Article published In:
[Journal of Historical Pragmatics 16:1] 2015
► pp. 59–85
Grammaticalization or pragmaticalization of discourse markers?
More than a terminological issue
Published online: 3 April 2015
https://doi.org/10.1075/jhp.16.1.03deg
https://doi.org/10.1075/jhp.16.1.03deg
Discourse markers are a crucial component of natural language, which is why a description and account of their diachronic evolution must be part of our linguistic models. However, researchers have different views on whether this evolution should be accounted for in terms of grammaticalization and/or pragmaticalization. In this paper, we provide a structured overview of the accounts given for the diachronic evolution of DMs. It is shown that the different positions encountered in the literature can be brought back to diverging views on the conceptualization of grammar, the categorization of discourse markers, and the weight that is put on specific processes involved in the diachronic change. We provide case studies for each of the positions that we present and discuss.
Keywords: discourse markers, grammaticalization, pragmaticalization
References (97)
Ahn, Mikyung. 2010. “From ‘Favor’ to ‘Cause’: The English Causal Adposition thanks to and its Korean Counterpart tekpwuney
”. Language Sciences 32 (5): 579–87.
Aijmer, Karin. 1997. “
I think: An English Modal Particle”. In Toril Swan and Olaf Jansen Westvik (eds), Modality in Germanic Languages. Historical and Comparative Perspective, 1–47. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Aijmer, Karin and Anne-Marie Simon-Vandenbergen. 2011. “Pragmatic Markers”. In Jan Zienkowski, Jan-Ola Östman and Jef Verschueren (eds), Discursive Pragmatics, 223–47. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Arroyo, José Luis Blas. 2011. “From Politeness to Discourse Marking: The Process of Pragmaticalization of muy bien in Vernacular Spanish”. Journal of Pragmatics 43 (3): 855–74.
Barth-Weingarten, Dagmar and Elizabeth Couper-Kuhlen. 2002. “On the Final though: A Case of Grammaticalization?” In Ilse Wischer and Gabriele Diewald (eds), New Reflections on Grammaticalization, 345–61. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Beijering, Karin. 2012. Expressions of Epistemic Modality in Mainland Scandinavian; A Study into the Lexicalization-Grammaticalization-Pragmaticalization Interface. (Groningen Dissertations in Linguistics 106). Zutphen: Wöhrmann Print Service. Available online at: [URL] (accessed 10 September 2013).
Boye, Kasper and Peter Harder. 2012. “A Usage-based Theory of Grammatical Status and Grammaticalization”. Language 88 (1): 1–44.
Brinton, Laurel J. 1996. Pragmatic Markers in English: Grammaticalization and Discourse Function. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
. 2001. “From Matrix Clause to Pragmatic Marker: The History of look-Forms”. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 2 (2): 177–99.
. 2006. “Pathways in the Development of Pragmatic Markers in English”. In Ans van Kemenade and Bettelou Los (eds), The Handbook of the History of English, 307–34. London: Blackwell.
. 2010. “The Development of I mean: Implications for the Study of Historical Pragmatics”. In Susan M. Fitzmaurice and Irma Taavitsainen (eds), Methods in Historical Pragmatics, 37–80. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Brinton, Laurel J. and Elizabeth Closs Traugott. 2005. Lexicalization and Language Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Callies, Marcus. 2012. “The Grammaticalization and Pragmaticalization of Cleft Constructions in Present-Day English”. In Sebastian Hoffmann, Paul Rayson and Geoffrey Leech (eds), English Corpus Linguistics: Looking Back, Moving Forward, 5–21. Amsterdam: Rodopi.
Chang, Miao-Hsia. 2008. “Discourse and Grammaticalization of Contrastive Markers in Taiwanese Southern Min: A Corpus-Based Study”. Journal of Pragmatics 40 (12): 2114–49.
Claridge, Claudia. 2013. “The Evolution of Three Pragmatic Markers: As it were, so to speak and if you like
”. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 14 (2): 161–84.
Claridge, Claudia and Leslie Arnovick. 2010. “Pragmaticalisation and Discursisation”. In Andreas H. Jucker and Irma Taavitsainen (eds), Historical Pragmatics (Handbook of Pragmatics, Vol. 8), 165–92. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
Croft, William A. 2001. Radical Construction Grammar: Syntactic Theory in Typological Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Degand, Liesbeth. 2001. Form and Function of Causation: A Theoretical and Empirical Investigation of Causal Constructions in Dutch. Leuven: Peeters.
Degand, Liesbeth and Benjamin Fagard. 2011. “
Alors between Discourse and Grammar. The Role of Syntactic Position”. Functions of Language 18 (1): 29–56.
. 2012. “Competing Connectives in the Causal Domain: French car and parce que
”. Journal of Pragmatics 44 (1): 154–68.
Degand, Liesbeth, Bert Cornillie and Paola Pietrandrea. 2013. “Discourse Markers and Modal Particles: Two Sides of the Same Coin?” In Liesbeth Degand, Bert Cornillie and Paola Pietrandrea (eds), Discourse Markers and Modal Particles. Categorization and Description, 1–18. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Degand, Liesbeth and Henk Pander Maat. 2003. “A Contrastive Study of Dutch and French Causal Connectives on the Speaker Involvement Scale”. In Arie Verhagen and Jeroen van de Weijer (eds), Usage-based Approaches to Dutch, 175–99. Utrecht: LOT.
Degand, Liesbeth and Anne-Marie Simon-Vandenbergen. 2011. “Introduction: Grammaticalization and (Inter)subjectification of Discourse Markers”. Linguistics 49 (2): 287–94.
Dér, Csilla Ilona. 2010. “On the Status of Discourse Markers”. Acta Linguistica Hungarica 57 (1): 3–28.
Diewald, Gabriele. 2006. “Discourse Particles and Modal Particles as Grammatical Elements”. In Kerstin Fischer (ed.), Approaches to Discourse Particles, 403–25. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
. 2011a. “Grammaticalization and Pragmaticalization”. In Heiko Narrog and Bernd Heine (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Grammaticalization, 450–61. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
. 2011b. “Pragmaticalization (Defined) as Grammaticalization of Discourse Functions”. Linguistics 49 (2): 365–90.
Dostie, Gaétane. 2004. Pragmaticalization et Marqueurs Discursifs. Analyse Sémantique et Traitement Lexicographique. Brussels: De Boeck.
Erman, Britt and Ulla-Britt Kotsinas. 1993. “Pragmaticalization: The Case of ba’ and you know
”. Studier i Modern Språkvetenskap 101: 76–93.
Evers-Vermeul, Jacqueline. 2005. The Development of Dutch Connectives. Change and Acquisition as Windows on Form-Function Relations. PhD Thesis. Utrecht University. Utrecht: LOT. Available online at: [URL] (accessed 10 September 2013).
Evers, Jacqueline, Liesbeth Degand, Benjamin Fagard and Liesbeth Mortier. 2011. “Historical and Comparative Perspectives on Subjectification: A Corpus-based Analysis of Dutch and French Causal Connectives”. Linguistics 49 (2): 445–78.
Fagard, Benjamin. 2010. “É vida, olha...: Imperatives as Discourse Markers and Grammaticalization Paths in Romance: A Diachronic Corpus Study”. Languages in Contrast 10 (2): 245–67.
Fitzmaurice, Susan. 2004. “Subjectivity, Intersubjectivity and the Historical Construction of Interlocutor Stance: From Stance Markers to Discourse Markers”. Discourse Studies 6 (4): 427–48.
Frank-Job, Barbara. 2006. “A Dynamic–Interactional Approach to Discourse Markers”. In Kerstin Fischer (ed.), Approaches to Discourse Particles, 395–413. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Givón, Talmy. 1983. Topic Continuity in Discourse: A Quantitative Cross-language Study. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 1991. “The Evolution of Dependent Clause Morpho-Syntax in Biblical Hebrew”. In Elizabeth Closs Traugott and Bernd Heine (eds), Approaches to Grammaticalization, Volume II: Types of Grammatical Markers, 257–310. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Goldberg, Adele. 1995. Constructions: A Construction Grammar Approach to Argument Structure. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Günthner, Susanne and Katrin Mutz. 2004. “Grammaticalization vs. Pragmaticalization? The Development of Pragmatic Markers in German and Italian”. In Walter Bisang, Nikolaus Himmelmann and Björn Wiemer (eds), What Makes Grammaticalization? A Look from Its Fringes and Its Components, 77–107. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. 10.1515/9783110197440
Hansen, Maj-Britt Mosegaard. 2005. “From Prepositional Phrase to Hesitation Marker: The Semantic and Pragmatic Evolution of French enfin
”. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 6 (2): 37–68.
. 2008. Particles at the Semantics/Pragmatics Interface: Synchronic and Diachronic Issues; A Study with Special Reference to the French Phasal Adverbs. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Haselow, Alexander. 2011. “Discourse Marker and Modal Particle: The Functions of Utterance-Final then in Spoken English”. Journal of Pragmatics 43 (14): 3603–23.
Hasselgård, Hilde, Stig Johansson, Bergljot Behrens and Cathrine Fabricius-Hansen (eds). 2002. Information Structure in a Cross-Linguistic Perspective. Amsterdam: Rodopi.
Heine, Bernd. 2003. “Grammaticalization”. In Brian D. Joseph and Richard D. Janda (eds), Handbook of Historical Linguistics, 575–601. Oxford: Blackwell.
. 2013. “On Discourse Markers: Grammaticalization, Pragmaticalization, or Something Else?” Linguistics 51 (6): 1205–47.
Heine, Bernd, Ulrike Claudi and Friederike Hünnemeyer. 1991. Grammaticalization. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Heine, Bernd, Gunther Kaltenböck, Tania Kuteva and Haiping Long. 2013. “An Outline of Discourse Grammar”. In Shannon Bischoff and Carmen Jany (eds), Functional Approaches to Language, 155–96. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Himmelmann, Nikolaus P. 2004. “Lexicalization and Grammaticization: Opposite or Orthogonal?” In Walter Bisang, Nikolaus Himmelmann and Björn Wiemer (eds), What Makes Grammaticalization? A Look from Its Fringes and Its Components, 21–42. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. 10.1515/9783110197440
Hopper, Paul J. 1991. “On Some Principles of Grammaticization”. In Elizabeth Closs Traugott and Bernd Heine (eds), Approaches to Grammaticalization, Volume I, Focus on Theoretical and Methodological Issues, 17–35. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Hopper, Paul J. and Elizabeth Closs Traugott. 2003 [1993]. Grammaticalization. 2nd edn. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hyun-Oak Kim, Alan. 2011. “Rhetorical Questions as Catalyst in Grammaticalization: Deriving Korean Discourse Marker ketun from Conditional Connective”. Journal of Pragmatics 43 (4): 1023–41.
Joseph, Brian D. 2001. “Is There such a Thing as Grammaticalization?” Language Sciences 231: 163–86.
. 2004. “Rescuing Traditional (Historical) Linguistics from Grammaticalization Theory”. In Olga Fischer, Muriel Norde and Harry Perridon (eds), Up and Down the Cline: The Nature of Grammaticalization, 45–71. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Kaltenböck, Gunther, Bernd Heine and Tania Kuteva. 2011. “On Thetical Grammar”. Studies in Language 35 (4): 848–93.
Koops, Christian and Arne Lohmann. 2013. “Discourse Marker Sequencing and Grammaticalization”. In Maria-Jose López-Couso et al. (eds), English Corpus Linguistics on the Move: Applications and Implications (Book of Abstracts ICAME 34), 126–8. Available online at: [URL] (accessed 10 September 2013).
Langacker, Ronald W. 2008. Cognitive Grammar: A Basic Introduction. New York: Oxford University Press.
Lehmann, Christian. 1985. “Grammaticalization: Synchronic Variation and Diachronic Change”. Lingua e stile 201: 303–18.
. 1995 [1982]. Thoughts on Grammaticalization: A Programmatic Sketch. 2nd edn. (First published as Arbeiten des Kölner Universalien-Projekt 48. Köln: Institut für Sprachwissenschaft der Universität.) Munich: Lincom Europa.
Lenker, Ursala. 2000. “
Soþlice and witodlice: Discourse Markers in Old English”. In Olga Fischer, Anette Rosenbach and Dieter Stein (eds), Pathways of Change: Grammaticalization in English, 229–49. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Lewis, Diana M. 2007. “From Temporal to Contrastive and Causal: The Emergence of Connective after all
”. In Agnès Celle and Ruth Huart (eds), Connectives as Discourse Landmarks, 89–99. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 2011. “A Discourse-Constructional Approach to the Emergence of Discourse Markers in English”. Linguistics 49 (2): 415–43.
Marchello-Nizia, Christiane. 2009. “Grammaticalisation et pragmaticalisation des connecteurs de concession en français: cependant, toutefois, pourtant”. Revue Roumaine de Linguistique 54 (1–2): 7–20.
Méndez-Naya, Belén. 2006. “Adjunct, Modifier, Discourse Marker: On the Various Functions of right in the History of English”. Folia Linguistica Historica 27 (1–2): 141–69.
Mulder, Jean and Sandra A. Thompson. 2008. “The Grammaticization of but as a Final Particle in English Conversation”. In Ritva Laury (ed.), Crosslinguistic Studies of Clause Combining: The Multifunctionality of Conjunctions, 179–204. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Norde, Muriel, and Karin Beijering. 2012. “Facing Interfaces: A Clustering Approach”. Paper presented at
Refining Grammaticalization
, Free University of Berlin, 24 February 2012.
Ocampo, Francisco. 2006. “Movement Towards Discourse is Not Grammaticalization: The Evolution of claro from Adjective to Discourse Particle in Spoken Spanish”. In Nuria Sagarra and Almeida Jacqueline Toribio (eds), Selected Proceedings of the 9th Hispanic Linguistics Symposium, 308–19. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.
Onodera, Noriko Okada. 1995. “Diachronic Analysis of Japanese Discourse Markers”. In Andreas H. Jucker (ed.), Historical Pragmatics, 393–437. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
. 2000. “Development of demo Type Connectives and na Elements: Two Extremes of Japanese Discourse Markers”. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 1 (1): 27–55.
Pinto de Lima, José. 2002. “Grammaticalization, Subjectification and the Origin of Phatic Markers”. In Ilse Wischer and Gabriele Diewald (eds), New Reflections on Grammaticalization, 363–78. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Pit, Mirna. 2006. “Determining Subjectivity in Text: The Case of Backward Causal Connectives in Dutch”. Discourse Processes 411: 151–74.
Prévost, Sophie. 2011. “
A propos from Verbal Complement to Discourse Marker: A Case of Grammaticalization?” Linguistics 49 (2): 391–413.
Rehbock, Helmut. 2009. “… ohne jetzt nun gleich aggressiv zu werden: Ein Zeitadverb als Diskursmarker”. Zeitschrift für Germanistische Linguistik 37 (2): 236–65.
Rosenkvist, Henrik and Sanna Skärlund. 2013. “Grammaticalization in the Present – The Changes of Modern Swedish typ
”. In Anna Giacolone Ramat, Caterina Mauri and Piera Molinelli (eds), Synchrony and Diachrony: A Dynamic Interface, 313–38. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Rossari, Corinne and Corina Cojocariu. 2008. “Constructions of the Type la cause/la raison/la preuve Utterance: Grammaticalization, Pragmaticalization, or Something Else?” Journal of Pragmatics 40 (8): 1435–54.
Schwenter, Scott A. and Elizabeth Closs Traugott. 2000. “Invoking Scalarity: The Development of in fact
”. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 11: 7–25.
Simon-Vandenbergen, Anne-Marie and Dominique Willems. 2011 “Crosslinguistic Data as Evidence in the Grammaticalization Debate: The Case of Discourse Markers”. Linguistics 49 (2): 333–64.
Spooren, Wilbert, Ted Sanders, Mike Huiskes and Liesbeth Degand. 2010. “Subjectivity and Causality: A Corpus Study of Spoken Language”. In Sally Rice and John Newman (eds), Empirical and Experimental Methods in Cognitive/Functional Research, 241–55. Stanford: CSLI Publications.
Taylor, John R. 1989. Linguistic Categorization: Prototypes in Linguistic Theory. Oxford: Clarendon.
Tabor, Whitney and Elizabeth Closs Traugott. 1998. “Structural Scope Expansion and Grammaticalization”. In Anna Giacalone Ramat and Paul J. Hopper (eds), The Limits of Grammaticalization, 229–72. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Traugott, Elizabeth Closs. 1995a. “Subjectification in Grammaticalization”. In Dieter Stein and Susan Wright (eds), Subjectivity and Subjectivisation: Linguistic Perspectives, 31–54. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
. 1995b. “The Role of the Development of Discourse Markers in a Theory of Grammaticalization”. Paper presented at the ICHL XII, Manchester. Version of 11/97. Available online at: [URL] (accessed 10 September 2013).
. 1999. “The Rhetoric of Counter-Expectation in Semantic Change: A Study in Subjectification”. In Andreas Blank and Peter Koch (eds), Historical Semantics and Cognition, 177–96. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Vincent, Diane. 2005. “The Journey of Non-Standard Discourse Markers in Quebec French: Networks Based on Exemplification”. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 6 (2): 188–210.
Waltereit, Richard. 2002. “Imperatives, Interruption in Conversation, and the Rise of Discourse Markers: A Study of Italian guarda
”. Linguistics 40 (5): 987–1010.
. 2006. “The Rise of Discourse Markers in Italian: A Specific Type of Language Change”. In Kerstin Fischer (ed.), Approaches to Discourse Particles, 61–67. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Wischer, Ilse. 2000. “Grammaticalization Versus Lexicalization: “Methinks” There is Some Confusion”. In Olga Fischer, Anette Rosenbach and Dieter Stein (eds), Pathways of Change: Grammaticalization in English, 355–70. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Wischer, Ilse and Gabriele Diewald (eds). 2002. New Reflections on Grammaticalization. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Cited by (67)
Cited by 67 other publications
Alfano, Iolanda
Buysse, Lieven
Chu, Weiwei & Yi Shan
Fagard, Benjamin
Fagard, Benjamin & Jean-Michel Fortis
Hickey, Raymond
Kazemian, Reza, Mohammad Amouzadeh & Homa Asadi
Lewis, Diana
Rakhilina, Ekaterina V., Serafima M. Gyulasaryan & Polina A. Bychkova
Schmidt-Riese, Aaron
Shan, Yi & Weiwei Chu
Traugott, Elizabeth Closs
2025. Afterword. In Semantic-Pragmatic Change from Intersubjective to Textual Meanings [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 353], ► pp. 272 ff.
Guz, Wojciech
Habicht, Külli, Külli Prillop & Carl Eric Simmul
Llopis Cardona, Ana & Marlies Jansegers
2024. Del rollo como sustantivo comodín contracultural al rollo aproximador en el español
coloquial actual. Spanish in Context 21:1 ► pp. 159 ff.
Metslang, Helle, Külli Habicht, Tiit Hennoste, Kirsi Laanesoo-Kalk, Külli Prillop, Andriela Rääbis & Carl Eric Simmul
Oleškevičienė, Giedrė Valūnaitė, Vitalija Karaciejūtė & Dalia Gulbinskienė
Tantucci, Vittorio & Sylvie Hancil
2023. Introduction. In Different Slants on Grammaticalization [Studies in Language Companion Series, 232], ► pp. 1 ff.
Xiaoli, Sun
Iwasaki, Shoichi & Parada Dechapratumwan
la Roi, Ezra
Sanders, José & Jacqueline Evers-Vermeul
Shefer, Hagit
Sun, Xiaoli
Van Olmen, Daniël & Vittorio Tantucci
Bogdanova-Beglarian, Natalia, Olga Blinova, Tatiana Sherstinova & Tatiana Sulimova
Fedriani, Chiara
Haselow, Alexander & Sylvie Hancil
2021. Grammar, discourse, and the grammar-discourse interface. In Studies at the Grammar-Discourse Interface [Studies in Language Companion Series, 219], ► pp. 1 ff.
Heine, Bernd, Gunther Kaltenböck, Tania Kuteva & Haiping Long
2021. On the rise of discourse markers. In Studies at the Grammar-Discourse Interface [Studies in Language Companion Series, 219], ► pp. 23 ff.
Álvarez-Prendes, Emma
Badan, Linda
Bogdanova-Beglarian, Natalia, Olga Blinova, Tatiana Sherstinova & Ekaterina Troshchenkova
Bogdanova-Beglarian, Natalia, Olga Blinova, Tatiana Sherstinova, Daria Gorbunova, Kristina Zaides & Tatiana Popova
Giomi, Riccardo & Evelien Keizer
Gorski, Edair Maria
Haselow, Alexander & Gunther Kaltenböck
2020. The brain and the mind behind grammar. In Grammar and Cognition [Human Cognitive Processing, 70], ► pp. 1 ff.
Hernández Páez, Marianela
Herrero Ruiz de Loizaga, Francisco Javier
Lansari, Laure
Pekelis, Olga E.
Rhee, Seongha
2020. Pseudo-hortative and the development of the discourse markereti poca(‘well, let’s see’) in Korean. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 21:1 ► pp. 53 ff.
Rodríguez-Abruñeiras, Paula
Scivoletto, Giulio
2020. Semasiological cyclicity in the evolution of discourse markers. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 21:2 ► pp. 236 ff.
Scivoletto, Giulio
Unuabonah, Foluke Olayinka
Viola, Lorella
2020. On the diachrony ofgiusto?(‘right?’) in Italian. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 21:1 ► pp. 83 ff.
Wang, Hui & Yicheng Wu
Bogdanova-Beglarian, Natalia & Yulia Filyasova
Breban, Tine & Sylvie Hancil
2018. Introduction. In New Trends in Grammaticalization and Language Change [Studies in Language Companion Series, 202], ► pp. 1 ff.
Heine, Bernd
2018. Are there two different ways of approaching grammaticalization?. In New Trends in Grammaticalization and Language Change [Studies in Language Companion Series, 202], ► pp. 23 ff.
Heine, Bernd
Inglese, Guglielmo & Ulrich Geupel
Marcus, Imogen
Taverniers, Miriam
Crible, Ludivine
2017. Towards an operational category of discourse markers. In Pragmatic markers, Discourse Markers and Modal Particles [Studies in Language Companion Series, 186], ► pp. 99 ff.
Dobrovoljc, Kaja
2017. Multi-word discourse markers and their corpus-driven identification. International Journal of Corpus Linguistics 22:4 ► pp. 551 ff.
Mazzon, Gabriella
2017. Paths of development of English DMs. In Pragmatic markers, Discourse Markers and Modal Particles [Studies in Language Companion Series, 186], ► pp. 289 ff.
Tanno, Koji
Tanno, Koji
2022. The role of discourse strategies in the grammaticalization of the Japanese discourse markerdakara. Language and Linguistics. 語言暨語言學 ► pp. 592 ff.
Caffi, Claudia
Ghezzi, Chiara & Piera Molinelli
Ghezzi, Chiara & Piera Molinelli
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 13 november 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
