Article published In: ITL - International Journal of Applied Linguistics
Vol. 63 (1984) ► pp.1–21
The Role of Field Independence in Foreign Language Instruction
Published online: 1 January 1984
https://doi.org/10.1075/itl.63.01dek
https://doi.org/10.1075/itl.63.01dek
Abstract
Based on the educational implications of field (in)dependence as described by Witkin et al. (1977), a series of hypotheses are formulated concerning the role of FI in L2-learning with different methods. Most existing L2-research, in contrast, has studied FI, usually assessed with the EFT, as an aptitude for learning with any particular teaching method, and has yielded somewhat inconsistent results, with a tendency to mild positive correlations between FI and L2-achievement. It is argued that FI in L2-learning should be viewed in the aptitude-treatment interaction paradigm and a series of suggestions are made concerning the assessment of FI as well as the design and the outcome measures for such interaction research.
References (48)
BERG, M.R. & HARRIS, L.J. (1980) : The effect of experimenter location and subject anxiety on cerebral activation as measured by lateral eye movements. Neuropsychologia 181, 89–93.
BIALYSTOK, E. & FROHLICH, M. (1978) : Variables of classroom achievement in second language learning. The Modern Language Journal 621, 327–336.
BROWN, H.D. (1973) : Affective variables in second language acquisition. Language Learning 231, 231–244.
(1977) : Cognitive and affective characteristics of good language learners. In C. Henning (ed.) : Proceedings of the Los Angeles Second Language Research Forum. Los Angeles : UCLA, 349–354.
CHASTAIN, K. (1975) : An examination of the basic assumption of 'individualized' instruction. The Modern Language Journal 591, 334–355.
CHICKERING, A.W. (1976) : The double bind of field dependence/independence in program alternatives for educational development. In S. Messick, et al.. : Individuality in Learning. San Francisco : Jossey-Bass, 79–89.
CORDER, S.P. (1976) : The study of interlanguage. In G. Nickel (ed.) : Proceedings of the Fourth International Congress of Applied Linguistics, vol. 21. Stuttgart : Hochschulverlag, 9–34.
CRONBACH, L.J. & SNOW, R.E. (1977) : Aptitudes and Instructional Methods. A Handbook for Research on Interactions. New York : Irvington.
DE FAZIO, V.J. (1973) : Field articulation differences in language abilities. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 251, 351–356.
DILLER, K.C. (1976) : Criteria for adapting language teaching methods to the learning styles and abilities of students. In G. Nickel (ed.) : Proceedings of the Fourth International Congress of Applied Linguistics, vol. 31. Stuttgart : Hochschulverlag, 341–351.
DOYLE, W. (1978) : Paradigms for research on teacher effectiveness. Review of Research in Education 51, 163–198.
GENESEE, F. (1978) : Individual differences in second language learning. Canadian Modern Language Review 341, 490–504.
GENESEE, F. & HAMAYAN, E. (1980) : Individual differences in second language learning. Applied Pyscholinguistics 11, 95–110.
GOLDSTEIN, K.M. & BLACMAN, S. (1978) : Cognitive Style : Five Approaches and Relevant Research. New York : John Wiley.
GRIPPIN, P.C. (1973) : Field independence and reflection-impulsitivity as mediators of performance on a programmed learning task with and without strong prompts. Paper presented to the American Psychological Association (University Microfilms 73–19, 674).
GRIPPIN, P.C. & OHNMACHT, F.W. (1974) : Field independence and dogmatism as mediators of performance on a programmed learning task with and without strong prompts. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association (ERIC Reproduction Service ED 095220).
HANSEN, J. & STANSFIELD, C. (1981) : The relationship of field-dependent-independent cognitive styles to foreign language achievement. Language Learning 311, 349–367.
HARTNETT, D.D. (1975) : The Relation of Cognitive Style and Hemispheric Preference to Deductive and Inductive Second Language Learning. Unpublished Master's Thesis, University of California at Los Angeles.
HAUPTMAN, P.C. (1971) : A structural approach versus a situational approach, to foreign-language teaching. Language Learning 211, 235–244.
HOSENFELD, C. (1979) : A learning-teaching view of second language instruction. Foreign Language Annals 121, 51–54.
KAGAN, D.M. (1980) : Syntactic complexity and cognitive style. Applied Psycholinguistics 11, 111–122.
KAGAN, S. & BURIEL, R. (1977) : Field dependence-independence and Mexican-American culture and education. In J.L. Martinez (ed.) : Chicano Psychology. New York, Academic Press.
KRASHEN, S.D. (1981) : Aptitude and attitude in relation to second language acguisition and learning. In : K.C. Diller (ed.) : Individual Differences and Universals in Language Learning Aptitutde. Rowley (Mass.) : Newbury House, 155–175.
KRASHEN, S.D., SELIGER, H. & HARTNETT, D. (1974) : Two studies in adult second language learning. Kritikon Litterarum 31, 220–228.
LEFEVER, M.M. & EHRI, L.C. (1976) : The relationship between field independence and sentence disambiguation ability. Journal of Psycho Unguis tic Research 51, 99–104.
LINN, M.C. & KYLLONEN, P. (1981) : The field-dependence-independence construct : some, one or none. Journal of Educational Psychology 731, 261–273.
NAIMAN, N., FROHLICH, M., STERN, H. & TODESCO, A. (1978) : The Good Language Learner. Toronto : Ontario Institute for Studies in Education.
NELSON, K. (1981) : Individual differences in language development : implications for development and language. Developmental Psychology 171, 170–187.
PACKER, J. & BAIN, J.D. (1978) : Cognitive style and teacher-student compatibility. Journal of Educational Psychology 701, 864–871.
PETERS, A.M. (1977) : Language Learning strategies : Does the whole equal the sum of the parts? Language 531, 560–573.
PETERSON, P.L. & SWING, S.R. (in press) : Beyond time on task : students' reports of their thought processes during direct instruction. The Elementary School Journal.
POOLE, M.E. (1978) : Exploration of relationship between linguistic, cognitive and verbal processing. Psychological Reports 431, 639–647.
ROSENSHINE, B. & FURST, N.F. (1973) : The use of direct observation to study teaching. In R.M.W. Travers (ed.) : Second Hanbook for Research on Teaching. Chicago : Rand McNally, 122–183.
SMITH, P.D. (1970) : A comparison of the Cognitive and Audiolingual Approaches to Foreign Language Instruction. The Pennsylvania Foreign Language Project. Philadelphia : Center for Curriculum Development.
TRIM, J.L.M., RICHTERICH, R., VAN EK, J.A. & WILKINS, D.A. (1980) : Systems development in adult language language learning : a European unit/credit system for modern language learning by adults. Strasbourg : Council of Europe.
TUCKER, W., HAMAYAN, E. & GENESEE, F. (1976) : Affective, cognitive and social factors in second language acquisition. Canadian Modern Language Review 231, 214–226.
VALETTE, R. (1969) : The Pennsylvania project, its conclusions and its implications. The Modern Language Journal 531, 396–404.
VAN EK, J.A. (1975) : The threshold level in a European unit/credit system for modern language learning by adults. Strasbourg, Council of Europe.
VAN ELS, T., EXTRA, G., VAN OS, C. & BONGAERTS, T. (1977) : Handboek voor de Toegepaste Taalkunde. Groningen : Wolters-Noordhoff.
WAPNER, S. (1976) : Process and context in the conception of cognitive style. In S. Messick, et al. (eds) : Individuality in Learning. San Francisco : Jossey-Bass, 73–78.
WELLS, W. (1978) : Aptitude à l'apprentissage d'une langue second et style cognitif. Paper presented at the Fifth International Congress of Applied Linguistics (Abstract in LLBA 12, n° 13, AILA Suppl. n° 2, p. 108a).
WESCHE, M.B. (1981) : Language aptitude measures in streaming, matching students with methods and diagnosis of learning problems. In K.C. Diller (ed.) : Individual Differences and Universals in Language Learning Aptitude. Rowley (Mass.) : Newbury House, 119–154.
WITKIN, H.A. (1976) : Cognitive style in academic performance and in teacher-student relations. In S. Messick, et al. (eds) : Individuality in Learning. San Francisco : Jossey-Bass, 38–72.
WITKIN, H.A., DYK, R.B., FATERSON, H.F., GOODENOUGH, D.R. & KARP, S.A. (1962) : Psychological Differentiation : Studies of Development. New York : John Wiley.
WITKIN, H.A. & GOODENOUGH, D.R. (1981) : Cognitive Styles : Essence and Origins. Field Dependence and Field Independence. New York : International Universities Press.
Cited by (1)
Cited by one other publication
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 30 march 2026. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.