Article published In: Developments in Diglossic Settings in the Asian Pacific Region:
Edited by Marinus van den Berg
[Journal of Asian Pacific Communication 30:1/2] 2020
► pp. 217–254
Special issue articles
Dialect and Putonghua in Xi’an city
The case of Beishan Menkou urban village
Published online: 30 June 2020
https://doi.org/10.1075/japc.00050.qio
https://doi.org/10.1075/japc.00050.qio
Abstract
As one of the industrial centers of Western China, Xi’an is undergoing a process in which surrounding “urban villages” are incorporated into the urban area. This paper reports on the
contact situation between the Xi’an dialect of Beishan Menkou “urban village” and Mandarin Chinese. Data collection started with
traditional dialect survey methodology which assumes the dialect to be homogeneous and shared across village members. It requires
respondents to read a standard list of Chinese characters. The assumption that the dialect is homogeneous is generally agreed upon
for older generations but is doubtful for the younger generation who are exposed to modern education and modern
life. We therefore stratified the survey across three generations with six informants, a male and female informants for each
generation. The results show that the dialect among the two older generations was still homogeneous and shared, whereas the
youngest generations showed influence of Putonghua on the dialect. This resulted in a new dialect variant “Dialect with Putonghua
features”, which is recognized by urban village members as such. Female respondents generally were conceived of as speaking the
New Dialect more clearly than their male counterparts. We also investigated the impact of the dialect on Putonghua and concluded
that among the younger generation, a form of “Local Putonghua” developed, whereas the accented forms used by older generations are
a variety of intermediate forms of this “Local Putonghua”. The paper further provides details of the changes taking place in the
New Dialect in terms of tones, initials and finals, vocabulary and grammar. Words in local Putonghua were also listed.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 1.1The relationship between Chinese dialects and Putonghua
- 1.1.1Local Putonghua
- 1.1.2Dialect with Putonghua Features
- 1.1.3Similarities and differences
- 1.2‘Urban villages’ in Xi’an
- 1.3The Xi’an urban village dialect
- 1.1The relationship between Chinese dialects and Putonghua
- 2.Method
- 3.Results of the survey
- 3.1Tone change
- 3.2Initial consonants
- 3.3Finals
- 3.4Lexical change
- 3.5Grammatical changes
- 4.The local Putonghua word list
- 4.1The pronunciation of monosyllabic words
- 4.2The pronunciation of bisyllabic words
- 5.Discussion
- 5.1Language change in the urban village
- 5.2The transition process from dialect to Putonghua
- 6.Conclusion
- Notes
References
References (19)
van den Berg, Marinus. (2019). The Restructuring of Chinese Speech Communities: The Case of Xi’an City, Shaanxi Province. China Language Strategy 中国语言战略 1–22.
van Bree, Cor. (2010). Stability of elements in Dutch dialects. In, M. E. van den Berg and Daming Xu (Eds.), Industrialization and the Restructuring of Speech Communities in China and Europe, (pp.283–302). Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Chao, Yuen Ren. (1968). A Grammar of Spoken Chinese. Berkeley, Cal.: University of California Press.
Chen, Yachuan. (1991). The Nature of “Local Putonghua” and Others. World Chinese Teaching, 1991 (1): 13.
Funio, Inoue. (2019). New Dialect, Urbanization and Historical Sociolinguistics. Paper presented at 17Th Annual Meeting of Urban Language Studies, August 23–26, 2019. Xi’an, China. Proceedings pp. 11–13.
Guo, Jun. (2007). Language attitude and dialect varieties – A survey of language attitude and language usage in Lishui county. Social Sciences in Nanjing.
Hou, Jinyi. (1994). Review and Prospect of Putonghua (Mandarin) Promotion. Applied Linguistics (Yuyan Wenzi Yingyong), 1994/41: 74.
Lan, Binhan (2004). Several Adverbs of Degree in Xi’an Dialect. Journal of Shaanxi Normal University, 99.
Liu, Yuting, He, Shenjing, Wu, Fulong, Webster, Chris. (2010). Urban villages under China’s rapid urbanization: Unregulated assets and transitional neighbourhoods. Habitat International 341: 135–144.
Lu, Tuanhua. (2010). A Comparison between the Phonetic Features of Xi’an Dialect and the Pronunciation of Mandarin, Kaoshi Zhoukan 91.
MOE (2014). News Release of the 17th National Putonghua Promotion Week. Ministry of Education of PRC. [URL]
