In:Beyond Markedness in Formal Phonology
Edited by Bridget D. Samuels
[Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today 241] 2017
► pp. 191–218
Chapter 8Are there brain bases for phonological markedness?
Published online: 16 November 2017
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.241.08sch
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.241.08sch
Abstract
Pursuing the question of whether there are brain bases for phonological markedness necessitates an empirical and testable approach. This approach – put forward in this chapter – is couched in a theory of phonological feature specification and tested with brain imaging methods, with an emphasis on electrophysiology, encompassing electro- and magnetoencephalographic experiments. After sketching the theoretical background and introducing the basics of the reported brain measures, the chapter contains a review of some electrophysiological findings with their re-interpretation from the point of view of phonological markedness. Furthermore, the feature-approach is contrasted with a proposed reduction of phonological markedness to frequency-of-occurrence relations. Altogether, the review provides some important suggestions and starting points for further looking into the neurobiological reality of phonological markedness.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Some thoughts about the scope of markedness
- 3.Some notions about brain bases and how they can be measured
- 3.1fMRI studies
- 3.2EEG studies
- 3.3Stimulation studies
- 4.Linking markedness and the brain
- 4.1Markedness and perceptual asymmetries: The case of underspecification
- 4.1.1General assumptions
- 4.1.2Asymmetries in EEG responses
- 4.1.3An underspecification account of MMN asymmetries
- 4.1.4Alternative accounts: Do they fare better?
- 4.1.5Markedness and Predictive Coding
- 4.2Markedness and co-occurrence constraints
- 4.3Phonological markedness in relation to morphological markedness
- 4.1Markedness and perceptual asymmetries: The case of underspecification
- 5.Conclusions
References
References (116)
Aaltonen, Olli, Hellström, Åke, Peltola, Maija S., Savela, Janne, Tamminen, Henna & Lehtola, Heidi. 2008. Brain responses reveal hardwired detection of native-language rule violations. Neuroscience Letters 444(1): 56–59.
Aboitiz, Francisco, Aboitiz, Sebastián & García, Ricardo, R. 2010. The Phonological Loop: A key innovation in human evolution. Current Anthropology 51(S1): S55-S65.
Alexandrov, Alexander A., Boricheva, Daria O., Pulvermüller, Friedemann & Shtyrov, Yuri. 2011. Strength of word-specific neural memory traces assessed electrophysiologically. PLoS ONE 6(8): e22999.
Baayen, Harald, Piepenbrock, Richard & Gulikers, Leon. 1995. The CELEX Lexical Database [CD-Rom]. Philadelphia PA: Linguistic Data Consortium, University of Pennsylvania.
Baddeley, Alan, Lewis, Vivien & Vallar, Giuseppe. 1984. Exploring the articulatory loop. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 36: 233–252.
Baldeweg, Torsten. 2006. Repetition effects to sounds: Evidence for predictive coding in the auditory system. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 10(3):93–94.
Bar, Moshe. 2009. The proactive brain: Memory for predictions. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 364 (1521):1235–1243.
Beckman, Jill N. 1999. Positional Faithfulness: An Optimality Theoretic Treatment of Phonological Asymmetries. New York, NY: Routledge.
Berent, Iris, Brem Anna-Katharine, Zhao Xu, Seligson, Erica, Pan Hong, Epstein, Jane, Stern, Emily, Galaburda, Albert M. & Pascual-Leone, Alvaro. 2015. Role of the motor system in language knowledge. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 112 (7): 1983–1988.
Berent, Iris, Lennertz, Tracey, Jun, Jongho, Moreno, Miguel A. & Smolensky, Paul. 2008. Language universals in human brains. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 105(14): 5321–5325.
Berent Iris, Lennertz, Tracey & Smolensky, Paul. 2010. Syllable markedness and misperception: It’s a two-way street In Handbook of the Syllable, Charles E. Cairns & Eric Raimy (eds), 373–394. Leiden: Brill.
Bonte, Milene L., Mitterer, Holger, Zellagui, Nadia, Poelmans, Hanne & Blomert, Leo. 2005. Auditory cortical tuning to statistical regularities in phonology. Clinical Neurophysiology 116:2765–2774.
Breen, Mara, Kingston, John & Sanders, Lisa D. 2013. Perceptual representations of phonotactically illegal syllables. Attention, Perception & Psychophysics 75(1):101–120.
Burton, Martha W. 2001. The role of inferior frontal cortex in phonological processing. Cognitive Science 25(5): 695–709.
Burton, Martha W., Small, Steven L. & Blumstein, Sheila E. 2000. The role of segmentation in phonological processing: An fMRI investigation. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 12(4): 679–690.
Calabrese, Andrea. 1995. A constraint-based theory of phonological markedness and simplification procedures. Linguistic Inquiry 26(3): 373–463.
Callan, Daniel, Callan, Akiko, Gamez, Mario, Sato, Masa-aki & Kawato, Mitsuo. 2010. Premotor cortex mediates perceptual performance. Neuroimage 51(2): 844–858.
Carlson, Nicole L., Ming, Vivienne L. & DeWeese, Michael Robert. 2012. Sparse codes for speech predict spectrotemporal receptive fields in the inferior colliculus. PLoS Computational Biology 8(7).
Clements, George N. 1990. The role of the sonority cycle in core syllabification. In Papers in Laboratory Phonology, I: Between the Grammar and Physics of Speech, John Kingston & Mary E. Beckman (eds), 283–333. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Connolly, John F. & Phillips, Natalie A. 1994. Event-related potential components reflect phonological and semantic processing of the terminal word of spoken sentences. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 6(3): 256–266.
Cornell, Sonia A., Lahiri, Aditi & Eulitz, Carsten. 2011. “What you encode is not necessarily what you store”: Evidence for sparse feature representations from mismatch negativity. Brain Research 1394: 79–89.
. 2013. Inequality across consonantal contrasts in speech perception: Evidence from mismatch negativity. Journal of Experimental Psychology. Human Perception and Performance 39(3): 757–772.
D′Ausilio, Allesandro, Bufalari, Ilaria, Salmas, Paola & Fadiga, Luciano. 2012. The role of the motor system in discriminating normal and degraded speech sounds. Cortex 48(7): 882–887.
Davis Matthew H. & Johnsrude, Ingrid S. 2007. Hearing speech sounds: top-down influences on the interface between audition and speech perception. Hearing Research 229(1–2): 132–147.
Desai, Rutvik, Conant, Lisa L., Waldron, Eric & Binder, Jeffrey R. 2006. FMRI of past tense processing: The effects of phonological complexity and task difficulty. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 18(2): 278–297.
Doeller, Christian F., Opitz, Bertram, Mecklinger, Axel, Krick, Christoph, Reith, Wolfgang & Schröger, E. 2003. Prefrontal cortex involvement in preattentive auditory deviance detection: Neuroimaging and electrophysiological evidence. NeuroImage 20(2): 1270–1282.
Eulitz, Carsten & Lahiri Aditi. 2004. Neurobiological evidence for abstract phonological representations in the mental lexicon during speech recognition. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16(4): 577–583.
Frackowiak, Richard, Friston, Karl J., Frith, Christopher D., Dolan, Raymond J., Price, Cathy, Seki, Semir, Ashburner, John & Penny, William. 2004. Human Brain Function. London: Academic Press.
Friederici, Angela D. 2012. The cortical language circuit: From auditory perception to sentence comprehension. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 16(5): 262–268.
Friston, Karl J. 2005. A theory of cortical responses. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 360(1456): 815–815.
2010. The free-energy principle: A unified brain theory? Nature Reviews Neuroscience 11(2): 127–138.
Garrido, Marta I., Kilner, James M., Stephan, Klaas E. & Friston, Karl J. 2009. The mismatch negativity: A review of underlying mechanisms. Clinical Neurophysiology 120: 453–463.
Gelfand, Jenna R. & Bookheimer, Susan Y. 2003. Dissociating neural mechanisms of temporal sequencing and processing phonemes. Neuron 38(5): 831–842.
Hallé, Pierre A. & Best, Catherine T. 2007. Dental-to-velar perceptual assimilation: A cross-linguistic study of the perception of dental stop+/l/ clusters. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 121 (5 Pt1):2899–2914.
Hansen Peter C., Kringelbach, Morten L. & Salmelin, Riitta. 2010. MEG: An Introduction to Methods. Oxford: OUP.
Harinen, Kirsi & Rinne, Teemu. 2013. Activations of human auditory cortex to phonemic and nonphonemic vowels during discrimination and memory tasks. NeuroImage 77: 279–287.
Haspelmath, Martin. 2006. Against markedness (and what to replace it with). Journal of Linguistics 42(1): 25–70.
Hestvik, Arild & Durvasula, Karthik. 2015. Neurobiological evidence for voicing underspecification in English. Brain and Language 152: 28–43.
Hickok, Gregory. 2014. The Myth of Mirror Neurons: The Real Neuroscience of Communication and Cognition. New York NY: W.W. Norton & Company.
Hickok, Gregory & Poeppel, David. 2007. The cortical organization of speech processing. Nature Reviews. Neuroscience 8(5): 393–402.
Humphries, Colin, Sabri, Merav, Lewis, Kimberly & Liebenthal, Einat. 2014. Hierarchical organization of speech perception in human auditory cortex. Frontiers in Neuroscience 8.
Husain, Fatima T., Fromm, Stephen J., Pursley, Randall H., Hosey, Lara A., Braun, Allen R. & Horwitz, Barry. 2006. Neural bases of categorization of simple speech and nonspeech sounds. Human Brain Mapping 27(8): 636–651.
Jacobsen, Thomas & Schröger, Erich. 2001. Is there pre-attentive memory-based comparison of pitch? Psychophysiology 38(4): 723–727.
Joanisse, Mark F. & Seidenberg, Mark S. 2005. Imaging the past: Neural activation in frontal and temporal regions during regular and irregular past-tense processing. Cognitive, Affective & Behavioral Neuroscience 5(3): 282–296.
Kazanina, Nina, Phillips, Colin & Idsardi, William. The influence of meaning on the perception of speech sounds. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 103(30): 11381–11386.
Kutas, Marta, van Petten Cyma K. & Kluender, Robert. 2006. Psycholinguistics Electrified II (1994–2005). In Handbook of Psycholinguistics, Matthew J. Taxler & Morton Ann Gernsbacher (eds), 659–724. New York NY: Academic Press.
Kwong, Kenneth K., Belliveau, John W., Chesler, David A., Goldberg, Inna E., Weisskoff, Robert M., Poncelet, Brigitte P., Kennedy, David N., Hoppel, Bernice E., Cohen, Mark S. & Turner, Robert. 1992. Dynamic magnetic resonance imaging of human brain activity during primary sensory stimulation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 89(12): 5675–5679.
Lahiri, Aditi & Reetz, Henning. 2002. Underspecified recognition. In Laboratory Phonology VII, Carlos Gussenhoven & Natasha Warner (eds), 637–677. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
. 2010. Distinctive features: Phonological underspecification in representation and processing. Journal of Phonetics 38: 44–59.
Lawyer, Laurel & Corina, David. An investigation of place and voice features using fMRI-adaptation. Journal of Neurolinguistics 27(1). .
Lee, Jin Hyung, Durand, Remy, Gradinaru, Viviana, Zhang, Feng, Goshen, Inbal, Kim, Dae-Shik, Fenno, Lief E., Ramakrishnan, Charu & Deisseroth, Karl. 2010. Global and local fMRI signals driven by neurons defined optogenetically by type and wiring. Nature 465 (7299): 788–792.
Liebenthal, Einat, Sabri, Merav, Beardsley, Scott A., Mangalathu-Arumana, Jain & Desai, Anjali. 2013. Neural dynamics of phonological processing in the dorsal auditory stream. The Journal of Neuroscience 33(39):15414–15424.
LoCasto, Paul C., Krebs-Noble, Donna, Gullapalli, Rao P. & Burton, Martha W. 2004. An fMRI investigation of speech and tone segmentation. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16 (9): 1612–1624.
Logothetis, Nikos K. & Wandell, Brian A. 2004. Interpreting the BOLD signal. Annual Review of Physiology 66: 735–769.
Maiste, Anita C., Wiens, Andrew S., Hunt, Melvyn J., Scherg, Michael & Picton, Terence W. 1995. Event-related potentials and the categorical perception of speech sounds. Ear and Hearing 16(1): 68–90.
Marcus, Gary F., Brinkmann, Ursula, Clahsen, Harald, Wiese, Richard & Pinker, Steven. 1995. German inflection: The exception that proves the rule. Cognitive Psychology 29: 189–256.
Meyer, Lars, Obleser, Jonas, Anwander, Alfred & Friederici, Angela D. 2012. Linking ordering in Broca’s area to storage in left temporo-parietal regions: The case of sentence processing. NeuroImage 62(3): 1987–1998.
Miglietta, Sandra, Grimaldi, Mirko & Calabrese, Andrea. 2013. Conditioned allophony in speech perception: An ERP study. Brain and Language 126(3): 285–290.
Miglio, Viola Giulia. 2005. Interactions between Markedness and Faithfulness Constraints in Vowel Systems. New York, NY: Routledge.
Mitterer, Holger. 2011. The mental lexicon is fully specified: Evidence from eye-tracking. Journal of Experimental Psychology. Human Perception and Performance 37(2): 496–513.
Molfese, Dennis L., Molfese, Victoria J. & Kelly, Spencer. 2001. The use of brain electrophysiology techniques to study language: A basic guide for the beginning consumer of electrophysiology information. Learning Disability Quarterly 24(3): 177–188.
Moreton, Elliott. 2002. Structural constraints in the perception of English stop-sonorant clusters. Cognition 84(1): 55–71.
Möttönen, Riikka, van de Ven, Guido M. & Watkins, Kate E. 2014. Attention fine-tunes auditory-motor processing of speech sounds. The Journal of Neuroscience 34(11): 4064–4069.
Näätänen, Risto, Lehtokoski, Anna, Lennes, Mietta, Cheour, Marie, Huotilainen, Minna, Ilvonen, Antti, Vainio, Martti, Alku, Paavo, Ilmoniemi, Risto J., Luuk, Aavo, Allik, Jüri, Sinkkonen, Janne & Alho, Kimmo. 1997. Language-specific phoneme representations revealed by electric and magnetic brain responses. Nature 385: 432–434.
Näätänen, Risto, Paavilainen, Petri, Rinne, Teemu & Alho, Kimmo. 2007. The mismatch negativity (MMN) in basic research of central auditory processing: A review. Clinical Neurophysiology 118(12): 2544–2590.
Näätänen, Risto & Winkler, István. 1999. The concept of auditory stimulus presentation in cognitive neuroscience. Psychological Bulletin 125: 826–859.
Newman, Randy Lynn & Connolly, John F. 2009. Electrophysiological markers of pre-lexical speech processing: Evidence for bottom-up and top-down effects on spoken word processing. Biological Psychology 80(1): 114–121.
Obleser, Jonas, Boecker, Henning, Drzezga, Alexander, Haslinger, Bernhard, Hennenlotter, Andreas, Roettinger, Michael, Eulitz, Carsten & Rauschecker, Joseph P. 2006. Vowel sound extraction in anterior superior temporal cortex. Human Brain Mapping 27(7): 562–571.
Obleser, Jonas & Eisner, Frank. 2009. Pre-lexical abstraction of speech in the auditory cortex. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 13(1): 14–199.
Oh, Tomasina M, Tan, Keith Liming, Ng, Phillina, Berne, Yeh Ing & Graham, Steven. 2011. The past tense debate: Is phonological complexity the key to the puzzle? NeuroImage 57(1): 271–280.
Peelle, Jonathan E., Johnsrude, Ingrid S. & Davis, Matthew H. 2010. Hierarchical processing for speech in human auditory cortex and beyond. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 4: 51.
Pertsova, Katya. 2015. Interaction of morphological and phonological markedness in Russian genitive plural allomorphy. Morphology 25(2): 229–266.
Peter, Varghese, McArthur, Genevieve & Thompson, William Forde. 2010. Effect of deviance direction and calculation method on duration and frequency mismatch negativity (MMN). Neuroscience Letters 482(1): 71–75.
Phillips, Colin, Pellathy, Thomas, Marantz, Alec, Yellin, Elron, Wexler, Kenneth, Poeppel, David, McGinnis, Martha & Roberts, Timothy. 2000. Auditory cortex accesses phonological categories: An MEG mismatch study. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 12: 1038–1105.
Pinker, Steven & Ullman, Michael T. 2002. The past and future of the past tense. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 6(11): 456–463.
Plaut, David C. & Gonnerman, Laura M. 2000. Are non-semantic morphological effects incompatible with a distributed connectionist approach to lexical processing? Language and Cognitive Processes 15(4–5): 445–485.
Poeppel, David, Idsardi, William J. & van Wassenhove, Virginie. 2008. Speech perception at the interface of neurobiology and linguistics. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 363(1493): 1071–1086.
Politzer-Ahles, Stephen, Schluter, Kevin, Wu, Kefei & Almeida, Diogo. 2016. Asymmetries in the perception of Mandarin tones: Evidence from mismatch negativity. Journal of Experimental Psychology. Human Perception and Performance 2: 1547–1570.
Praamstra, Peter, Meyer, Antje S. & Levelt, Willem J. M. 1994. Neurophysiological manifestations of phonological processing: Latency variation of a negative ERP component timelocked to phonological mismatch. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 6(3): 204–219.
Price, Cathy J., Wise, Richard J., Warburton, E. A., Moore, C. J., Howard, David, Patterson, Karalyn, Frackowiak, Richard S. & Friston, Karl J. 1996. Hearing and saying. The functional neuro-anatomy of auditory word processing. Brain: A Journal of Neurology 119( Pt 3): 919–931.
Prince, Alan & Smolensky, Paul. 2004. Optimality Theory – Constraint Interaction in Generative Grammar. Malden MA: Blackwell.
Pulvermüller, Friedemann & Fadiga, Luciano. 2010. Active perception: Sensorimotor circuits as a cortical basis for language. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 11: 351–360.
Pulvermüller, Friedemann, Kujala, Teija, Shtyrov, Yuri, Simola, Jaana, Tiitinen, Hannu, Alku, Paavo, Alho, Kimmo, Martinkauppi, Sami, Illmoniemi, Risto J. & Näätänen, Risto. 2001. Memory traces for words as revealed by the mismatch negativity. Neuroimage 14: 607–616.
Rauschecker, Joseph P. & Scott, Sophie K. 2009. Maps and streams in the auditory cortex: Nonhuman primates illuminate human speech processing. Nature Neuroscience 12(6): 718–724.
Rimol, Lars M., Specht, Karsten, Weis, Susanne, Savoy, Robert & Hugdahl, Kenneth. Processing of sub-syllabic speech units in the posterior temporal lobe: An fMRI study. NeuroImage 26 (4): 1059–1067.
Roberts, Adam C., Kotzor, Sandra, Wetterlin, Allison & Lahiri, Aditi. 2014. Asymmetric processing of durational differences – Electrophysiological investigations in Bengali. Neuropsychologia 58: 88–98.
Scharinger, Mathias, Bendixen, Alexandra, Trujillo-Barreto, Nelsen J. & Obleser, Jonas. A sparse neural code for some speech sounds but not for others. PLoS ONE, 7(7):e40953. .
Scharinger, Mathias, Eulitz, Carsten & Lahiri, Aditi. 2010. Mismatch negativity effects of alternating vowels in morphologically complex word forms. Journal of Neurolinguistics 23(4): 383–399.
Scharinger, Mathias, Idsardi, William J. & Poe, Samantha. 2011. Neuromagnetic reflections of harmony and constraint violations in Turkish. Journal of Laboratory Phonology 2(1): 99–124.
Scharinger, Mathias, Merickel, Jennifer, Riley, Joshua & Idsardi, William J. 2011. Neuromagnetic evidence for a featural distinction of English consonants: Sensor- and source-space data. Brain and Language 116: 71–82.
Scharinger, Mathias, Monahan, Philip J. & Idsardi, William J. 2012. Asymmetries in the processing of vowel height. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 55: 903–918.
Schluter, Kevin, Politzer-Ahles, Stephen & Almeida, Diogo. 2016. No place for /h/: An ERP investigation of English fricative place features. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 31(6):728–740.
Schröger, Erich. 2005. The mismatch negativity as a tool to study auditory processing. Acta Acústica 91: 490–501.
Sharma, Anu & Dorman, Michael F. 2000. Neurophysiologic correlates of cross-language phonetic perception. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 107(5 Pt 1): 2697–2703.
Shtyrov, Yuri, Osswald, Katja & Pulvermüller, Friedemann. 2008. Memory traces for spoken words in the brain as revealed by the hemodynamic correlate of the mismatch negativity. Cerebral Cortex 18(1): 29–37.
Siebner, Hartwig R., Hartwigsen, Gesa, Kassuba, Tanja & Rothwell, John C. 2009. How does transcranial magnetic stimulation modify neuronal activity in the brain? Implications for studies of cognition. Cortex; A Journal Devoted to the Study of the Nervous System and Behavior 45(9): 1035–1042.
Steriade, Donca. 1995. Underspecification and markedness. In The Handbook of Phonological Theory, John A. Goldsmith (ed.), 114–174. Oxford: Blackwell.
Stockall, Linnaea & Marantz, Alec. 2006. A single route, full decomposition model of morphological complexity: MEG evidence. The Mental Lexicon 1(1): 85–123.
Trubetzkoy, Nikolai S. 1936. Essai d’une theorie des oppositions phonologiques. Journal de Psychologie Normale et Pathologique 33: 5–18.
Truckenbrodt, Hubert, Steinberg, Johanna, Jacobsen, Thomas K. & Jacobsen, Thomas. 2014. Evidence for the role of German final devoicing in pre-attentive speech processing: A mismatch negativity study. Frontiers in Psychology 5: 1317.
Ullman, Michael T. 2001. The Declarative/Procedural model of lexicon and grammar. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 30(1): 37–69.
Winkler, István. 2007. Interpreting the Mismatch Negativity. Journal of Psychophysiology 21(3–4): 147–163.
Winkler, István, Karmos, George & Näätänen, Risto. 1996. Adaptive modeling of the unattended acoustic environment reflected in the mismatch negativity event-related potential. Brain Research 742(1–2) :239–252.
Winkler, István, Lehtokoski, Anne, Alku, Paavo, Vainio, Martti, Czigler, Istvan, Csepe, Valeria, Aaltonen, Olli, Raimo, Ilkka, Alho, Kimmo, Lang, Heikki, Iivonen, Antti & Näätänen, Risto. 1999. Pre-attentive detection of vowel contrasts utilizes both phonetic and auditory memory representations. Cognitive Brain Research 7(3): 357–369.
Cited by (1)
Cited by one other publication
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 22 november 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
