrie (ed.), 23–43. Edmonton, Alberta: Linguistic Research.
Baxter, William H. & Sagart, Laurent. 2011. Baxter-Sagart Old Chinese Reconstruction. [URL] (20 February 2011)
Benzing, Johannes. 1955. Die tungusischen Sprachen: Versuch einer vergleichenden Grammatik. Wiesbaden: Verlag der Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur in Mainz.
Bobaljik, Jonathan. 2009. Disharmony and Decay: Itelmen Vowel Harmony in the Soviet Period. Ms, University of Connecticut.
Buraev, Ignatij Dmitrievich. 1959. Zvukovoj sostav burjatskogo jazyka(The Sound Structure of Buriat). Ulan-Ude.
Casali, Roderic F. 2003. [ATR] value asymmetries and underlying vowel inventory structure in Niger-Congo and Nilo-Saharan. Linguistic Typology 7(3): 307–382.
Castrén, A. 1856. Grundzüge einer tungusischen Sprachlehre nebst kurzem Wörterverzeichniss. Saint Petersburg.
Catford, John C. 1994. Vowel systems of Caucasian languages. In Non-Slavic Languages of the USSR: Papers from the Fourth Conference, Howard Isaac Aronson (ed.), 44–60. Columbus OH: Slavica.
Čenggeltei. 1959. Mongɣol kelen-ü baɣarin ayalɣun-u abiy-a-yin jüi ba üges-ün jüi [Phonology and morphology of the Baarin dialect of Mongolian]. Öbör Monggol-un Yeke Surgaguli-yin Erdem Sinjilegen-ü Sedgül: Gün Uqagan Neyigem Sinjilekü Uqagan (Journal of Inner Mongolia University: Philosophy and Social Sciences) 1959(2): 1–96.
. 1963. Mongɣol kelen-ü abiyan-u sistem (The Mongolian sound system). Öbör Monggol-un Yeke Surgaguli-yin Erdem Sinjilegen-ü Sedgül: Gün Uqagan Neyigem Sinjilekü Uqagan (Journal of Inner Mongolia University: Philosophy and Social Sciences) 1963(2): 1–84.
Čenggeltei & Sinedke. 1959. Mongɣol kelen-ü ündüsün egesig-üd-ün tuqai (The basic vowels of Mongolian). Öbör Monggol-un Yeke Surgaguli-yin Erdem Sinjilegen-ü Sedgül: Gün Uqagan Neyigem Sinjilekü Uqagan (Journal of Inner Mongolia University: Philosophy and Social Sciences) 1959(2): 97–114.
Cho, Mi-Hui. 1994. Vowel Harmony in Korean: A Grounded Phonology Approach. PhD dissertation, Indiana University.
Clements, G.N. & Rialland, Annie. 2008. Africa as a phonological area. In A Linguistic Geography of Africa, B. Heine & D. Nurse (eds), 36–85. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dimmendaal, Gerrit J. 2001. Areal diffusion versus genetic inheritance: an African perspective. In Areal Diffusion and Genetic Inheritance: Problems in Comparative Linguistics, Alexandra Y. Aikhenvald & Robert M.W. Dixon (eds), 359–392. Oxford: OUP.
Dresher, B. Elan, Harvey, Christopher & Oxford, Will. 2012. Contrast shift as a type of diachronic change. Handout presented at the 43rd annual meeting of the North East Linguistic Society (NELS 43), CUNY.
Dresher, B. Elan & Zhang, Xi. 2005. Contrast and phonological activity in Manchu vowel systems. Canadian Journal of Linguistics/Revue Canadienne de Linguistique 50: 45–82.
Georg, Stefan. 2004. Unreclassifying Tungusic. In Proceedings of the First International Conference on Manchu-Tungus Studies (Bonn, August 28-September 1, 2000), Vol 2: Trends in Tungusic and Siberian Linguistics [Tunguso Sibirica 9], Carsten Naeher, Giovanni Stary & Michael Weiers (eds), 45–57. Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz.
Goad, Heather. 1992. [Atr] and [Rtr] are different features. In Proceedings of the Tenth West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, Dawn Bates (ed.), 163–173. Stanford CA: CSLI.
Hall, Beatrice L. & Hall, Richard M.R. 1980. Nez Perce vowel harmony: An Africanist explanation and some theoretical questions. In Issues in Vowel Harmony (Proceedings of the CUNY Linguistics Conference on Vowel Harmony, 14th May 1977), [Studies in Language Companion Series 6], Robert M. Vago (ed), 201-236. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Hattori, Shirō. 1975. Boin chōwa to chūki chōsengo no boin taikei (Vowel harmony and the Middle Korean vowel system). Gengo no Kagaku 6: 1–22.
. 1982. Vowel harmonies of the Altaic languages, Korean, and Japanese. Acta Orientalia Hungarica 36: 207–214.
Hu, Zengyi. 2001. Elunchun yu yanjiu(Research on the Oroqen Language). Beijing, China: Minzu chubanshe.
Hyman, Larry. 2011. The Macro-Sudan belt and Niger-Congo reconstruction. Language Dynamics & Change 1(1): 3–49.
Ikegami, Jirō. 1997. Uirutago jiten (A Dictionary of the Uilta Language spoken on Sakhalin). Sapporo: Hokkaidō Daigaku Tosho Kankōkai.
Joseph, Andrew & Whitman, John. 2013. The diachronic consequences of the RTR analysis of Tungusic vowel harmony. In MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 67: Proceedings of the 8th Workshop on Altaic Formal Linguistics (WAFL 8), Umut Özge (ed.), 159–174. Cambridge MA: MITWPL.
Kang, Hijo & Ko, Seongyeon. 2011. In search of the acoustic correlates of tongue root retraction in three Altaic languages: Western Buriat, Tsongol Buriat, and Ewen. Altai Hakpo 22: 179–203.
Kaun, Abigail. 1995. The Typology of Rounding Harmony: An Optimality Theoretic Approach. PhD dissertation, UCLA.
. 2004. The typology of rounding harmony. In Phonetically Based Phonology, Bruce Hayes, Robert M. Kirchner & Donca Steriade (eds), 87–116. Cambridge: CUP.
Kazama, Shinjirō. 2003. Basic Vocabulary (A) of Tungusic Languages (Endangered Languages of the Pacific Rim Publications Series A2–037) Publications on Tungus Languages and Cultures 25]. Ōsaka: Ōsaka Gakuin University.
Kim, Chin-Wu. 1978. “Diagonal” vowel harmony? Some implications for historical phonology. In Recent Developments in Historical Phonology 4, Jacek Fisiak (ed.), 221–236. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Kim, Jong-Kyoo. 2000. Quantity-sensitivity and Feature-sensitivity of Vowels: A Constraint-based Approach to Korean Vowel Phonology. PhD dissertation, Indiana University.
Kim, Juwon. 1988. Moumcohwawa selchwuk: Hwunminjengum haylyeyuy selchwukey tayhaye (Vowel harmony and “selchwuk”: On the tongue retraction in Hunminjeongeum). Eoneohag (Journal of the Linguistic Society of Korea) 9(10): 29-43.
. 1989. Mancwu thwungkwusuceyeuy moumcohwa yenkwu (A Study on Vowel Harmony in the Manchu-Tungus Languages). PhD dissertation, Seoul National University.
. 1993. Moumcohwauy yenku (A Study on Vowel Harmony in Korean). Kyeungsan: Yeungnam University Press.
. 1999. Selkunhwuchwukkwa selkuncencin (RTR and ATR). In Eneuy yeksa(History of Languages: In Honor of Professor Baeg-in Seong), 311–341. Seoul: Thaehaksa.
Kim-Renaud, Y.-K. 2008. The vowel system and vowel harmony in 15th century Korean revisited. In Proceedings of the SCRIPTA 2008: Hunminjeongeum and Alphabetic Writing Systems, 23–36.
Ko, Seongyeon. 2010. A contrastivist view on the evolution of the Korean vowel system. In MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 61: Proceedings of the 6th Workshop on Altaic Formal Linguistics (WAFL 6), Hiroki Maezawa & Azusa Yokogoshi (eds), 181–196. Cambridge MA: MITWPL.
. 2011. Vowel contrast and vowel harmony shift in the Mongolic languages. Language Research 47(1): 23–43.
. 2012. Tongue Root Harmony and Vowel Contrast in Northeast Asian Languages. PhD dissertation, Cornell University.
. 2013a. The end of the Korean vowel shift controversy. Korean Linguistics 15(2): 195–216.
. 2013b. Vowel feature hierarchies in Tungusic. In Current Trends in Altaic Linguistics: A Festschrift for Professor Emeritus Seong Baeg-in on his 80th Birthday, Juwon Kim & Dongho Ko (eds), 91-124. Seoul: Altaic Society of Korea.
. 2013c. Towards a contrast-driven typology of the Altaic vowel systems. Paper presented at the 9th Workshop on Altaic Formal Linguistics (WAFL 9). Cornell University, Ithaca NY.
Kwak, Chung-gu. 2003. Hyentay kwukeuy moumcheykyewa ku pyenhwauy panghyang (The vowel system of Contemporary Korean and direction of change). Kwukehak 41: 59–91.
Ladefoged, Peter & Maddieson, Ian. 1996. The Sounds of the World’s Languages. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
Lee, Byung-Gun. 1985. Moum cohwauy thukseng (Some tangible properties of vowel harmony). Inmwunnonchong 15: 3–36.
Lee, Jin-Seong. 1992. Phonology and Sound Symbolism of Korean Ideophones. PhD dissertation, Indiana University.
Lee, Ki-Moon. 1958. A comparative study of Manchu and Korean. Ural-altaische Jahrbücher 30: 104–120.
. 1972. Kwukesa kaysel (Outline of the History of the Korean Language), 2nd edn. Seoul: Tower Press.
Li, Bing. 1996. Tungusic Vowel Harmony: Description and Analysis [HIL Dissertations 18]. Leiden: Holland Institute of Generative Linguistics.
Lulich, Steven & Whaley, Lindsay. 2012. An acoustic phonetic study of Oroqen vowels. In Recent advances in Tungusic Languages [Turcologica 89], Andrej Malchukov & Lindsay Whaley (eds), 59–78. Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz.
. 2000. How have Korean vowels changed through time? Korean Linguistics 10: 1–59.
Möömöö, Sürèngijn. 1977. Sistema fonem sovremennogo mongol’skogo jazyka (The Phoneme System of Modern Mongolian). Warszawa: Wydawnictwa Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego.
Nevins, Andrew. 2010. Locality in Vowel Harmony [Linguistic Inquiry Monograph 55]. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Nikolaeva, Irina Alekseevna & Tolskaya, Maria. 2001. A Grammar of Udihe [Mouton Grammar Library 22]. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Park, Jong-Hee. 1983. Kwuke umwunlon yenkwu (A Study on Korean Phonology). Iksan: Wonkwang University Press.
. 1994. Cwunglipmoum /i/-uy poncilkwa moumcohwa (The nature of the neutral vowel /i/ and vowel harmony). In Wulimal yenkwuuy saymthe, 134–153. Daejeon: Mwunkyeng Press.
. 2002. Cwungsengmoum /i/-uy thwumyengsengkwa pwulthwumyengseng (The transparency and opacity of the neutral vowel /i/ in Middle Korean). Hangeul 257: 71–101.
Park, Jong-Hee & Kwon, Pyong-Ro. 2009. Moumcheykyeyuy pyenchenkwa cacilkyelhap coken (The change of vowel system and featural combination conditions in Middle Korean). Kwukemwunhak 47: 37–61.
Poppe, Nicholas N. 1955. Introduction to Mongolian Comparative Studies. Helsinki: Suomalais-ugrilainen Seura.
. 1960. Vergleichende Grammatik der altaischen Sprachen, Teil I: Vergleichende Lautlehre (Comparative grammar of the Altaic languages, Part 1: comparative phonology). Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz.
Przezdziecki, Marek. 2005. Vowel Harmony and Coarticulation in Three Dialects of Yoruba: Phonetics Determining Phonology. PhD dissertation, Cornell University.
Rice, Keren. 2007. Markedness in phonology. In The Cambridge Handbook of Phonology, Paul de Lacy (ed.), 79–98. Cambridge: CUP.
Robbeets, Martine. I. 2005. Is Japanese Related to Korean, Tungusic, Mongolic and Turkic? [Turcologica 64]. Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz.
Shiraishi, Hidetoshi & Botma, Bert. 2013. Asymmetries and attractors in Nivkh vowel sequences. Ms, Sapporo Gakuin University and Leiden University.
Starostin, Sergei A., Dybo, Anna V. & Mudrak, Oleg A. 2003. Etymological Dictionary of the Altaic Languages [Handbuch der Orientalistik VIII.8.1–3]. Leiden: Brill.
Steriade, Donca. 1995. Underspecification and markedness. In The Handbook of Phonological Theory, John A. Goldsmith (ed), 114–174. Oxford: Blackwell.
Sunik, O.P. 1968. Udėgejskij jazyk (Udihe language). In Jazyki narodov SSSR (Languages of the Peoples of the USSR) 5: 210–232. Leningrad: Nauka.
Svantesson, Jan-Olof, Tsendina, Anna, Karlsson, Anastasia M. & Franzén, Vivan. 2005. The Phonology of Mongolian. Oxford: OUP.
Titov, Je. I. 1926. Tungussko-russkij slovar’s priloženijem knigi M. A. Kastrena “Osnovy izučenija tungusskogo jazyka”. Irkutsk.
Tsintsius, Vera. 1949. Sravnitel’naja fonetika tunguso-man’chzhurskikh jazykov (Comparative Phonetics of the Manchu-Tungus Languages). Leningrad: Nauka.
. 1975–1977. Sravnitel’nyj slovar’ tunguso-man’chzhurskikh jazykov (Comparative Dictionary of the Manchu-Tungus Languages). Leningrad: Nauka.
van der Hulst, Harry & van de Weijer, Jeroen. 1995. Vowel harmony. In The Handbook of Phonological Theory, John A. Goldsmith (ed), 495–534. Oxford: Blackwell.
Vaux, Bert. 2009. [atr] and [back] harmony in the Altaic languages. In Investigations into Formal Altaic Linguistics: Proceedings of WAFL3, Sergei Tatevosov (ed), 50–67. Moscow: MAKS Press.
Vovin, Alexander. 2000. On the Great Vowel Shift in Middle Korean and position of stress in Proto-Korean. Korean Linguistics 10: 61–78.
Zhang, Xi. 1996. Vowel Systems of the Manchu-Tungus Languages of China. PhD dissertation, University of Toronto.
Zhang, Xi & Dresher, B. Elan. 2004. Tongue root harmony in Written Manchu. In Proceedings of the First International Conference on Manchu-Tungus Studies (Bonn, August 28-September 1, 2000), Vol 2: Trends in Tungusic and Siberian Linguistics, Carsten Naeher, Giovanni Stary & Michael Weiers (eds), 161–190. Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz.
Cited by (31)
Cited by 31 other publications
Janhunen, Juha A.
Kenstowicz, Michael J.
Nikolsky, Aleksey
Aikhenvald, Alexandra Y.
Ansaldo, Umberto, Walter Bisang & Pui Yiu Szeto
Arkadiev, Peter & Timur Maisak
Coupe, Alexander R.
Dahl, Östen
Esseesy, Mohssen
Haig, Geoffrey
Haspelmath, Martin
Heine, Bernd
Johanson, Lars & Éva Á. Csató
Klamer, Marian
McWhorter, John H.
Mithun, Marianne
Moyse-Faurie, Claire
Mushin, Ilana
Heiko Narrog & Bernd Heine
Narrog, Heiko, Seongha Rhee & John Whitman
Smith, Hiram L.
Zariquiey, Roberto
Robbeets, Martine
Shiraishi, Hidetoshi & Bert Botma
2017. On the diachronic origin of Nivkh height restrictions. In Sonic Signatures [Language Faculty and Beyond, 14], ► pp. 202 ff.
Bugaeva, Anna
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 3 december 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
