A view from clean: Manner and result

Levin, Beth; Hovav, Malka Rappaport

doi:10.1075/slcs.147.14lev

In:Language Description Informed by Theory
Edited by Rob Pensalfini, Myfany Turpin and Diana Guillemin
[Studies in Language Companion Series 147] 2014
► pp. 337–358

Get fulltext from our e-platform

Download Book PDF

Manner and result

A view from clean

Beth Levin

Malka Rappaport Hovav

Published online: 28 January 2014

https://doi.org/10.1075/slcs.147.14lev

As a deadjectival verb, English clean should be a clear-cut result verb, yet it often shows hallmarks of a manner verb. This paper investigates this dual behavior in light of manner/result complementarity: the proposal that verbs lexicalize either manner or result meaning components, but not both. We demonstrate that once lexicalized and contextually determined meaning components are distinguished, clean conforms to manner/result complementarity. It can be a result verb, not entailing a particular manner. However, given its strong association with cleaning routines, some uses simply lexicalize manner. Crucially, in manner uses the result drops out, consistent with manner/result complementarity. The manner-only and result-only uses of clean, then, instantiate related senses, each conforming to manner/result complementarity.

References (32)

References

Arsenijević, Boban. 2010. On the syntactic nature of manner-incorporation. Ms, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona.

Beavers, John. 2008. Scalar complexity and the structure of events. In Event Structures in Linguistic Form and Interpretation , Johannes Dölling, Tatjana Heyde-Zybatow & Martin Schäfer (eds.), 245–265. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.

Brisson, Christine. 1994. The licensing of unexpressed objects in English verbs. In Papers from the 30th Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society , 1: The Main Session , 90–102. Chicago IL: Chicago Linguistic Society.

Fillmore, Charles J.1970. The grammar of hitting and breaking. In Readings in English Transformational Grammar , Roderick A. Jacobs & Peter S. Rosenbaum (eds), 120–133. Waltham MA: Ginn.

Goldberg, Adele E.1995. Constructions: A Construction Grammar Approach to Argument Structure . Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press.

2001. Patient arguments of causative verbs can be omitted: The role of information structure in argument distribution. Language Sciences 23: 503–534.

2005. Constructions, lexical semantics and the Correspondence Principle: Accounting for generalizations and subregularities in the realization of arguments. In The Syntax of Aspect , Nomi Erteschik-Shir & Tova Rapoport (eds), 215–236. Oxford: OUP.

Guerssel, Mohamed, Hale, Kenneth, Laughren, Mary, Levin, Beth & White Eagle, Josie. 1985. A cross-linguistic study of transitivity alternations. In Papers from the Parasession on Causatives and Agentivity , 48–63. Chicago IL: Chicago Linguistic Society.

Hay, Jennifer, Kennedy, Christopher & Levin, Beth. 1999. Scalar structure underlies telicity in ‘degree achievements’. In Proceedings of SALT 9 , Tanya Matthews & Devon Strolovitch (eds), 127–144. Ithaca NY: Cornell Linguistics Circle Publications.

Kearns, Kate. 2007. Telic senses of deadjectival verbs. Lingua 117: 27–66.

Kennedy, Christopher. 2001. Polar opposition and the ontology of ‘degrees’. Linguistics and Philosophy 24: 33–70.

Kennedy, Christopher & Levin, Beth. 2008. Measure of change: The adjectival core of verbs of variable telicity. In Adjectives and Adverbs in Semantics and Discourse , Louise McNally & Christopher Kennedy (eds), 156–182. Oxford: OUP.

Kennedy, Christopher & McNally, Louise. 2005. Scale structure, degree modification, and the semantic typology of gradable predicates. Language 81: 345–381.

Koontz-Garboden, Andrew & Beavers, John. 2012. Manner and result in roots of verbal meaning. Linguistic Inquiry 43: 331–369.

Laughren, Mary. 1988. Towards a lexical representation of Warlpiri verbs. In Thematic Relations [Syntax and Semantics 21], Wendy Wilkins (ed.), 215–242. New York NY: Academic Press.

Levin, Beth & Rappaport Hovav, Malka. 1991. Wiping the slate clean: A lexical semantic exploration. Cognition 41: 123–151.

. 1992. The lexical semantics of verbs of motion: The perspective from unaccusativity. In Thematic Structure: Its Role in Grammar , Ignacio M. Roca (ed.), 247–269. Berlin: Foris.

. 1995. Unaccusativity: At the Syntax-lexical Semantics Interface . Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.

. 2006. Constraints on the complexity of verb meaning and VP structure. In Between 40 and 60 Puzzles for Krifka , Hans-Martin Gärtner, Regine Eckardt, Renate Musan & Barbara Stiebels(eds.). <[URL]>

. 2013. Lexicalized meaning and manner/result complementarity. In The Subatomic Semantics of Event Predicates , Boban Arsenijevic, Berit Gehrke & Rafael Marín (eds), 49–70. Dordrecht: Springer.

Mateu, Jaume & Acedo-Matellán, Víctor. 2012. The manner/result complementarity revisited: A syntactic approach. In The End of Argument Structure , María Cristina Cuervo & Yves Roberge (eds), 209–228. Bingley: Emerald.

Mittwoch, Anita. 2005. Unspecified arguments in episodic and habitual sentences. In The Syntax of Aspect , Nomi Erteschik-Shir & Tova Rapoport (eds.), 237–254. Oxford: OUP.

Rappaport Hovav, Malka. 2008. Lexicalized meaning and the internal temporal structure of events. In Crosslinguistic and Theoretical Approaches to the Semantics of Aspect [Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today 110], Susan D. Rothstein (ed.), 13–42. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.

Rappaport Hovav, Malka & Levin, Beth. 1998. Building verb meanings. In The Projection of Arguments: Lexical and Compositional Factors , Miriam Butt & Wilhelm Geuder (eds), 97–134. Stanford CA: CSLI.

. 2005. Change of state verbs: Implications for theories of argument projection. In The Syntax of Aspect , Nomi Erteschik-Shir & Tova Rapoport (eds), 274–286. Oxford: OUP.

. 2010. Reflections on manner/result complementarity. In Syntax, Lexical Semantics, and Event Structure , Edit Doron, Malka Rappaport Hovav & Ivy Sichel (eds.), 21–38. Oxford: OUP.

. 2012. Lexicon uniformity and the causative alternation. In The Theta System: Argument Structure at the Interface , Martin Everaert, Marijana Marelj & Tal Siloni (eds.), 150–176. Oxford: OUP.

Rothstein, Susan. 2004. Structuring Events: A Study in the Semantics of Aspect . Oxford: Blackwell.

Schalley, Andrea C.2004. Cognitive Modeling and Verbal Semantics: A Representational Framework Based on UML . Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.

Talmy, Leonard. 2000. Towards a Cognitive Semantics , II: Typology and Process in Concept Structuring . Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.

Tenny, Carol L.1994. Aspectual Roles and the Syntax-Semantics Interface . Dordrecht: Kluwer.

van der Leek, Frederike. 1996. The English conative construction: A compositional account. In Papers from the 32nd Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society , 1: The Main Session , 363–378. Chicago IL: Chicago Linguistic Society.

Cited by (31)

Cited by 31 other publications

Order by:

Hopperdietzel, Jens

2025. Manner/result polysemy as contextual allosemy: Evidence from Daakaka. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 43:1 ► pp. 273 ff.

Iwata, Seizi

2025. The manner of cutting revisited. Constructions and Frames 17:2 ► pp. 236 ff.

Gärdenfors, Peter

2024. Event structure, force dynamics and verb semantics. Language Sciences 102 ► pp. 101610 ff.

Kou, Xinyan & Jill Hohenstein

2024. Manner, result, and intention: implications for event typology from a cognitive account of verb semantics based on fulfilment types. Language and Cognition 16:4 ► pp. 1053 ff.

Menete, Sérgio N. & Guiying Jiang

2024. Another member out of the family: the description of manner of gait in Changana verbs of motion. Folia Linguistica 58:2 ► pp. 401 ff.

Wood, Jim

2023. Icelandic Nominalizations and Allosemy,

GLASS, LELIA

2022. English verbs can omit their objects when they describe routines. English Language and Linguistics 26:1 ► pp. 49 ff.

Menete, Sérgio N.

2022. Motion events in Changana spoken narrative. Southern African Linguistics and Applied Language Studies 40:3 ► pp. 251 ff.

Lin, Jingxia

2021. Typological shift in lexicalizing motion events: The case of Wenzhou . Linguistic Typology 25:1 ► pp. 1 ff.

Spathas, Giorgos & Dimitris Michelioudakis

2021. States in the decomposition of verbal predicates. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 39:4 ► pp. 1253 ff.

Pross, Tillmann

2020. Dispositions and the verbal description of their manifestations: a case study on Emission Verbs. Linguistics and Philosophy 43:2 ► pp. 149 ff.

van Gelderen, Elly

2019. Stability and Change in Intransitive Argument Structure. Open Linguistics 5:1 ► pp. 217 ff.

Acedo–Matellán, Víctor & Jaume Mateu

2014. From syntax to roots. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 14 ff.

Acquaviva, Paolo

2014. The roots of nominality, the nominality of roots. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 33 ff.

Alexiadou, Artemis

2014. Roots in transitivity alternations. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 57 ff.

Artemis Alexiadou, Hagit Borer & Florian Schäfer

2014. Introduction. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 1 ff.

Artemis Alexiadou, Hagit Borer & Florian Schäfer

2014. The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax,

Anagnostopoulou, Elena & Yota Samioti

2014. Domains within words and their meanings. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 81 ff.

Borer, Hagit

2014. The category of roots. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 112 ff.

De Belder, Marijke, Noam Faust & Nicola Lampitelli

2014. On a low and a high diminutive. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 149 ff.

Doron, Edit

2014. The interaction of adjectival passive and Voice. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 164 ff.

Gallego, Ángel J.

2014. Roots and phases. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 192 ff.

Hovav, Malka Rappaport

2014. Building scalar changes. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 259 ff.

Levinson, Lisa

2014. The ontology of roots and verbs. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 208 ff.

Lowenstamm, Jean

2014. Derivational affixes as roots. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 230 ff.

Roßdeutscher, Antje

2014. When roots license and when they respect semantico‐syntactic structure in verbs. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. 282 ff.

[no author supplied]

2014. General preface. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. vii ff.

[no author supplied]

2014. Copyright Page. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. iv ff.

[no author supplied]

2014. List of abbreviations. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. xi ff.

[no author supplied]

2014. Notes on contributors. In The Syntax of Roots and the Roots of Syntax, ► pp. viii ff.

[no author supplied]

2019. Encoding Motion Events in Mandarin Chinese [Studies in Chinese Language and Discourse, 11],

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 3 december 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.