In:Structures, Strategies and Beyond: Studies in honour of Adriana Belletti
Edited by Elisa Di Domenico, Cornelia Hamann and Simona Matteini
[Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today 223] 2015
► pp. 343–368
Minimality effects in children’s passives
Published online: 27 August 2015
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.223.16sny
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.223.16sny
Many studies find true verbal passives in English acquired only after age four, but some find three-year-olds fully adultlike. We explain this discrepancy using Relativized Minimality (RM, Rizzi 2004). Collins (2005a) argues the passive involves movement of the logical object across the logical subject (either PRO, or a lexical DP with ‘by’), and normally this requires smuggling. We propose smuggling is maturationally unavailable until age four. Three-year-olds succeed only if the intervener is eliminated, as in certain Romance reflexive-clitic constructions; or if +Topic/+WH on the logical object can prevent an RM violation, as in certain studies of the English passive. Following Grillo (2008), we explain the still-later acquisition of non-actional passives by their need for both smuggling and semantic coercion.
Keywords: language acquisition, maturation, minimality, passive, smuggling
References (76)
Adani, Flavia, van der Lely, Heather, Forgiarini, Matteo & Guasti, Maria Teresa. 2010. Grammatical feature dissimilarities make relatives clauses easier: A comprehension study with Italian children. Lingua 120(9): 2148–2166.
Baker, Mark. 1988. Incorporation: A Theory of Grammatical Function Changing. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press.
Baker, Mark, Johnson, Kyle & Roberts, Ian. 1989. Passive arguments raised. Linguistic Inquiry 20: 219–251.
Belletti, Adriana. 2009. Notes on passive object relatives. In Functional Structure from Top to Toe, Peter Svenonius (ed.), 97–114. Oxford: OUP.
Belletti, Adriana & Contemori, Carla. 2010. Intervention and attraction: On the production of subject and object relatives by Italian young children and adults. In Language Acquisition and Development: Proceedings of GALA 2009, João Costa, Maria Lobo & Fernanda Pratas, 39–52. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars.
Belletti, Adriana, Friedmann, Naama, Brunato, Dominique & Rizzi, Luigi. 2012. Does gender make a difference? Comparing the effect of gender on children’s comprehension of relative clauses in Hebrew and Italian. Lingua 122(10): 1053–1069.
Bever, Thomas G. 1970. The cognitive basis for linguistic structures. In Cognition and the Development of Language, John R. Hayes (ed.), 279–362. New York NY: John Wiley & Sons.
Borer, Hagit & Wexler, Kenneth. 1987. The maturation of syntax. In Parameter Setting, Thoma Roeper & Alexander E. Williams (eds), 23–172. Dordrecht: Reidel.
. 1992. Bi-unique relations and the maturation of grammatical principles. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 10: 147–189.
Cipriani, Paola, Pfanner, Pietro, Chilosi, Anna, Cittadoni, Lorena, Ciuti, Alessandro, Maccari, Anna, Pantano, Natalia, Pfanner, Lucia, Poli, Paola, Sarno, Stefania, Bottari, Piero, Cappelli, Giuseppe, Colombo, C. & Veneziano, Edy. 1989. Protocolli diagnostici e terapeutici nello sviluppo e nella patologia del linguaggio (1/84 Italian Ministry of Health/Ministero della Salute). Pisa: Stella Maris Foundation.
Crain, Stephen, Thornton, Rosalind & Murasugi, Keiko. 2009. Capturing the evasive passive. Language Acquisition 16(2): 123–133.
Crawford, Jean. 2004. The Acquisition of the Sesotho Passive: Reanalyzing a Counterexample to Maturation. MA thesis, Boston University.
. 2012. Developmental Perspectives on the Acquisition of the Passive. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Connecticut.
De Cat, Cécile & Plunkett, Bernadette. 2002. QU’ est ce qu’ i(l) dit, celui+Là? Notes méthodologiques sur la transcription d’un corpus francophone. In Romanistische Korpuslinguistik: Korpora und gesprochene Sprache/Romance Corpus Linguistics: Corpora and Spoken Language, Claus D. Pusch & Wolfgang Raible (eds). Tübingen: Narr.
Demuth, Katherine. 1990. Subject, topic and Sesotho passive. Journal of Child Language 17(1): 67–84.
Demuth, Katherine, Moloi, Francina & Machobane, Malillo. 2010. Three-year-olds’ comprehension, production, and generalization of Sesotho passives. Cognition 115(2): 238–251.
de Villiers, Jill & de Villiers, Peter. 1985. The acquisition of English. In The Crosslinguistic Study of Language Acquisition, Vol. 1: The Data, Dan I. Slobin (ed.), 27–141. Hillsdale NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Friedmann, Naama. 2007. Young children and A-chains: The acquisition of Hebrew unaccusatives. Language Acquisition 14: 377–422.
Friedmann, Naama, Belletti, Adriana & Rizzi, Luigi. 2009. Relativized relatives: Types of intervention in the acquisition of A-bar dependencies. Lingua 119: 67–88.
Friedmann, Naama & Costa, Joao. 2011. Acquisition of SV and VS Order in Hebrew, European Portuguese, Palestinian Arabic, and Spanish. Language Acquisition 18: 1–38.
Friedmann, Naama, & Costa, Joao. 2012. Children acquire unaccusatives and A-movment very early. In The Theta System: Argument Structure at the Interface, Martin Everaert, Marijana Marelj, & Tal Siloni (eds), Oxford: OUP.
Froud, Karen, Tsakali, Vina & Wexler, Kenneth. 2010. Late maturation of Raising in English: Evidence from typically developing children. Poster presented at Generative Approaches to Language Acquisition: North America (GALANA), Philadelphia PA, September.
Ganger, Jennifer, Dunn, Sabrina & Gordon, Peter. 2005. Genes take over when the input fails: A twin study of the passive. In A Supplement to the Proceedings of the 29th Annual Boston Conference on Language Development, Alejna Brugos, Manuella R. Clark-Cotton & Seungwan Ha (eds), Somerville MA: Cascadilla Press.
Gavarró, Anna & Parramon, Xavier. 2011. The acquisition of Catalan passives and the adjectival interpretation. Paper presented at the Linguistic Symposium on Romance Languages, University of Ottawa, May.
Gehrke, Berit & Grillo, Nino. 2008. How to become passive. In Explorations of Phase Theory: Features, Arguments, and Interpretation at the Interfaces, Kleanthes K. Grohmann (ed.), 231–268. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Gorden, Peter & Chafetz, Jill. 1990. Verb-based versus class-based accounts of actionality effects in children’s comprehension of passives. Cognition 36: 227–254.
Grillo, Antonino. 2008. Generalized minimality: Syntactic underspecification in Broca’s Aphasia. Utrecht: LOT.
Gualmini, Andrea, Hulsey, Sarah, & Hacquard, Valentine. 2008. The question–answer requirement for scope assignment. Natural Language Semantics 16: 205–237.
Hirsch, Christopher & Wexler, Kenneth. 2004. Who seems to rescue raising. Poster presented at the Inaugural Conference on Generative Approaches to Language Acquisition – North America, University of Hawai’i at Manoa, December.
Hirsch, Christopher, Modyanova, Nadia & Wexler, Kenneth. 2006. Predicting passive acquisition: Environmental factors and biological maturation. Paper presented at Scandinavian Conference of Linguistics, Workshop in Language Acquisition, Aalborg, Denmark.
Hirsch, Christopher & Wexler, Kenneth. 2006. Children’s passives and their resulting interpretation. In The Proceedings of the Inaugural Conference on Generative Approaches to Language Acquisition North America [UCONN Occasional Papers in Linguistics 4], Kamil Ud Deen, Jun Nomura, Barbara Schulz & Bonnie D. Schwartz (eds), 125–136.
Hirsch, Christopher, Orfitelli, Robyn, & Wexler, Kenneth. 2007. When seem means think: The role of the experiencer-phrase in children’s comprehension of raising. In Galana 2 – Proceedings of the Conference on Generative Approaches to Language Acquisition North America 2, Alyona Belikova, Luisa Meroni & Mari Umeda (eds), 135–146. Somerville MA: Cascadilla Press.
. 2008. The acquisition of raising reconsidered. In Proceedings of the Conference on Generative Approaches to Language Acquisition, Anna Gavarro & M. João Freitas (eds), 253–262. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Press.
Hirsch, Christopher. 2011. The Acquisition of Raising. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT.
Hyams, Nina & Snyder, William. 2005. Young children never smuggle: Reflexive clitics and the Universal Freezing Hypothesis. Paper presented at the Boston University Conference on Language Development, 5 November 2005. <[URL]>
. 2006. Young children are frozen: Reflexive clitics and the Universal Freezing Hypothesis. Ms, UCLA/UConn. <[URL]>
Lorusso, Paolo. 2003. L’acquisizione dei verbi inaccusativi: Studio sull’acquisizione spontanea dei parlanti. MA thesis, University of Siena.
Lorusso, Paolo, Caprin, Claudia & Guasti, Maria-Teresa. 2005. Overt subject distribution in early Italian children.
Supplement Proceeding of Boston University Conference on Language Development
. <[URL]>
MacWhinney, B. 2000. The CHILDES Project: Tools for Analyzing Talk, 3rd edn. Mahwah NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Manetti, Claudia. 2012. The Acquisition of Italian Passives: Evidence from Comprehension, Production and Syntactic Priming Studies. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Siena.
Manetti, Claudia & Belletti, Adriana. 2013. Causatives and the acquisition of the Italian passive. Paper presented at GALA 2013, University of Oldenburg, Germany.
Maratsos, Michael P., Fox, Dana, Becker, Judith & Chalkley, Mary Ann. 1985. Semantic restrictions on children’s early passives. Cognition 19: 167–191.
Meints, Kirsten. 1999. Protoypes and the acquisition of passives. In Perspectives on Cognitive Science, Vol. 4, B. Kokinov (ed.), 67–77. Sofia: NBU Press.
Nevins, Andrew. 2002. Vdef & MLC: Why English passives might be tough for kids. Ms, MIT.
O’Brien, Karen, Elaine Grolla & Lillo-Martin, Diane. 2006. Non-actional passives are understood by young children. In Proceedings of the 30th annual Boston Conference on Language Development, David Bamman, Tatiana Magnitskaia & Colleen Zaller (eds), 441–451. Somerville MA: Cascadilla Press.
Orfitelli, Robyn. 2012a. Experiencing a slight delay: Intervening arguments and the acquisition of subject-to-subject raising. In Proceedings of the 36th Boston University Conference on Language Development, Vol. 2, Alia K. Biller, Esther Y. Chung & Amelia E. Kimball (eds), 374–386. Somerville MA: Cascadilla Press.
. 2012b. Argument Intervention in the Acquisition of A-movement. Ph.D. dissertation, UCLA.
Pinker, Steven, LeBeaux, David S. & Frost, Loren Ann. 1987. Productivity and constraints in the acquisition of the passive. Cognition 26: 195–267.
. 2001. Relativized minimality effects. In The Handbook of Contemporary Syntactic Theory, Mark Baltin & Chris Collins (eds), 89–110. Oxford: Blackwell.
. 2004. Locality and Left Periphery. In Structures and Beyond. The Cartography of Syntactic Structure, Vol. 3, Adriana Belletti (ed.), 223–251. Oxford: OUP.
Roberts, Craigie. 2011. Topics. In Semantics: An International Handbook of Natural Language Meaning, Vol. 2, Claudia Maienborn, Klaus von Heusinger & Paul Portner (eds), 1908–1934. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
Roeper, Thomas. 1987. Implicit arguments and the head-complement relation. Linguistic Inquiry 18: 267–310.
Snyder, William, Hyams, Nina & Crisma, Paola. 1995. Romance auxiliary selection with reflexive clitics: Evidence for early knowledge of unaccusativity. In The Proceedings of the Twenty-sixth Annual Child Language Research Forum, Eve V. Clark (ed.), Stanford CA: CSLI.
Snyder, William & Hyams, Nina. 2008. Children’s passives: The role of discourse features. Paper presented in the Psycholinguistics Brownbag Series, University of Connecticut, Storrs. <[URL]> (6 September 2008).
Sportiche, Dominique. 1998. Movement, agreement and case. In Partitions and Atoms of Clause Structure, Dominiquie Sportische (ed.), London: Routledge.
. 2008. Reflexive constructions in French (and in other Romance languages and elsewhere). UCLA Lecture Notes, Spring.
. 2010. French reflexive se: Binding and Merge locality. <[URL]>
Starke, Michel. 2001. Move Dissolves into Merge: A Theory of Locality. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Geneva.
Stromswold, Karin, Pinker, Steven & Kaplan, Ronald M. 1985. Cues for understanding the passive voice. In Papers and Reports in Child Language, 24. Stanford CA: Stanford University Department of Linguistics.
Suppes, Patrick, Smith, Robert & Léveillé, Madeleine. 1973. The French syntax of a child’s noun phrases. Archives de Psychologie 42: 207–269.
Suzman, Susan. 1985. Learning the passive in Zulu. Papers and Reports on Child Language Development 24: 131–137.
Travis, Lisa. 2000. Event structure in syntax. In Events as Grammatical Objects: The Converging Perspectives of Lexical Semantics and Syntax, Carol Tenny & James Pustejovsky (eds), 145–185. Stanford CA: CSLI.
Turner, Elizabeth Ann & Rommetveit, Ragnar. 1967. The acquisition of sentence voice and reversibility. Child Development 38(3): 649–660.
Volpato, Francesca, Tagliaferro, Laura, Verin, Laura & Cardinaletti Anna. 2013. The comprehension of (eventive) verbal passives by Italian preschool age children. In Advances in Language Acquisition, Stavroula Stavrakaki, Marina Lalioti & Polyxeni Konstantinopoulou (eds), 243–250. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars.
Volpato, Francesca, Verin, Laura & Cardinaletti, Anna. 2012. The acquisition of passives in Italian: Auxiliaries and answering strategies in an experiment of elicited production. Paper presented at The Romance Turn V, Universidade Nova de Lisboa.
Cited by (38)
Cited by 38 other publications
Agostinho, Celina, Anna Gavarró & Ana Lúcia Santos
Correia, Liliana, Maria Lobo & Cristina Flores
Hyams, Nina
2025. Children’s sluices. In Footprints of Phrase Structure [Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today, 288], ► pp. 170 ff.
Janke, Vikki & Gloria Chamorro
Liu, Minqi, Victoria Mateu & Nina Hyams
AL-Junaid , Najwa Ahmad , Amal Thneibat , Abdel Rahman Altakhaineh & Hiba Alhendi
Albedaiwi, Bayan & Yasser Albaty
Du, Jiao, Stephanie Durrleman, Xiaowei He & Haopeng Yu
Du, Jiao, Xiaowei He & Haopeng Yu
Du, Jiao, Xiaowei He & Haopeng Yu
Henke, Ryan E., Julie Brittain, Kamil U. Deen & Sara Acton
Aravind, Athulya & Loes Koring
Shin, Gyu-Ho & Kamil Ud Deen
Stanford, Emily & Hélène Delage
McKee, Cecile, Dana McDaniel & Merrill F. Garrett
Paolazzi, Caterina Laura, Nino Grillo, Claudia Cera, Fani Karageorgou, Emily Bullman, Wing Yee Chow & Andrea Santi
Sánchez Calderón, Silvia & Raquel Fernández Fuertes
Agostinho, Celina & Anna Gavarró Algueró
2021. The acquisition of verbal passives by Portuguese-speaking children. In Romance Languages and Linguistic Theory 2017 [Current Issues in Linguistic Theory, 355], ► pp. 9 ff.
Nguyen, Emma & Lisa Pearl
Santos, Ana Lúcia
2021. Some thoughts on (the acquisition of) control. In L1 Acquisition and L2 Learning [Language Acquisition and Language Disorders, 65], ► pp. 83 ff.
Mateu, Victoria Eugenia
Minai, Utako
Belletti, Adriana & Claudia Manetti
GRILLO, NINO, ARTEMIS ALEXIADOU, BERIT GEHRKE, NILS HIRSCH, CATERINA PAOLAZZI & ANDREA SANTI
Mateu, Victoria & Nina Hyams
2019. On the learnability of implicit arguments. In Three Streams of Generative Language Acquisition Research [Language Acquisition and Language Disorders, 63], ► pp. 185 ff.
Mateu, Victoria & Nina Hyams
Paolazzi, Caterina Laura, Nino Grillo, Artemis Alexiadou & Andrea Santi
Pinto, Manuela & Shalom Zuckerman
Borga, Jason & William Snyder
2018. French experiencer verbs and the Universal Freezing Hypothesis. In On the Acquisition of the Syntax of Romance [Language Acquisition and Language Disorders, 62], ► pp. 7 ff.
de Lima Júnior, João Claudio, Marina Rosa Ana Augusto & Letícia M. Sicuro Corrêa
2018. Discrimination of passive predicates by Brazilian Portuguese-speaking children. In On the Acquisition of the Syntax of Romance [Language Acquisition and Language Disorders, 62], ► pp. 31 ff.
de Lima Júnior, João Claudio, Letícia M. Sicuro Corrêa & Marina Rosa Ana Augusto
2018. Favorable processing conditions in the production of passive sentences by Brazilian Portuguese-speaking children. In On the Acquisition of the Syntax of Romance [Language Acquisition and Language Disorders, 62], ► pp. 91 ff.
Jensen de López, Kristine, Kristen Schroeder & Anna Gavarró
CHOE, JINSUN & WILLIAM O'GRADY
Hyams, Nina & Robyn Orfitelli
Santos, Ana Lúcia, Anabela Gonçalves & Nina Hyams
[no author supplied]
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 22 november 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
