In:Pragmatics and its Interfaces
Edited by Cornelia Ilie and Neal R. Norrick
[Pragmatics & Beyond New Series 294] 2018
► pp. 85–119
Pragmatics vs rhetoric
Political discourse at the pragmatics-rhetoric interface
Published online: 7 September 2018
https://doi.org/10.1075/pbns.294.05ili
https://doi.org/10.1075/pbns.294.05ili
Abstract
Pragmatics and rhetoric display a range of commonalities and convergences in that both are concerned with discursive and extra-discursive strategies that enable the negotiation and re-negotiation of context-situated meaning, and the co-performance of interpersonal and institutional relationships in terms of intentions and expectations. At the same time, while pragmatics and rhetoric display differences in analytical focus, they complement each other, through specific insights into, e.g., interactive uses of addressing forms and goal-oriented speech acts (pragmatics) and figurative language use and argumentation processes (rhetoric). The aim of this chapter is to explore the interface between pragmatics and rhetoric, arguing that a pragma-rhetorical approach provides systematic tools for a multi-level analysis of discursive contextualisation of political power struggle and of metadiscursive framing of question-answer political confrontation.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Target of the present study
- 3.Pragmatics and rhetoric revisited
- 3.1The pragmatics-rhetoric interface
- 3.2Interfacing the pragmatics and the rhetoric of political discourse
- 4.Pragma-rhetorical approach to political discourse
- 4.1Contextualisation through meaning negotiation and re-negotiation in political interviews
- 4.2Metadiscourse framing strategies in question-answer sequencing in parliamentary debates
- 5.Conclusions
References
References (95)
Althaus, Scott L. 2012. “What’s Good and Bad in Political Communication Research? Normative Standards for Evaluating Media and Citizen Performance.” In The Sage Handbook of Political Communication, ed. by Holli A. Semetko, and Margaret Scammell, 97–112. London, UK and Thousand Oaks, US: SAGE Publications Limited.
Aronoff, Myron J., and Jan Kubik. 2013. Anthropology and Political Science: A Convergent Approach. Berghahn Books.
Atkins, J., Alan Finlayson, James Martin, and Nick Turnbull (eds). 2014. Rhetoric in British Politics and Society. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Bates, Stephen R., Peter Kerr, Christopher Byrne, and Liam Stanley. 2012. “Questions to the Prime Minister: A Comparative Study of PMQs from Thatcher to Cameron.” Parliamentary Affairs 2: 1–28.
Bhatia, Aditi. 2006. “Critical Discourse Analysis of Political Press Conferences.” Discourse & Society 17(2): 173–203.
Booth, Wayne C.. 1974. Modern Dogma and the Rhetoric of Assent. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bull, Peter. 2000. “New Labour, New Rhetoric? An Analysis of the Rhetoric of Tony Blair.” In Beyond Public Speech and Symbols: Explorations in the Rhetoric of Politicians and the Media, ed. by Christ’l De Landtsheer, and Ofer Feldman, 3–16. Greenwood Publishing Group.
Charteris-Black, J. 2005. Politicians and Rhetoric: The Persuasive Power of Metaphor. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Covino, William A. and David A. Jolliffe. 1995. Rhetoric: Concepts, Definitions, Boundaries. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Cummings, Louise. 2005. Pragmatics: A Multidisciplinary Perspective. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
De Fina, Anna 1995. “Pronominal Choice, Identity and Solidarity in Political Discourse.” Text 15 (3): 379–410.
Degano, Chiara. 2014. “Presidential Press Conferences: An Analysis of a Dialogic Genre.” In Genres and Genre Theory in Transition: Specialized Discourses Across Media and Modes, ed. by Giuliana Garzone, and Cornelia Ilie). Boca Raton, FA: BrownWalker Press.
De Landtsheer, Christ’l, and Ofer Feldman (eds). 2000. Beyond Public Speech and Symbols: Explorations in the Rhetoric of Politicians and the Media. Greenwood Publishing Group.
Drew, Paul. 2018. “The Interface between Pragmatics and Conversation Analysis.” In Pragmatics and Its Interfaces, ed. by Cornelia Ilie and Neal R. Norrick, 59–83. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Elliott, Judy and Peter Bull. 1996. “A question of threat: face threats in questions posed during televised political interviews”. Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology 6: 49–72.
Fetzer, Anita (ed). 2013. The Pragmatics of Political Discourse: Explorations Across Cultures. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 2018. “Discourse Pragmatics: Communicative Action Meets Discourse Analysis.” In Pragmatics and Its Interfaces, ed. by Cornelia Ilie and Neal R. Norrick, 33–57. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Finlayson, Alan. 2007. “From Beliefs to Arguments: Interpretive Methodology and Rhetorical Political Analysis.” British Journal of Politics & International Relations 9(4): 545–563.
Franklin, Mark, and Philip Norton (eds). 1993. Parliamentary Questions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fraser, Bruce. 2010. “Hedging in Political Discourse: The Bush 2007 Press Conferences.” In Perspectives in Politics and Discourse, ed. by Urszula Okulska, and Piotr Cap, 201–214. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Grice, H. Paul. 1975. “Logic and Conversation.” In Syntax and Semantics Vol. 3, Speech acts, ed. by Peter Cole, and Jerry L. Morgan, 59–82. New York: Academic Press.
Hahn, Dan F. 2003. Political Communication: Rhetoric, Government, and Citizens. 2nd edition. State College PA: Strata Publishing.
Harris, Sandra. 1991. “Evasive Action: How Politicians Respond to Questions in Political Interviews.” In Broadcast talk, ed. by Paddy Scannell, 76–99. London: Sage.
Harris, Sandra, Karen Grainger, and Louise Mullany. 2006. “The Pragmatics of Political Apologies.” Discourse & Society 17(6): 715–737.
Herrick, James A.. 2001. The History and Theory of Rhetoric: An Introduction Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Hymes, D. H. 1972. “On communicative competence. In J. B. Pride and J. Holmes (eds.), Sociolinguistics (pp.269–293). London: Penguin.
Ilie, Cornelia. 1994. What Else Can I Tell You? A Pragmatic Study of English Rhetorical Questions as Discursive and Argumentative Acts. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International.
. 2000. “Cliché-Based Metadiscursive Argumentation in the Houses of Parliament.” International Journal of Applied Linguistics 10(1): 65–84.
. 2003a. “Discourse and Metadiscourse in Parliamentary Debates.” Journal of Language and Politics 1(2): 269–291.
. 2003b. “Parenthetically Speaking: Parliamentary Parentheticals as Rhetorical Strategies.” In
Dialogue Analysis 2000: Selected Papers from the 10th IADA Anniversary Conference, Bologna 2000, ed. by Marina Bondi, and Sorin Stati, 253–264. Tübingen: Niemeyer.
. 2004. “Insulting as (Un)parliamentary Practice in the British and Swedish Parliaments: A Rhetorical Approach.” In Cross-Cultural Perspectives on Parliamentary Discourse, ed. by P. Bayley, 45–86. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 2006. “Towards a Pragma-Rhetorical Approach: From Rhetoric to Pragmatics and Beyond.” In Pragmatics, ed. by Ashok Thorat, 16–37. Institute of Advanced Studies in English, Aundh, Pune.
. 2008. “Talking the Talk, Walking the Walk: Candidate Profiles in Election Campaign Interviews”. In Giovanni Gobber, Sibilla Cantarini, Sara Cigada, Maria Cristina Gatti and Silvia Gilardoni (eds.). L’analisi linguistica e letteraria XVI, Special Issue, 2: 543–557. (Proceedings of the IADA Workshop Word Meaning in Argumentative Dialogue – Homage to Sorin Stati).
. 2009a. “Strategies of Refutation by Definition: A Pragma-Rhetorical Approach to Refutations in American Public Speech.” In Pondering on Problems of Argumentation. Twenty Essays on Theoretical Issues, ed. by Frans H. van Eemeren, and Bart Garssen, 35–51. Berlin: Springer.
. 2009b. “Argumentative Functions of Parentheticals in Parliamentary Debates.” In Discourse and politics, ed. by Gloria Álvarez-Benito, Gabriela Fernández-Díaz, and Isabel Íñigo-Mora, 61–79. Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
. 2010a. “Strategic Uses of Parliamentary Forms of Address: The Case of the U.K. Parliament and the Swedish Riksdag.” Journal of Pragmatics 42(4): 885–911.
. 2010b. “Identity Co-Construction in Parliamentary Discourse Practices.” In European Parliaments under Scrutiny: Discourse Strategies and Interaction Practices, ed. by Cornelia Ilie, 57–78. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
. 2011. “The Gender Divide in Election Campaign Interviews: Questioning Barack Obama and Calling into Question Hillary Clinton.” Redescriptions – Yearbook of Political Thought, Conceptual History and Feminist Theory 15: 125–148.
. 2013. “Gendering Confrontational Rhetoric: Discursive Disorder in the British and Swedish Parliaments.” Democratization 20(3): 501–521.
. 2015a. “Questions and Questioning.” In The International Encyclopedia of Language and Social Interaction, ed. by Karen Tracy, Cornelia Ilie, and Todd Sandel, Boston: John Wiley & Sons.
. 2015b. “Follow-ups as Multifunctional Questioning and Answering Strategies in Prime Minister’s Questions.” In The dynamics of political discourse: Forms and functions of follow-ups, ed. by Anita Fetzer, Elda Weizman and Lawrence N. Berlin. 195–218. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 2016. “Parliamentary Discourse and Deliberative Rhetoric”. In Parliaments and parliamentarism: A Comparative History of Disputes about a European Concept, ed. by Pasi Ihalainen, Cornelia Ilie, and Kari Palonen,133–145. Oxford and New York: Berghahn Books.
Ilie, Cornelia and Cezar Ornatowski. 2016. “Central and Eastern European Parliamentary Rhetoric since the Nineteenth Century: The Case of Romania and Poland.” In Parliaments and Parliamentarism: A Comparative History, of Disputes about a European Concept, ed. by Pasi Ihalainen, Cornelia Ilie, and Kari Palonen, 192–215. Oxford and New York: Berghahn Books.
Ilie, Cornelia. 2017a. “Questioning the Questionable: Arguments and Counter-arguments in Political Accountability Interviews.” In Argumentation across Communities of Practice: Multi-disciplinary Perspectives, ed. by Cornelia Ilie, and Giuliana Garzone. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 2017b. “Parliamentary Debates.” In The Routledge Handbook of Language and Politics (section “Genres for Political Action”), ed. by Ruth Wodak, and Bernhard Forchtner. Oxon: Routledge.
Jiang, Xiangying. 2006. “Cross-cultural Pragmatic Differences in US and Chinese Press Conferences: The Case of the North Korea Nuclear Crisis.” Discourse & Society 17(2): 237–257.
Kennedy, George A. 1999[1980]. Classical Rhetoric and Its Christian and Secular Tradition from Ancient to Modern Times. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Kienpointner, Manfred. 2013. “Strategic Maneuvering in the Political Rhetoric of Barack Obama.” Journal of Language and Politics 12(3): 357–377.
Klotz, Peter. 1999. “Politeness and Political Correctness: Ideological Implications.” Pragmatics 9(1): 155–161.
Kramer, Elise. 2011. “The Playful is Political: The Metapragmatics of Internet Rape-joke Arguments.” Language in Society 40 (2): 137–168.
Lovenduski, Joni. 2012. “Prime Minister’s Questions as Political Ritual.” British Politics 7(4): 314–340.
Martin, James, Judi Atkins, Alan Finlayson, and Nick Turnbull (eds.). 2014 Rhetoric in British Politics and Society. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Meyer, Michel. 2010. “The Brussels School of Rhetoric: From the New Rhetoric to Problematology.” Philosophy and Rhetoric 43(4): 403–429.
Norrick, Neal R. 2018. “Narrative Studies versus Pragmatics (of Narrative).” In Pragmatics and Its Interfaces, ed. by Cornelia Ilie and Neal R. Norrick, 122–142. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Norris, Pippa. 2005. “Political Communications.” In International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences, ed. by James D. Wright. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Ornatowski, Cezar M. 2012. “The Idea of Politics in Political Rhetoric.” Forum Artis Rhetoricae 2: 7–21.
Perelman, Chaïm, and Lucie Olbrecht-Tyteca. 2006[1969]. The New Rhetoric: A Treatise on Argumentation. Trans. John Wilkinson, and Purell Weaver. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
Reicher, Stephen, and Nicolas Hopkins. 1996. “Self-category Constructions in Political Rhetoric: An Analysis of Thatcher’s and Kinnock’s Speeches Concerning the British Miners’ Strike (1984–85).” European Journal of Social Psychology 26(3): 353–371.
Rorty, Richard (ed). 1967. The Linguistic Turn: Recent Essays in Philosophical Method. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.
Roulet, Eddy. 1996. “Polyphony”. In J. Verschueren, Jan-Ola Östman, and Jan Blommaert (eds.), Handbook of Pragmatics. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Sanders, R. E. 1978. “Utterances, Actions, and Rhetorical Inquiry.” Philosophy and Rhetoric 11(2): 114–133.
Searle, John R. 1969. Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Subramanian, Ajantha. 2012. “Political Anthropology.” In Anthropology, ed. by John L. Jackson. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Turnbull, Nick. 2017. “Political Rhetoric and Its Relationship to Context: A New Theory of the Rhetorical Situation, the Rhetorical and the Political.” Critical Discourse Studies 14 (2): 115–131.
Tzanne, Angeliki. 1999. Talking at Cross-Purposes: The Dynamics of Miscommunication. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Walton, Douglas N. 1997. “Judging How Heavily a Question is Loaded: A Pragmatic Method.” Inquiry: Critical Thinking Across the Disciplines, vol. 17, 53–71.
2010. Appeal to Expert Opinion: Arguments from Authority. Philadelphia: Pennsylvania University Press.
Cited by (18)
Cited by 18 other publications
Amon, Marri, Marge Käsper & Anu Treikelder
Hoinărescu, Liliana
2024. Review of Ilie (2024): Manufacturing Dissent: Manipulation and Counter-manipulation in Times of Crisis. Journal of Language Aggression and Conflict
Marinho, Cristina & Michael Billig
2024. How can governments be prevented from manipulating statistics about Covid-19?. In Manufacturing Dissent [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 339], ► pp. 186 ff.
Stopfner, Maria
2024. Spanish influenza 1918/19. In Manufacturing Dissent [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 339], ► pp. 26 ff.
Strukowska, Marta E.
Botaș, Adina
2023. A dialogic speech act approach to ridiculing references in the French presidential debate of 2022. Language and Dialogue 13:3 ► pp. 364 ff.
Ilie, Cornelia
2021. Discussion, dispute or controversy?. Journal of Language Aggression and Conflict 9:2 ► pp. 237 ff.
Ilie, Cornelia
2021. Evasive answers vs. aggressive questions. In Questioning and Answering Practices across Contexts and Cultures [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 323], ► pp. 35 ff.
Ilie, Cornelia
2024. Manipulating citizens’ beliefs and emotions. In Manufacturing Dissent [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 339], ► pp. 85 ff.
Kuznyetsova, Ganna
Bjaiya al-mas'ud, Hameed Hassoon & Abdullah Muhammad Naif
Drew, Paul
2018. The interface between pragmatics and conversation analysis. In Pragmatics and its Interfaces [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 294], ► pp. 59 ff.
Fetzer, Anita
2018. Discourse pragmatics. In Pragmatics and its Interfaces [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 294], ► pp. 33 ff.
Haugh, Michael & Jonathan Culpeper
2018. Integrative pragmatics and (im)politeness theory. In Pragmatics and its Interfaces [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 294], ► pp. 213 ff.
House, Juliane
2018. Translation studies and pragmatics. In Pragmatics and its Interfaces [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 294], ► pp. 143 ff.
Norrick, Neal R.
2018. Narrative studies versus pragmatics (of narrative). In Pragmatics and its Interfaces [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 294], ► pp. 121 ff.
Pereira, Gerardine M.
2018. The interface between pragmatics and gesture studies. In Pragmatics and its Interfaces [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 294], ► pp. 163 ff.
Yus, Francisco
2018. The interface between pragmatics and internet-mediated communication. In Pragmatics and its Interfaces [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 294], ► pp. 267 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 28 november 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
