"Thunder Is When the Angels Are Upstairs Bowling": Narratives and Explanations at the Dinner Table

Beals, Diane E.; Snow, Catherine E.

doi:10.1075/jnlh.4.4.06thu

Article published In: Historical Representation
[Journal of Narrative and Life History 4:4] 1994
► pp. 331–352

Get fulltext from our e-platform

Download PDF

"Thunder Is When the Angels Are Upstairs Bowling": Narratives and Explanations at the Dinner Table

Diane E. Beals | Washington University

Catherine E. Snow | Harvard University

Published online: 4 August 2015

https://doi.org/10.1075/jnlh.4.4.06thu

Abstract The domain of narrative is often assumed to be the first extended discourse genre accessible to young children, and a natural mode for representing and remembering information. Ultimately, however, children must move beyond narrative to include other genres within their competency, such as explanation. Furthermore, narrative and explanation share a number of features that might lead one to expect more or less parallel development. We studied the occurrence of narrative and explanatory sequences of talk during mealtimes in 31 lowincome families with preschool-aged children. Narrative and explanatory sequences constituted approximately equal percentages of the total talk, but explanatory sequences were much briefer and more frequent than narrative sequences. Equivalent measures of narrative and explanatory talk showed moderate correlations, suggesting that families that engaged in one type of discourse also engaged in the other; this suggestion was confirmed by the finding that a large proportion of explanatory utterance were also parts of narratives. As 3- and 4-year-olds, children participated more competently in narrative than in explanatory discourse, though they requested many explanations at all ages. (Discourse Genres; Explanation; Development)

References (39)

Bamberg, M. (1987). The acquisition of narratives. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.

Barbieri, M. S., Colavita, F., & Scheuer, N. (1990). The beginning of the explaining capacity. In G. Conti-Ramsden & C. Snow (Eds.), Children's language (Vol. 7, pp. 245–272). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.

Barbieri, M. S. (1991). The origin of explanations. Contributi di Psicologia, 41, 153–176.

Beals, D. E. (1991). "Iknow who makes ice cream": Explanations in mealtime conversations of low-income families of preschoolers. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Harvard University.

(1983). Explanatory talk in low-income families's mealtimes Applied Psycholinguistics, 141, 489–513.

Beals, D. E., & De Temple, J. M. (1993a). Home contributions to early language and literacy development. In D. Leu & C. Kinzer (Eds.) Forty-second yearbook o f the National Reading Conference (pp. 207–215). Chicago: National Reading Conference.

(1993b, March). The where and when of whys and whats: Explanatory talk across settings. Paper presented at the meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, New Orleans.

Beals, D., & Smith, M. (1992, April). Eating, reading, and pretending: Predictors o f kindergarten literacy skills. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco.

Berman, R. A., & Slobin, D. I. (1994). Different ways of relating events in narrative: A crosslin-guistic developmental study. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.

Bloom, L., Lahey, M., Hood, L., Lifter, K., & Fiess, K. (1980). Complex sentences: Acquisition of syntactic connectives and the semantic relations they encode. Journal of Child Language, 71, 235–261.

Bruner, J. (1986). Actual minds, possible worlds. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Donaldson, M. (1986). Children's explanations: A psycholinguistic study. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

Gallas, K. (1993). The languages of learning. New York: Teachers College Press.

Gardner, H. (1983). Frames of mind: The theory of multiple intelligences. New York: Basic Books.

(1991). The unschooled mind. New York: Basic Books.

(1993). From conflict to clarification: A comment on Egan's "Narrative and learning: A voyage of implications." Linguistics and Education, 51, 181–185.

Heath, S. B. (1983). Ways with words. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Hicks, D. (1993). Narrative discourse and classroom learning: An essay response to Egan's "Narrative and learning: A voyage of implications." Linguistics and Education, 51, 127–148.

Hood, L. (1977). A longitudinal study o f the development o f expression of causal relations in complex sentences. Unpublished doctoral thesis, Columbia University.

Hood, L., & Bloom, L. (1979). What, when, and how about why: A longitudinal study of early expressions of causality. Monographs o f the Society for Research in Child Development, 44(6 Serial No. 181).

Hopkins, R. (1993). Narrative schooling. New York: Teachers College Press.

Kemper, S. (1984). The development of narrative skills: Explanations and entertainments. In S. Kuczaj (Ed.), Discourse development: Progress in cognitive development research (pp. 99–124). New York: Springer-Verlag.

Labov, W. (1972). Language in the inner city. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

MacWhinney, B. (1991). The CHILDES Project. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.

MacWhinney, B., & Snow, C. E. (1990). The Child Language Data Exchange System: An update. Journal of Child Language, 171, 457–473.

McCartney, K., & Nelson, K. (1981). Children's use of scripts in story recall. Discourse Processes, 41, 59–70.

Nelson, K., & Gruendel, J. M. (1986). Children's scripts. In K. Nelson (Ed.), Event knowledge (pp. 21–46). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.

Nelson, K., & Seidman, S. (1984). Playing with scripts. In I. Bretherton (Ed.), Symbolic Play (pp. 45–70). Orlando, FL: Academic.

Newkirk, T. (1989). More than stories: The range of children's writings. Portsmouth, NH: Heineman.

Ninio, A., & Bruner, J. (1978). The achievements and antecedents of labelling. Journal of Child Language, 51, 1–15.

Ochs, E., Taylor, C., Rudolph, D., & Smith, R. (1992). Storytelling as a theory-building activity. Discourse Processes, 151, 37–72.

Pappas, C. (1991a). Fostering full access to literacy by including information books. Language Arts, 681, 449–462.

(1991b). Young children's strategies in learning the "book language" of information books. Discourse Processes, 141, 203–225.

(1993a). Is narrative "primary"? Some insights from kindergartners' pretend readings of stories and information books. Journal of Reading Behavior, 251, 97–130.

(1993b). Questioning our ideologies about narrative and learning: Response to Egan. Linguistics and Education, 51, 157–164.

Peterson, C., & McCabe, A. (1983). Developmental psycholinguistics: Three ways of looking at a child's narrative. New York: Plenum.

Snow, C. E., & Dickinson, D. K. (1987). A proposal to the Ford Foundation. Unpublished manuscript, Harvard University.

Snow, C. E., Dickinson, D. K., & Tabors, P. O. (1989). Home-school study of language and literacy development: A continuation proposal. Unpublished manuscript, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.

Snow, C. E., & Kurland, B. F. (in press). Sticking to the point: Talk about magnets as a context for engaging in scientific discourse. In D. Hicks (Ed.), Child discourse and social learning. New York, Cambridge University Press.

Cited by (50)

Cited by 50 other publications

Order by:

Wei, Ran, Paul L. Harris, Catherine E. Snow & Meredith L. Rowe

2025. From the “Here and Now” to the “There and Then”: How parent–child decontextualized conversations support early development. Developmental Review 77 ► pp. 101217 ff.

Brand, Natalie, Emilia Djonov & Sheila Degotardi

2024. Toddler-educator decontextualised talk and its value for toddlers’ learning. Early Years 44:2 ► pp. 370 ff.

Cho, Minkyung & Young-Suk Grace Kim

2023. Do Second Graders Adjust Their Language by Discourse Context?. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools 54:2 ► pp. 569 ff.

Morag Yaar, Noa, Ofir Sadka, Aviv Yativ, Gilad Kfir, Noga Rosenberg, Yonatan Michael Ozbaher, Oren Zuckerman & Hadas Erel

2023. Proceedings of the 22nd Annual ACM Interaction Design and Children Conference, ► pp. 449 ff.

Hilvert, Elizabeth, Emily Lorang & Audra Sterling

2021. Maternal Use of Decontextualized and Contextualized Talk: An In-Depth Investigation of Early Parent–Child Interactions in Down Syndrome. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology 30:4 ► pp. 1767 ff.

Kandemir, Aysen Şimşek, Hasan Latif & Engin Karaman

2021. An Analysis of the Quality of the Time Allocated to Dinner by Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). The Family Journal

Quasthoff, Uta & Juliane Stude

2021. Children’s narrative interactions. Narrative Inquiry 31:1 ► pp. 147 ff.

Leech, Kathryn A., Amanda S. Haber, Youmna Jalkh & Kathleen H. Corriveau

2020. Embedding Scientific Explanations Into Storybooks Impacts Children’s Scientific Discourse and Learning. Frontiers in Psychology 11

Ribner, Andrew D., Catherine S. Tamis-LeMonda & Lynn S. Liben

2020. Mothers’ distancing language relates to young children’s math and literacy skills. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 196 ► pp. 104863 ff.

Uccelli, Paola, Özlem Ece Demir‐Lira, Meredith L. Rowe, Susan Levine & Susan Goldin‐Meadow

2019. Children's Early Decontextualized Talk Predicts Academic Language Proficiency in Midadolescence. Child Development 90:5 ► pp. 1650 ff.

Westby, Carol

2019. Explaining. Word of Mouth 30:5 ► pp. 11 ff.

Blum-Kulka, Shoshana

2016. Language Socialization and Family Dinnertime Discourse. In Language Socialization, ► pp. 1 ff.

Blum-Kulka, Shoshana

2017. Language Socialization and Family Dinnertime Discourse. In Language Socialization, ► pp. 65 ff.

Blum‐Kulka, Shoshana

2008. Language Socialization and Family Dinnertime Discourse. In Encyclopedia of Language and Education, ► pp. 2661 ff.

Heller, Vivien

2016. Meanings at hand: Coordinating semiotic resources in explaining mathematical terms in classroom discourse. Classroom Discourse 7:3 ► pp. 253 ff.

PEETS, KATHLEEN F. & ELLEN BIALYSTOK

2015. Academic discourse: Dissociating standardized and conversational measures of language proficiency in bilingual kindergarteners. Applied Psycholinguistics 36:2 ► pp. 437 ff.

Leech, Kathryn A. & Meredith L. Rowe

2014. A comparison of preschool children’s discussions with parents during picture book and chapter book reading. First Language 34:3 ► pp. 205 ff.

Bova, Antonio & Francesco Arcidiacono

2013. Investigating children’s Why-questions: A study comparing argumentative and explanatory function. Discourse Studies 15:6 ► pp. 713 ff.

Bova, Antonio & Francesco Arcidiacono

2014. “You must eat the salad because it is nutritious”. Argumentative strategies adopted by parents and children in food-related discussions at mealtimes. Appetite 73 ► pp. 81 ff.

Gosen, Myrte N., Jan Berenst & Kees de Glopper

2013. The interactional structure of explanations during shared reading at kindergarten. International Journal of Educational Research 62 ► pp. 62 ff.

Harding, Celia, Candace Wade & Kirsty Harrison

2013. Communication between children and carers during mealtimes. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs 13:4 ► pp. 242 ff.

Mantzicopoulos, Panayota, Helen Patrick & Ala Samarapungavan

2013. Science Literacy in School and Home Contexts: Kindergarteners’ Science Achievement and Motivation. Cognition and Instruction 31:1 ► pp. 62 ff.

Nyhout, Angela & Daniela K. O’Neill

2013. Mothers’ complex talk when sharing books with their toddlers: Book genre matters. First Language 33:2 ► pp. 115 ff.

Rowe, Meredith L.

2012. A Longitudinal Investigation of the Role of Quantity and Quality of Child‐Directed Speech in Vocabulary Development. Child Development 83:5 ► pp. 1762 ff.

Bova, Antonio

2011. Functions of “Why” Questions Asked by Children in Family Conversations. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 30 ► pp. 776 ff.

Bova, Antonio

2019. Introduction. In The Functions of Parent-Child Argumentation, ► pp. 1 ff.

Patrick, Helen, Kiana R. Johnson, Panayota Mantzicopoulos & DeLeon L. Gray

2011. “I Tell Them I Know How to Do My ABCs!”. The Elementary School Journal 112:2 ► pp. 383 ff.

Blum-Kulka, Shoshana, Michal Hamo & Talia Habib

2010. Explanations in naturally occurring peer talk: Conversational emergence and function, thematic scope, and contribution to the development of discursive skills. First Language 30:3-4 ► pp. 440 ff.

Peterson, Shira May

2009. Narrative and Paradigmatic Explanations in Preschool Science Discourse. Discourse Processes 46:4 ► pp. 369 ff.

Beck, Sarah W.

2008. Cultural Variation in Narrative Competence and Its Implications for Children's Academic Success. In Spanish-Language Narration and Literacy, ► pp. 332 ff.

Fiese, Barbara H. & Marlene Schwartz

2008. RECLAIMING THE FAMILY TABLE: MEALTIMES AND CHILD HEALTH AND WELLBEING. Social Policy Report 22:4 ► pp. 1 ff.

Peterson, Shira May & Lucia French

2008. Supporting young children's explanations through inquiry science in preschool. Early Childhood Research Quarterly 23:3 ► pp. 395 ff.

Spagnola, Mary & Barbara H. Fiese

2007. Family Routines and Rituals. Infants & Young Children 20:4 ► pp. 284 ff.

Gelman, Susan A. & Gail M. Gottfried

2006. Creativity in Young Children's Thought. In Creativity and Reason in Cognitive Development, ► pp. 221 ff.

Kendall, Shari

2006. ‘Honey, I'm home!’: Framing in family dinnertime homecomings. Text & Talk - An Interdisciplinary Journal of Language, Discourse Communication Studies 26:4-5 ► pp. 411 ff.

KENDALL, SHARI

2008. The balancing act: Framing gendered parental identities at dinnertime. Language in Society 37:4 ► pp. 539 ff.

Snow, Catherine E. & Diane E. Beals

2006. Mealtime talk that supports literacy development. New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development 2006:111 ► pp. 51 ff.

Burns, Susan, Linda Espinosa & Catherine E. Snow

2004. Débuts de la littératie, langue et culture : perspective socioculturelle. Revue des sciences de l'éducation 29:1 ► pp. 75 ff.

Tryggvason, Marja-Terttu

2004. Comparison of Topic Organization in Finnish, Swedish-Finnish, and Swedish Family Discourse. Discourse Processes 37:3 ► pp. 225 ff.

Yont, Kristine M., Catherine E. Snow & Lynne Vernon-Feagans

2003. The role of context in mother–child interactions: an analysis of communicative intents expressed during toy play and book reading with 12-month-olds. Journal of Pragmatics 35:3 ► pp. 435 ff.

Tenenbaum, Harriet R., Maureen A. Callanan, Consuelo Alba-Speyer & Leticia Sandoval

2002. The Role of Educational Background, Activity, and Past Experiences in Mexican-Descent Families’ Science Conversations. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences 24:2 ► pp. 225 ff.

Boudreau, Donna

2001. Supporting Narrative Development in Young Children. Perspectives on Language Learning and Education 8:2 ► pp. 16 ff.

Boudreau, Donna

2008. Narrative Abilities. Topics in Language Disorders 28:2 ► pp. 99 ff.

Crosson, Jillian & Ann Geers

2001. Analysis of Narrative Ability in Children with Cochlear Implants. Ear and Hearing 22:5 ► pp. 381 ff.

Brach, Elizabeth L., Kathleen A. Camara & Robert F. Houser

2000. Patterns of Dinnertime Interaction in Divorced and Non-Divorced Families. Journal of Divorce & Remarriage 32:3-4 ► pp. 125 ff.

Aukrust, Vibeke Grøver & Catherine E. Snow

1998. Narratives and explanations during mealtime conversations in Norway and the U.S.. Language in Society 27:2 ► pp. 221 ff.

Imbens-Bailey, Alison L. & Catherine E. Snow

1997. Chapter 7 Making meaning in parent-child interaction: A pragmatic approach. In The Problem of Meaning - Behavioral and Cognitive Perspectives [Advances in Psychology, 122], ► pp. 261 ff.

Ochs, Elinor & Lisa Capps

1996. NARRATING THE SELF. Annual Review of Anthropology 25:1 ► pp. 19 ff.

Snow, Catherine E., Patton O. Tabors, Petra A. Nicholson & Brenda F. Kurland

1995. SHELL: Oral Language and Early Literacy Skills in Kindergarten and First-Grade Children. Journal of Research in Childhood Education 10:1 ► pp. 37 ff.

[no author supplied]

2008. NARRATIVE LINKS TO LITERACY AND OTHER SCHOOL ACHIEVEMENTS. In Spanish-Language Narration and Literacy, ► pp. 271 ff.

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 13 november 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.