Article published In: Discourses of Fake News
Edited by Scott Wright
[Journal of Language and Politics 20:5] 2021
► pp. 653–675
Delegitimizing the media?
Analyzing politicians’ media criticism on social media
Published online: 15 June 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/jlp.20081.ege
https://doi.org/10.1075/jlp.20081.ege
Abstract
A growing literature on the impact of “fake news“ accusations on legacy news outlets suggests that the use of this term is
part of a much larger trend of increased and delegitimizing media criticism by political actors. However, so far, there is very little
empirical evidence on how prevailing politicians’ delegitimizing media criticism really is and under which conditions it occurs. To fill
these gaps, we present results of a content analysis of media-related Facebook postings by Austrian and German politicians in 2017
(N = 2,921). The results suggest that media criticism, in general, is actually rare and that about half of it can be
described as delegitimizing (i.e., characterized by incivility or absence of argumentation). Most often, media criticism is used by populist
politicians, who accuse “the media” in general of bias and falsehoods.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Media criticism in a digital age: From “good” to “bad”?
- 3.Characteristics of delegitimizing media criticism
- 3.1Absence of reasoning
- 3.2Presence of incivility
- 4.The importance of the “fake news” label
- 5.Determinants of delegitimizing media criticism
- 5.1Political actors: Populist politicians and parties
- 5.2Journalistic actors: Generalization of addressee
- 5.3Time period: Election campaigns
- 6.Methods
- 6.1Case selection
- 6.2Sample
- 6.3Coding procedure
- 6.4Measures
- 6.5Intercoder reliability
- 7.Results
- 7.1Descriptive results
- 7.2Delegitimizing media criticism
- 7.3Determinants of delegitimizing media criticism
- 8.Conclusion
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
References
References (66)
Aalberg, Toril, Frank Esser, Carsten Reinemann, Jesper Strömbäck, and Claes De Vreese, (eds). 2016. Populist
political communication in Europe. Routledge.
Aaldering, Loes, and Rens Vliegenthart. 2016. “Political
leaders and the media. Can we measure political leadership images in newspapers using computer-assisted content
analysis?”. Quality &
Quantity 50, no. 5: 1871–1905.
Althaus, Scott L. 2012. “What’s good and bad in
political communication research? Normative standards for evaluating media and citizen
performance.” In The SAGE handbook of political
communication, ed. by Holli A. Semetko, and Margaret Scammell, 97–112, London: SAGE Publications.
Bakker, Ryan, Liesbet Hooghe, Seth Jolly, Gary Marks, Jonathan Polk, Jan Rovny, Marco Steenbergen, and Milada Vachudova. 2020. “2019
Chapel Hill Expert Survey”. Available on chesdata.eu. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.
Bickford, Susan. 2011. “Emotion
talk and political judgment.” The Journal of
Politics 73, no. 4: 1025–1037.
Carey, James W. 1974. “Journalism and criticism: The
case of an undeveloped profession.” The Review of
Politics 36, no. 2: 227–249.
Carlson, Matt. 2009. “Media
criticism as competitive discourse: Defining reportage of the Abu Ghraib scandal.” Journal of
Communication
Inquiry 33, 3: 258–277.
. 2016. “Embedded
Links, Embedded Meanings: Social media commentary and news sharing as mundane media
criticism.” Journalism
Studies 17, no. 7: 915–924.
Cheruiyot, David. 2018. “Popular
Criticism That Matters: Journalists’ perspectives of ‘quality’ media critique.” Journalism
Practice 12, no. 8: 1008–1018.
Cheruiyot, D. 2019. Criticising
Journalism: Popular Media Criticism in the Digital Age (Doctoral
dissertation, Karlstads universitet).
Coe, Kevin, Kate Kenski, and Stephen A. Rains. 2014. “Online
and uncivil? Patterns and determinants of incivility in newspaper website comments.” Journal of
Communication 64, no. 4: 658–679.
Dahlgren, Peter. 2005. “The
Internet, public spheres, and political communication: Dispersion and deliberation.” Political
Communication 22, no. 2: 147–162.
Denner, Nora, and Christina Peter. 2017. „Der Begriff Lügenpresse in deutschen Tageszeitungen.“ [The
term lying press in German
newspapers]. Publizistik 62, no. 3: 273–297.
Die
Presse. (2017, July 3). “Pröll-Privatstiftung: Zivilprozess um ‘Fake News’-Vorwurf” [Pröll Private Foundation: Civil Suit Over ‘fake News’ Accusation]. [URL]
Farkas, Johan, and Jannick Schou. 2018. “Fake
news as a floating signifier: Hegemony, antagonism and the politics of falsehood. “Javnost-The
Public 25, no. 3: 298–314.
Eberl, Jakob-Moritz, Hajo Boomgaarden, and Markus Wagner. 2017. “One
bias fits all? Three types of media bias and their effects on party preferences.” Communication
Research 44, no. 8: 1125–1148.
Egelhofer, Jana Laura, Loes Aaldering, Jakob-Moritz Eberl, Sebastian Galyga, and Sophie Lecheler. 2020. “From
novelty to normalization? How journalists use the term ‘fake news’ in their
reporting.” Journalism
Studies 21, no. 10, 1323–1343.
Egelhofer, Jana Laura and Sophie Lecheler. 2019. “Fake
news as a two-dimensional phenomenon: a framework and research agenda.” Annals of the
International Communication
Association 43, no. 2: 97–116.
Engesser, Sven, Nicole Ernst, Frank Esser and Florin Büchel. 2016. “Populism
and social media: How politicians spread a fragmented ideology.” Information, Communication
&
Society 20, no. 8: 1109–1126.
Ernst, Nicole, Sven Engesser, Florin Büchel, Sina Blassnig, and Frank Esser. 2017. “Extreme
parties and populism: an analysis of Facebook and Twitter across six countries.” Information,
Communication &
Society 20, no. 9: 1347–1364.
Farhall, Kate, Andrea Carson, Scott Wright, Andrew Gibbons, and William Lukamto. 2019. “Political
Elites’ Use of Fake News Discourse Across Communications Platforms.” International Journal of
Communication 131 (2019): 4353–4375.
Fawzi, Nayla. 2019. “Untrustworthy
news and the media as ‘enemy of the people?’ How a populist worldview shapes recipients’ attitudes toward the
media.” The International Journal of
Press/Politics 24, no. 2: 146–164.
. 2020. “Right-Wing
Populist Media Criticism.” In Perspectives on Populism and the
Media, ed. by Benjamin Krämer and Christina Holtz-Bacha, 39–56. Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG.
Figenschou, Tine Ustad and Karoline Andrea Ihlebæk. 2019. “Challenging
Journalistic Authority: Media criticism in far-right alternative media.” Journalism
Studies 20, no. 9: 1221–1237.
Friess, Dennis, and Christiane Eilders. 2015. “A
systematic review of online deliberation research.” Policy &
Internet 7, no. 3: 319–339.
Guess, Andrew, Brendan Nyhan, and Jason Reifler. 2017. “’You’re
fake news!’ The 2017 Poynter media trust survey.” Retrieved from [URL]
Gründl, Johann. 2020. “Populist
ideas on social media: A dictionary-based measurement of populist communication.” New Media
& Society.
Hameleers, Michael. 2020a. “My
Reality Is More Truthful Than Yours: Radical Right-Wing Politicians’ and Citizens’ Construction of ‘Fake’ and ‘Truthfulness’
on Social Media – Evidence From the United States and The Netherlands.” International Journal
of
Communication 141 (2020): 1135–1152.
. 2020b. “Populist
disinformation: Exploring intersections between online populism and disinformation in the US and the
Netherlands.” Politics and
Governance 8, no. 1: 146–157.
Haller, André and Kristoffer Holt. 2019. “Paradoxical
populism: How PEGIDA relates to mainstream and alternative media.” Information, Communication
&
Society 22, no. 12: 1665–1680.
Holt, Kristoffer, and André Haller. 2017. “What
Does ‘Lügenpresse’ Mean? Expressions of Media Distrust on PEGIDA’s Facebook
Pages.” Politik 20, no. 4: 42–57.
Humprecht, Edda, Frank Esser, and Peter Van Aelst. 2020. “Resilience
to online disinformation: A framework for cross-national comparative research.” The
International Journal of
Press/Politics 25, no. 3: 493–516.
Humprecht, Edda, Lea Hellmueller, and Juliane A. Lischka. 2020. “Hostile
Emotions in News Comments: A Cross-National Analysis of Facebook Discussions.” Social Media+
Society 6, no.1: 1–12.
Jagers, Jan and Stefaan Walgrave. 2007. “Populism
as political communication style: An empirical study of political parties’ discourse in Belgium. European Journal of Political
Research” 46, no. 3: 319–345.
Jamieson, Kathleen Hall, Allyson Volinsky, Ilana Weitz, and Kate Kenski. 2017. “The
political uses and abuses of civility and incivility.” The Oxford handbook of political
communication, ed. by Kate Kenski and Kathleen Hall Jamieson, 205–218, Oxford University Press.
King, Gary and Langche Zeng. 2001. “Logistic
regression in rare events data.” Political
analysis 9, no. 2: 137–163.
Kritzinger, Sylvia, Julian Aichholzer, Nico Büttner, Jakob-Moritz Eberl, Thomas Meyer, Carolina Plescia, Markus Wagner, Davide Morisi, Hajo Boomgaarden and Wolfgang C. Müller. 2018. “AUTNES
Multi-Mode Panel Study 2017” –
Documentation. Vienna: AUSSDA.
Ladd, Jonathan M. 2012. Why Americans hate the media and how it
matters. Princeton University Press.
Lakoff, George. Interviewed by Kurtzleben, Danielle. 2017 (February 17). “With
‘Fake News,’ Trump Moves from Alternative Facts to Alternative Language.” [URL]
Lischka, Juliane. 2019. “A
badge of honor? How The New York Times discredits President Trump’s fake news
accusations.” Journalism
Studies 20, no. 2: 287–304.
Löfgren Nilsson, Monica, and Henrik Örnebring. 2016. “Journalism
under threat: Intimidation and harassment of Swedish journalists.” Journalism
Practice 10, no. 7: 880–890.
Lombard, Mathew, Jennifer Snyder-Duch, and Cheryl Bracken. 2002. “Content
analysis in mass communication: Assessment and reporting of intercoder reliability.” Human
communication
research 28, no. 4: 587–604.
Masullo Chen, Gina, and Shuning Lu. 2017. “Online
political discourse: Exploring differences in effects of civil and uncivil disagreement in news website
comments.” Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic
Media 61, 1: 108–125.
Masullo Chen, Gina, Paromita Pain, Victoria Y. Chen, Madlin Mekelburg, Nina Springer, and Franziska Troger. 2020. “‘You
really have to have a thick skin’: A cross-cultural perspective on how online harassment influences female
journalists.” Journalism 21, no. 7, 877–895.
Maurer, Marcus, Pablo Jost, Jörg Haßler, and Simon Kruschinski. 2019. „Auf den Spuren der Lügenpresse.“ [On the trail of the liar
press]. Publizistik 64, no. 1: 15–35.
Meeks, Lindsey. 2020. “Defining
the Enemy: How Donald Trump Frames the News Media.” Journalism & Mass Communication
Quarterly, 97, no. 1: 211–234.
Naab, Teresa K., Dominique Heinbach, Marc Ziegele, and Marie-Theres Grasberger. 2020. “Comments
and credibility: how critical user comments decrease perceived news article
credibility.” Journalism
Studies 21, no. 6: 783–801.
Newman, Nic, Richard Fletcher, Antonis Kalogeropoulos, David Levy, and Rasmus K. Nielsen. 2018. “Reuters
Institute Digital News Report 2018.”
Newman, Nic, Richard Fletcher, Antonis Kalogeropoulos, and Rasmus K. Nielsen. 2019. “Reuters
Institute Digital News Report 2019.”
Otto, Lukas P., Sophie Lecheler, and Andreas RT Schuck. 2020. “Is context the key? The (non-) differential effects of mediated incivility in three European countries.” Political Communication 37, 1: 88–107.
Prochazka, Fabian, Patrick Weber, and Wolfgang Schweiger. 2018. “Effects
of civility and reasoning in user comments on perceived journalistic quality.” Journalism
Studies 19, no. 1: 62–78.
Quarfoot, David, and Richard A. Levine. 2016. “How
robust are multirater interrater reliability indices to changes in frequency distribution?” The
American
Statistician 70, no. 4: 373–384.
Reporters without
Borders (2018). RSF Index 2018: “Hatred of journalism threatens
democracies.” Retrieved from [URL]
Rooduijn, Matthijs, Stijn Van Kessel, Caterina Froio, Andrea Pirro, Sarah De Lange, Daphne Halikiopoulou, Paul Lewis, Cas Mudde, and Paul Taggart. 2019. “The
PopuList: An Overview of Populist, Far Right, Far Left and Eurosceptic Parties in Europe.” [URL]
Schulz, Anne, Werner Wirth, and Philipp Müller. 2018. “We
are the people and you are fake news: A social identity approach to populist citizens’ false consensus and hostile media
perceptions.” Communication
Research 47, no. 2: 201–226.
Sobieraj, Sarah, and Jeffrey B. Berry. 2011. “From
incivility to outrage: Political discourse in blogs, talk radio, and cable news.” Political
Communication 28, no. 1: 19–41.
Solis, Jonathan A., and Iñaki Sagarzazu. 2020. “The
Media Smells like Sulfur!!! Leaders and Verbal Attacks against the Fourth Estate in Unconsolidated
Democracies.” Political
Communication 37, no. 1: 20–45.
Tsfati, Yariv and Jonathan Cohen. 2005. “Democratic
Consequences of Hostile Media Perceptions: The Case of Gaza Settlers.” The Harvard
International Journal of
Press/Politics 10, no. 4: 28–51.
Van Aelst, Peter, Jesper Strömbäck, Toril Aalberg, Frank Esser, Claes De Vreese, Jörg Matthes, David Hopmann et al. 2017. “Political
communication in a high-choice media environment: a challenge for democracy?” Annals of the
International Communication
Association 41, no. 1: 3–27.
Van Dalen, Arjen. 2019. “Rethinking
journalist–politician relations in the age of populism: How outsider politicians delegitimize mainstream
journalists.” Journalism.
Waisbord, Silvio. 2018. “The
elective affinity between post-truth communication and populist politics.” Communication
Research and
Practice 4, no. 1: 17–34.
Cited by (46)
Cited by 46 other publications
Bakanov, R. P. & M. A. Myasnikova
Buyens, Willem, Peter Van Aelst & Steve Paulussen
Damstra, Alyt, Elina Lindgren, Rens Vliegenthart, Hajo Boomgaarden, Jesper Strömbäck & Yariv Tsfati
Gattermann, Katjana, Elske van den Hoogen & Claes de Vreese
Goulart Massuchin, Michele, Maíra Orso & Bruno Bernardo De Araújo
Haapala, Taru & Juan Roch
Kluknavská, Alena
Kluknavská, Alena, Olga Eisele, Monika Bartkowska & Nina Kriegler
Köker, Philipp, Tilko Swalve, Merle Huber, Christoph Hönnige & Dominic Nyhuis
Lamot, Kenza, Kathleen Beckers & Peter Van Aelst
Lázaro, Andreu Rodilla
Miller, Christopher J. & Yucong Jiang
Novais, Rui Alexandre & Rogério Christofoletti
Radnitz, Scott & Yuan Hsiao
Radnitz, Scott, Steven Karceski & Yuan Hsaio
Strömbäck, Jesper, Sofia Johansson, Elena Broda, Erik Espeland & Hugo Ekström
Strömbäck, Jesper & Mathilda Åkerlund
Wang, Rui & Yini Zhang
Wolleschensky, Johanna & Annika Sehl
Baptista, João Pedro, Anabela Gradim & Daniela Fonseca
Buttgereit, Lina, Michael Hameleers, Katjana Gattermann & Andreas Schuck
Cimaglio, Christopher
Conrad, Maximilian
Gravesteijn, Emily, Erika van Elsas & Katjana Gattermann
Hart, Christopher
Heidenreich, Tobias, Jakob-Moritz Eberl, Petro Tolochko, Fabienne Lind & Hajo G. Boomgaarden
Monetti, Luiza
Novais, Rui Alexandre
Novais, Rui Alexandre
Novais, Rui Alexandre Sousa da Costa & Ângela Maria Teixiera Leite
van der Goot, Emma, Karolin Soontjens, Kathleen Beckers, Willem Buyens & Peter van Aelst
Archer, Allison M N
Ceron, Andrea, Giovanni Pagano & Margherita Bordignon
Egelhofer, Jana Laura
Ekman, Mattias & Andreas Widholm
Firdaus, Satria, Neysa Naila, Azzahra Dinar Pramesti, Cindy Kartika Sari, Dhara Fatimah Azzahra & Deni Angela
Kluknavská, Alena & Olga Eisele
Liminga, Agnes & Jesper Strömbäck
Carson, Andrea & Scott Wright
Egelhofer, Jana Laura, Ming Boyer, Sophie Lecheler & Loes Aaldering
Gibbons, Andrew & Andrea Carson
Macaraig, Ayee & Michael Hameleers
Thiele, Daniel & Tjaša Turnšek
Wright, Scott
Wright, Scott
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 13 november 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
