Article published In: Language and Linguistics
Vol. 18:3 (2017) ► pp.430–451
北京話連去變調的成因及其與詞重音的關係
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) 4.0 license.
For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at rights@benjamins.nl.
Article language: Undefined
Published online: 31 July 2017
https://doi.org/10.1075/lali.18.3.04hig
https://doi.org/10.1075/lali.18.3.04hig
抽象
北京話去聲連讀存在前去變成升調的社會變體,對於這種變體的成因,學界的看法不盡相同。本文用個案語音和文本分析的方法對北京話連去變調與詞重音之間的關係進行了研究。首先通過聲學測量和兩個聽辨實驗確定了變調樣本的重音格式,發現前去能夠變為升調的兩字組基本上都是聽感上的後重型。然後通過與若干輕音詞表的對比確認發生前去變調的雙音節詞在北京口語中不存在前重式。文章分析了北京話中兩種去聲變調格式——前去變為升調和後去變為低降調——的形成原因以及詞重音對變調格式的作用。作者認為,連去組合中的兩種變調格式實質上都是在重音保留本調原則、重讀音節同化非重讀音節原則和減少曲折原則的基礎上,相鄰音節音高同化作用的結果,同時,去聲連讀中的順向同化和逆向同化作用間接也說明了北京話的雙音節詞存在前重和後重兩種重音模式。
Abstract
Cause of Tone 4 sandhi in Beijing Mandarin and its relationship with lexical stress
In the social dialect of Beijing Mandarin, Tone 4 (T4), a falling tone, can turn into a rising tone when preceding another T4. Researchers have not been able to reach an agreement on the cause of the tone sandhi rule. This paper investigates the relationship between preceding-T4 sandhi and lexical stress based on the results of a speech case study and text analysis. First of all, two perceptual experiments and an acoustic measurement were conducted to verify stress patterns in disyllabic sample words where the preceding-T4 sandhi can occur. Results showed that in almost all of these samples, listeners confirmed they had final stress. Next, the chosen sample words were cross-checked with lists of neutral-tone words, which further proved they cannot have initial stress in spoken Beijing Mandarin. The causes of two patterns of T4 sandhi, namely, the preceding T4 changing to a rising tone and the following T4 changing to a low falling tone, and the effect of lexical stress on the sandhi patterns were analyzed. We argue that both T4 sandhi patterns are the results of assimilation between adjacent tones under the effects of Principle of Accentual Preservation, Principle of Accentual Attraction, and Principle of Up and Down, and that the effects of progressive and regressive assimilation in T4-sequences imply that two stress patterns—initial and final-stress patterns—exist in Beijing Mandarin.
Keywords: Beijing Mandarin, lexical stress, Tone 4, tone sandhi
Article outline
- 1.引言
- 2.變調樣本的獲取
- 2.1原始語料
- 2.2語料篩選
- 2.2.1清晰度和音步篩選
- 2.2.2變調樣本的確定
- 2.3聲學分析
- 2.4發音的認同
- 2.5與前人結果的對比
- 3.變調語料的重音模式
- 3.1重音的聽辨
- 3.2兩字組後重模式的進一步確認
- 3.2.1對前重樣本的分析
- 3.2.2與北京話輕聲詞表的對比
- 3.2.3述補式的重音格式
- 4.討論
- 4.1變調和後重的因果關係
- 4.2降調變為升調的成因
- 5.結論
- 謝辭
參考文獻
References (61)
Boersma, Paul, & David Weenink. 2012. Praat: Doing Phonetics by Computer [Computer Program] Version 5.3.35. Available at [URL] (accessed 8 December 2012).
Cao, Jianfen ( 曹劍芬). 1995. Liandu biandiao yu qingzhong duili 連續讀變調與輕重對立 [Tone sandhi and the stressed/unstressed opposition]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 1995.41: 312–320.
. (ed.) 2007. Xiandai Yuyin Yanjiu yu Tansuo 現代語音研究與探索 [
Study and Exploration of Contemporary Chinese Phonetics
], ed. by Jianfen Cao ( 曹劍芬). Beijing: The Commercial Press.
Cen, Qixiang ( 岑麒祥). 2013. Yuyinxue Gailun 語音學概論(修訂第二版) [
Outline of Phonetics
] (2nd edition). Beijing: The Commercial Press.
Chen, Zhangtai ( 陳章太), & Xingjian Li ( 李行健). 1996. Putonghua Jichu Fangyan Jiben Cihuiji: Yuyinjuan (Shang) 普通話基礎方言基本詞彙集: 語音卷(上) [
General Lexical Glossary of Basic Mandarin Dialects
], Vol. 11. Beijing: Language and Culture Press.
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (中國社會科學院語言研究所詞典編輯室). (eds.) 2012. Xiandai Hanyu Cidian 現代漢語詞典 [
Contemporary of Chinese Dictionary
] (6th edition). Beijing: The Commercial Press.
Chinese Dictionary Compiling Department (中國大辭典編纂處). 2011. Guoyu Cidian (Yingyin Ben) 國語辭典(影印本) [
Chinese Dictionary (Photocopy of original version)
]. Beijing: The Commercial Press.
Dong, Jianjiao ( 董建交). 2010. Beijinghua qusheng liandu biandiao moshi zaitan 北京話去聲連讀變調模式再探 [Further exploration into the tone sandhi pattern of qusheng (the fourth tone) in Beijing dialect]. Yuyan Yanjiu Jikan 語言研究集刊 [
Collected Papers on Language Studies
] 2010.71: 164–172.
Duanmu, San ( 端木三). 1999. Zhongyin lilun he Hanyu de cichang xuanze 重音理論和漢語的詞長選擇 [The accent theory and Chinese word length priority]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 1999.41: 246–254.
Hou, Jingyi ( 侯精一), & Duanzheng Wen ( 溫端政). 1993. Shanxi Fangyan Diaocha Yanjiu Baogao 山西方言調查研究報告 [
Report on Shanxi Dialect Investigation and Study
]. Taiyuan: Shanxi College Associated Press.
Hyman, Larry M. 1978. Historical tonology. Tone: A Linguistic Survey, ed. by Victoria A. Fromkin, 257–269. New York: Academic Press.
Jia, Yuan ( 賈媛). 2011. Putonghua tongyin yigou liangyinzu zhongyin leixing bianxi 普通話同音異構兩音組重音類型辨析 [Stress patterns of disyllabic words terms with identical pronunciation and different morph-syntactic structures in Standard Chinese]. Tsinghua Daxue Xuebao (Ziran Kexue Ban) 清華大學學報(自然科學版) [
Journal of Tsinghua University (Science and Technology)
] 2011.51.91: 1307–1312.
Jiang, Ping ( 蔣平), & Liuwen Xie ( 謝留文). 2001. Nanchangxian (Jiangxiang) fangyan de qingzhongyin yu biandiao 南昌縣(蔣巷)方言的輕重音與變調 [Stress and tone sandhi in Nanchang (Jiangxiang) dialect]. Fangyan 方言 [
Dialect
] 2001.21: 152–160.
Jiang, Ping ( 蔣平). 2005. Lipu fangyan de qingzhongyin yu lianxu biandiao 荔浦方言的輕重音與連讀變調 [Stress and tone sandhi in Lipu dialect]. Fangyan 方言 [
Dialect
] 2005.31: 198–208.
Jin, Song ( 勁松). 2002. Xiandai Hanyu Qingsheng Dongtai Yanjiu 現代漢語輕聲動態研究 [
Research on Diachronic Changes and Variations of Neutral Tone in Mandarin Chinese
]. Beijing: The Ethnic Publishing House.
Kratochvíl, Paul ( 巴維爾). 1987. Beijinghua zhengchang huayu li de qingsheng 北京話正常話語裡的輕聲 [Atonicity in normal Beijing dialect speech]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 1987.51: 330–345.
Li, Weimin ( 厲為民). 1981. Shilun qingsheng he zhongyin 試論輕聲和重音 [Tentative study of neutral tone and lexical stress]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 1981.11: 35–40.
Li, Xiaofan ( 李小凡). 2004. Hanyu fangyan liandu biandiao de cengji he leixing 漢語方言連讀變調的層級和類型 [Levels and classes of tone sandhi in the Chinese dialects]. Fangyan 方言 [
Dialect
] 2004.11: 16–33.
Lin, Maocan ( 林茂燦), Jingzhu Yan ( 顏景助), & Guohua Sun ( 孫國華). 1984. Beijinghua liangzizu zhengchang zhongyin de chubu shiyan 北京話兩字組正常重音的初步實驗 [Preliminary experiments on the normal stress in Beijing disyllables]. Fangyan 方言 [
Dialect
] 1984.11: 57–73.
Lin, Maocan ( 林茂燦), & Jingzhu Yan ( 顏景助). 1992. Putonghua siyinjieci he duanyu zhong shengdiao xietong fayin moshi 普通話四音節詞和短語中聲調協同發音模式 [Tonal coarticulation patterns in quadrisyllabic word and phrase of Mandarin]. Shengxue Xuebao 聲學學報 [
Acta Acustica
] 1992.17.61: 456–467.
Lin, Tao ( 林燾). 1957. Xiandai Hanyu buzuyu li de qingyin xianxiang suo fanying chulai de yufa he yuyi wenti 現代漢語補足語裡的輕音現象所反映出來的語法和語義問題 [Grammatical and lexical problems in the neutral tone of the predicative complement in Modern Chinese]. Beijing Daxue Xuebao (Renwen Kexue) 北京大學學報(人文科學) [
Journal of Peking University (Philosophy and Social Sciences)
] 1957.21: 61–74.
. 1985. Beijinghua qusheng lianxu biandiao xintan 北京話去聲連讀續變調新探 [A re-examination of tone sandhi in connection with the going tone (去聲) in the Beijing dialect]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 1985.21: 99–104.
Lin, Tao ( 林燾), & William S. -Y. Wang ( 王士元). 1985. Shengdiao ganzhi wenti 聲調感知問題 [The perception of tones]. Zhongguo Yuyan Xuebao 中國語言學報 [
The Journal of Linguistic Society of China
] 1985.21: 59–69.
Lin, Tao. 1987. A “new” phenomenon of tone sandhi in Beijing Mandarin. Phonologica 1984: Proceedings of the Fifth International Phonology Meeting, Eisenstadt, 25–28 June, 1984, ed. by Wolfgang U. Dressier, Hans C. Luschützky, Oskar E. Pfeiffer & John R. Rennison, 175–180. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lin, Tao ( 林燾). 1991. Beijing dongjiao yinyangping diaozhi de zhuanhua 北京東郊陰陽平調值的轉化 [The transfer of the tone value between 陰平 (even) and 陽平 (rising) in the eastern suburb of Beijing]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 1991.11: 21–26.
. 1992. “Rupai sansheng” bushi 「入派三聲」補釋 [Additional interpretation of the ‘redistribution of entering tone among other tones’]. Yuyanxue Luncong 語言學論叢 [
Essays on Linguistics
] 1992.171: 3–18.
Lin, Tao ( 林燾), & Lijia Wang ( 王理嘉). 1992. Yuyinxue Jiaocheng 語音學教程 [
A Course in Phonetics
]. Beijing: Peking University Press.
Liu, Lili ( 劉俐李). 2005. Hanyu shengdiao de qugong tezheng he jiangshi yin’gao 漢語聲調的曲拱特徵和降勢音高 [The contour features and fall pitch of Chinese tones]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 2005.31: 255–268.
Lu, Xun ( 魯迅). 2005. Luxun Quanji 魯迅全集 [
Complete Works of Lu Xun
], Vol. 51. Beijing: People’s Literature Publishing House.
Lu, Yunzhong ( 魯允中). 2001. Qingsheng he Erhua 輕聲和兒化 [
Neutral Tone and Erhua
]. Beijing: The Commercial Press.
Luo, Changpei ( 羅常培), & Jun Wang ( 王均). 1957. Putonghua Yuyinxue Gangyao 普通語音學綱要 [
Outline of General Phonetics
]. Beijing: Science Press.
Ni, Jiyu ( 倪寄予). 1957. Zhang Xunru : Beijinghua Qingsheng Cihui (shukan pingjie) 張洵如:《北京話輕聲詞彙》 (書刊評介) [Zhang Xunru: Dictionary Collection of Beijing Mandarin Neutral Tone Words (book review)]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 1957.121: 47.
Qing, Wei ( 卿瑋). 2014. Cong Cizhongyin ji Xietong Fayin Kan Chongqinghua Liangzizu Liandu Biandiao 從詞重音及協同發音看重慶話兩字組連讀變調 [
An Analysis on the Disyllabic Tone Sandhi of Chongqing Dialect from the Perspectives of Word Stress and Tonal Coarticulation
]. Beijing: Peking University MA thesis.
Research Group of Mandarin Phonetics of Chinese Character Reform Commission (中國文字改革委員會普通話語音研究班). 1963. Putonghua Qingshengci Huibian 普通話輕聲詞彙編 [
Dictionary Collection Neutral Tone Words in Mandarin
]. Beijing: The Commercial Press.
Shih, Chi-lin. 1986. The Prosodic Domain of Tone Sandhi in Chinese. San Diego: University of California, San Diego dissertation.
Song, Dandan ( 宋丹丹). 2007. Xingfu Shenchu 幸福深處 [
The Secrets of Happiness
]. Hubei: Changjiang Literature and Art Press.
Sun, Dejin ( 孫德金). 1989. Beijing Xijiao Huoqiying Manren de Beijinghua Diaocha 北京西郊火器營滿人的北京話調查 [
Research of the Beijing Dialect by Manchurians from Huoqiying of Beijing’s Western Suburbs
]. Beijing: Renmin University of China MA thesis.
. 1992. Jingxi Huoqiying manren de Beijinghua diaocha 京西火器營滿人的北京話調查 [Research of the Beijing dialect by Manchurians from Huoqiying of Beijing’s western suburbs]. Beijinghua Yanjiu 北京話研究 [
Study of the Beijing Dialect
], ed. by Mingyang Hu ( 胡明揚), 68–142. Beijing: Beijing Yanshan Press.
. 2005. Beijinghua qusheng liandu biandiao diaocha 北京話去聲連讀變調調查 [Studies of tone 4 sandhi in Beijing dialect]. Miaoxie yu Shizheng–Hanyu Yaosu de Duoshijiao Kaocha 描寫與實證—漢語要素的多視角考察 [
A Descriptive and Empirical Study of the Elements of Chinese—A Multi-Perspective Investigation
], ed. by Dejin Sun ( 孫德金), 221–231. Beijing: Beijing Language and Culture University Press.
Sun, Jingtao ( 孫景濤). 2002. Shilun “yu” zi shengdiao de buguize yanbian 試論「於」字聲調的不規則演變 [A discussion on the irregular tonal change of the word yu (於)]. Yuyanxue Luncong 語言學論叢 [
Essays on Linguistics
] 2002.261: 44–58.
Tong, Sheng-qiang ( 童盛強). 2002. Lieju zhuci “zheyang” 列舉助詞「這樣」 [The enumerative auxiliary word–“zheyang”]. Xibei Shida Xuebao (Shehui Kexue Ban) 西北師大學報(社會科學版) [
Journal of Northwest Normal University (Social Sciences)
] 2002.39.51: 83–86.
Wang, Hongjun ( 王洪君). 2008. Hanyu Feixianxing Yinxixue 漢語非線性音系學 [
Non-linear Phonology of Chinese
] (Revised edition). Beijing: Peking University Press.
Wang, Yunjia ( 王韞佳). 1993. Beijinghua Shengdiao Weiguan Bianhua de Shiyan Yanjiu 北京話聲調微觀變化的實驗研究 [
Micro-variation of Mandarin Tones
]. Beijing: Peking University dissertation.
Wang, Yunjia ( 王韞佳), Min Chu ( 初敏), Lin He ( 賀琳), & Yongqiang Feng ( 馮勇強). 2003. Lianxu huayu zhong shuangyinjie yunlüci de zhongyin ganzhi 連續話語中雙音節韻律詞的重音感知 [The perception of disyllabic word stress of Chinese speech in utterance]. Shengxue Xuebao 聲學學報 [
Acta Acustica
] 2003.28.61: 534–539.
Wang, Yunjia ( 王韞佳), Min Chu ( 初敏), & Lin He ( 賀琳). 2006. Hanyu jiaodian zhongyin he yuyi zhongyin fenbu de chubu shiyan yanjiu 漢語焦點重音和語義重音分佈的初步實驗研究 [An experimental study on the distribution of the focus-related and semantic accent in Chinese]. Shijie Hanyu Jiaoxue 世界漢語教學 [
Chinese Teaching in the World
] 2006.21: 86–98.
Wang, Yunjia ( 王韞佳), & Min Chu ( 初敏). 2008. Guanyu putonghua cizhongyin de ruogan wenti 關於普通話詞重音的若干問題 [Aspects of lexical stress in Mandarin]. Zhongguo Yuyin Xuebao 中國語音學報 [
Chinese Journal of Phonetics
] 2008.11: 141–147.
Wang, Zhijie ( 王志潔), & Shengli Feng ( 馮勝利). 2006. Shengdiao duibifa yu Beijinghua shuangyinzu de zhongyin leixing 聲調對比法與北京話雙音組的重音類型 [Tonal contrast and disyllabic stress patterns in Beijing Mandarin]. Yuyan Kexue 語言科學 [
Linguistic Sciences
] 2006.5.11: 3–22.
Wei, Gangqiang ( 魏鋼強) (ed.) 1998. Pingxiang Fangyan Cidian 萍鄉方言詞典 [
Pingxiang Dialect Dictionary
]. Nanjing: Jiangsu Educational Press.
Wu, Jiansheng ( 吳建生), & Hongyin Zhao ( 趙宏因). 1997. Wanrong Fangyan Cidian 萬榮方言詞典 [
Wanrong Dialect Dictionary
]. Nanjing: Jiangsu Educational Press.
Wu, Zongji ( 吳宗濟). 1985. Putonghua sanzizu biandiao guilü 普通話三字組變調規律 [Tone sandhi of trisyllabic combinations in Putonghua]. Zhongguo Yuyan Xuebao 中國語言學報 [
The Journal of Linguistic Society of China
] 1985.21: 70–92.
Xu, Shirong ( 徐世榮). 1990. Beijing Tuyu Cidian 北京土語辭典 [
Beijing Dialect Dictionary
]. Beijing: Beijing Publishing House.
Ye, Jun ( 葉軍). 1999. Hanyu Yuju Yunlü de Yufa Gongneng 漢語語句韻律的語法功能 [
The Grammatical Function of Prosody in Contemporary Chinese
]. Shanghai: Fudan University dissertation.
Yin, Zuoyan ( 殷作炎). 1982. Guanyu putonghua shuangyin changyongci qingzhongyin de chubu kaocha 關於普通話雙音常用詞輕重音的初步考察 [A preliminary study of accents and atonics in disyllabic words in common use]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [
Studies of the Chinese Language
] 1982.31: 168–173.
Zhang, Hongnian ( 張洪年). 1985. Zhenjiang fangyan de liandu biandiao 鎮江方言的連讀變調 [Tone sandhi in the Zhenjiang dialect]. Fangyan 方言 [
Dialect
] 1985.31: 191–204.
Zhang, Xunru ( 張洵如) (ed.). 1957. Beijinghua Qingsheng Cihui 北京話輕聲詞彙 [
Dictionary Collection of Beijing Mandarin Neutral Tone Words
]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company
Cited by (1)
Cited by one other publication
Wang, Tianheng
2025. Tones of Beijing dialect since 1900 and their
evolution. Language and Linguistics. 語言暨語言學 26:4 ► pp. 752 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 25 november 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
