Article published In: International Journal of Learner Corpus Research
Vol. 1:1 (2015) ► pp.7–24
Contrastive interlanguage analysis
A reappraisal
Published online: 23 March 2015
https://doi.org/10.1075/ijlcr.1.1.01gra
https://doi.org/10.1075/ijlcr.1.1.01gra
Since its introduction in 1996, Contrastive Interlanguage Analysis (CIA) has become a highly popular method in Learner Corpus Research. Its comparative design has made it possible to uncover a wide range of features distinctive of learner language and assess their degree of generalizability across learner populations. At the same time, however, the method has drawn criticism on several fronts. The purpose of this article is threefold: to provide a brief overview of CIA research, to discuss the main criticisms the method has faced in recent years and to present a revised model, CIA², which makes the central role played by variation in interlanguage studies more explicit and is generally more in line with the current state of foreign language theory and practice.
References (54)
Ädel, A. 2006. Metadiscourse in L1 and L2 English. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
. 2008. “Involvement features in writing: Do time and interaction trump register awareness?” In G. Gilquin, S. Papp, & B. Díez-Bedmar (Eds.), Linking Up Contrastive and Learner Corpus Research. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 33–53.
Aijmer, K. 2002. “Modality in advanced Swedish learners’ written interlanguage”. In S. Granger, J. Hung & S. Petch-Tyson (Eds.), Computer Learner Corpora, Second Language Acquisition and Foreign Language Learning. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 55–76.
Aston, G. 2008. “It’s only Human....”. In A. Martelli & V. Pulcini (Eds.), Investigating English with Corpora: Studies in Honour of Maria Teresa Prat. Monza: Polimetrica International Scientific Publisher, 343–354.
. 2011. “Applied corpus linguistics and the learning experience”. In V. Viana, S. Zingier & G. Barnbrook (Eds.), Perspectives on Corpus Linguistics. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 1–16.
Ballier, N. & Martin, P. forthcoming. “Speech annotation of learner corpora”. In S. Granger, G. Gilquin & F. Meunier (Eds.), Cambridge Handbook of Learner Corpus Research. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Barbieri, F. 2010. “Review of G. Gilquin, S. Papp & M. B. Díez-Bedmar (Eds.) Linking Up Contrastive and Learner Corpus Research. Amsterdam: Rodopi (2008)”, Studies in Second Language Acquisition 32(1), 148–150.
Bley-Vroman, R. 1983. “The comparative fallacy in interlanguage studies: the case of systematicity”, Language Learning 331, 1–17.
Breckle, M. & Zinsmeister, H. 2012. “A corpus-based contrastive analysis of local coherence in L1 and L2 German”. In V. Karabalić, M.A. Varga & L. Pon (Eds.), Discourse and Dialogue Studies between Theory, Research Methods, and Application/Diskurs- und Dialogforschungen zwischen Theorie, Methodik und Anwendung. Frankfurt/Main: Peter Lang, 235–250.
Brutt-Griffler, J. & Samimy, K.K. 2001. “Transcending the nativeness paradigm”, World Englishes 20(1), 99–106.
Callies, M. 2008. “Easy to understand but difficult to use? Raising constructions and information packaging in the advanced learner variety”. In G. Gilquin, M.B. Diez-Bedmar & S. Papp (Eds.), Linking Up Contrastive and Learner Corpus Research. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 201–226.
Cook, V. 2012. “Nativeness and language pedagogy”. In C. Chapelle (Ed.), The Encyclopedia of Applied Linguistics. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 4173–4176.
Dörnyei, Z. & Skehan, P. 2003. “Individual differences in second language learning”. In C.J. Doughty & M.H. Long (Eds.), The Handbook of Second Language Acquisition. Malden: Blackwell, 589–630.
Ferguson, G. 2009. “Issues in researching English as a lingua franca: a conceptual enquiry”, International Journal of Applied Linguistics 19(2), 117–135.
Giagkou, M., Kantzou, V., Stamouli, S. & Tzevelekou, M. 2013. “Discriminating CEFR levels in Greek L2: a corpus-based study of young learners’ written narratives”. Learner Corpus Research Conference – Book of Abstracts. Universitetet i Bergen, Norway, 49–50. Available at [URL] (accessed accessed 15 January 2015).
Gilquin, G. 2002. “Automatic retrieval of syntactic structures: The quest for the Holy Grail”, International Journal of Corpus Linguistics 7(2), 183–214.
. forthcoming. “At the interface of contact linguistics and second language acquisition research: New Englishes and Learner Englishes compared”, English World-Wide 36(1).
Gilquin, G. & Paquot, M. 2008. “Too chatty: Learner academic writing and register variation”, English Text Construction 11, 41–61.
Granger, S. 1993. “The International Corpus of Learner English”. In J. Aarts, P. de Haan & N. Oostdijk (Eds.), English Language Corpora: Design, Analysis and Exploitation. Amsterdam and Atlanta: Rodopi, 57–69.
. 1996. “From CA to CIA and back: An integrated contrastive approach to computerized bilingual and learner corpora”. In K. Aijmer, B. Altenberg & M. Johansson (Eds.), Languages in Contrast. Text-based cross-linguistic studies. Lund: Lund University Press, 37–51.
. 1998. “The computer learner corpus: a versatile new source of data for SLA research”. In S. Granger (Ed.), Learner English on Computer. London and New York: Longman, 3–18.
. 2002. “A bird’s-eye view of learner corpus research”. In S. Granger, J. Hung & S. Petch-Tyson (Eds.), Computer Learner Corpora, Second Language Acquisition and Foreign Language Learning. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 3–33.
. 2009. “The contribution of learner corpora to second language acquisition and foreign language teaching: A critical evaluation”. In K. Aijmer (Ed.), Corpora and Language Teaching. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 13–32.
. 2012a. “How to use foreign and second language learner corpora”. In A. Mackey & S.G. Gass (Eds), A Guide to Research Methods in Second Language Acquisition. Malden: Basil Blackwell, 7–29.
. 2012b. “Learner corpora”. In C.A. Chapelle (Ed.), The Encyclopedia of Applied Linguistics. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 3235–3242.
Granger, S. & Tyson, S. 1996. “Connector usage in the English essay writing of native and non-native EFL speakers of English”, World Englishes 15(1), 17–21.
Granger, S., Dagneaux, E., Meunier, F. & Paquot, M. 2009. International Corpus of Learner English. Version 2 (Handbook and CD-ROM). Louvain-la-Neuve: Presses universitaires de Louvain.
Hall, C.J., Wicaksono, R., Liu, S., Qian, Y. & Xiaoqing, X. 2013. English Reconceived: Raising Teachers’ Awareness of English as a ‘Plurilithic’ Resource Through an Online Course. ELT Research Papers 13-05. London: British Council. Available at [URL] (accessed 14 September 2014).
Hasselgård, H. & Johansson, S. 2011. “Learner corpora and contrastive interlanguage analysis”. In F. Meunier, S. De Cock, G. Gilquin & M. Paquot (Eds.), A Taste for Corpora. In Honour of Sylviane Granger. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 33–61.
Jantunen, J. & Brunni, S. 2013. “Morphology, lexical priming and second language acquisition: a corpus-study on learner Finnish”. In S. Granger, G. Gilquin & F. Meunier (Eds.), Twenty Years of Learner Corpus Research: Looking back, Moving ahead. Louvain-la-Neuve: Presses universitaires de Louvain, 235–245.
Johansson, S. 1991. “Times change, and so do corpora”. In K. Aijmer & B. Altenberg (Eds.), English Corpus Linguistics. London and New York: Longman, 305–314.
Lardiere, D. 2003. “Revisiting the comparative fallacy: a reply to Lakshmanan and Selinker, 2001”, Second Language Research 19(2): 129–143.
Larsen-Freeman, D. 2014. “Another step to be taken – Rethinking the end point of the interlanguage continuum”. In Z. Han & E. Tarone (Eds.), Interlanguage. Forty years later. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 203–220.
Lee, D. & Chen, S. 2009. “Making a bigger deal of the smaller words: Function words and other key items in research writing by Chinese learners”, Journal of Second Language Writing 181, 149–165.
Mauranen, A. 2011. “Learners and users – Who do we want data from?” In F. Meunier, S. De Cock, G. Gilquin & M. Paquot (Eds.), A Taste for Corpora. In honour of Sylviane Granger. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 155–171.
Möller, V. 2013. “How Do Educational Settings at the Secondary Level Impact on Learners’ Use of the English Passive? – Evidence from the Secondary-Level Corpus of Learner English (SCooLE)”. Paper presented at the
Learner Corpus Research Conference
, Bergen, Norway, 27-29 September 2013. [URL] (last accessed 15 September 2014).
Ortega, L. & Byrnes, H. 2008. “Theorizing advancedness, setting up the longitudinal research agenda”. In L. Ortega & H. Byrnes (Eds.), The Longitudinal Study of Advanced L2 Capacities. New York and London: Routledge, 281–300.
Paquot, M. 2010. Academic Vocabulary in Learner Writing. From Extraction to Analysis. London and New York: Continuum.
. 2014. “Cross-linguistic influence and formulaic language. Recurrent word sequences in French learner writing”. In L. Roberts, I. Vedder & J. Hulstijn (Eds.), EUROSLA Yearbook 2014. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: Johns Benjamins, 240–261.
Paquot, M. & Granger, S. 2012. “Formulaic language in learner corpora”, Annual Review of Applied Linguistics 321, 130–149.
Péry-Woodley, M.-P. 1990. “Contrastive discourses: Contrastive analysis and a discourse approach to writing”, Language Teaching 231, 143–151.
Romaine, S. 2003. “Variation”. In C.J. Doughty & M.H. Long (Eds.), The Handbook of Second Language Acquisition. Malden: Blackwell, 409–435.
Seidlhofer, B. 2001. “Closing a conceptual gap: the case for a description of English as a lingua franca”, International Journal of Applied Linguistics 11(2), 133–158.
Selinker, L. 2014. “Interlanguage 40 years on. Three themes from here”. In Z. Han & E. Tarone (Eds.), Interlanguage. Forty years later. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 221–246.
Shea, M. 2009. “A corpus-based study of adverbial connectors in learner text”, MSU Working Papers in SLS 1(1), 1–13.
Springer, P.E. 2012. Advanced Learner Writing. A Corpus-based Study of the Discourse Competence of Dutch Writers of English in the Light of the C1/C2 Levels of the CEFR. Oisterwijk: BOXpress.
Strawn, B.A. 2009. “Comparative approaches: History, theory and the image of God”. In J. LeMon & K. Richards (Eds.), Method Matters: Essays on the Interpretation of the Hebrew Bible in Honor of David L. Petersen. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 117–142.
Sung Park, E. 2004. “The Comparative Fallacy in UG Studies”, Working Papers in TESOL and Applied Linguistics 4(1), 1–4. Available at [URL] (accessed 15 September 2014).
Tan, M. 2005. “Authentic language or language errors? Lessons from a learner corpus”, ELT Journal 59(2), 126–134.
Cited by (140)
Cited by 140 other publications
Chen, Jiaxin, Yao Yao & Dechao Li
Cock, Sylvie De
de Crignis, Patricia
Gafni, Chen, Livnat Herzig Sheinfux, Hadar Klunover, Anat Bar Siman Tov, Anat Prior & Shuly Wintner
Gan, Qiao & Min Wang
2025. Examining contextual constraints on the English dative alternation in L2 written production. International Journal of Corpus Linguistics 30:3 ► pp. 265 ff.
Granger, Sylviane & Magali Paquot
Götz, Sandra
Huang, Lan-fen
Kim, Seonwoong & Sun-Young Oh
Larsson, Tove, Marcus Callies, Tülay Dixon, Hilde Hasselgård, Nicole Hober, Natalia Judith Laso, Sanne van Vuuren, Isabel Verdaguer & Magali Paquot
2025. Adverb placement in L1 and L2 spoken production. International Journal of Corpus Linguistics 30:1 ► pp. 79 ff.
Larsson, Tove & Gaëtanelle Gilquin
Lorenz, Anne & Constanze Weth
2025.
Faktör — factoure —
facteure?. In Early Language Education in Instructed Contexts [Language Learning & Language Teaching, 62], ► pp. 140 ff.
Pan, Zhaoyi
Song, Yingming & Jiajin Xu
Taş, Songül
Wang, Ying, Henrik Kaatari, Tove Larsson, Hongping Xiong & Fei Liu
Wedig, Helena, Carola Strobl, Jim J. J. Ureel & Tanja Mortelmans
Wedig, Helena, Carola Strobl, Jim J. J. Ureel, Tanja Mortelmans & Larissa Weber
2025. The influence of L1 Dutch on connective use in L2 German academic writing. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research
Akeel, Eman S.
Chen, Jiaxin, Dechao Li & Kanglong Liu
Chung, Tieu Thuy & Peter R. Crosthwaite
Gan, Qiao
Hollmann, Willem B., Kazuko Fujimoto & Masahiro Kuroda
Ishikawa, Shin'ichiro
Kopotev, Mikhail, Olesya Kisselev & Maria Polinsky
Kotze, Haidee & Bertus van Rooy
2024. Introduction. In Constraints on Language Variation and Change in Complex Multilingual Contact Settings [Contact Language Library, 60], ► pp. 1 ff.
Lim, Joyce Dong Ok, Geraldine Mark, Pascual Pérez-Paredes & Anne O’Keeffe
Liu, Dilin, Xiaofei Lu & Isaiah W. Yoo
2024. Corpus linguistics and second language studies. Journal of Second Language Studies 7:2 ► pp. 193 ff.
Lücke, Stephan, Patricia de Crignis, Johanna Wolf & Florian Zacherl
Lücke, Stephan, Patricia de Crignis, Johanna Wolf & Florian Zacherl
Mair, Christian
Marynenko, Pavlo & Tatjana Portnova
Paquot, Magali
Zhang, Jingxin, Yabo Yan & Yong Mei
2024. Review of Ishikawa (2023): The ICNALE Guide: An Introduction to a Learner Corpus Study on Asian Learners’ L2 English. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 10:2 ► pp. 377 ff.
Abboud, Omaima
Ahmed, Abdelhamid M. & Xiao Zhang
Chen, Howard, Keiko Mochizuki & Hongyin Tao
Friginal, Eric, Ashleigh Cox & Rachelle Udell
Granger, Sylviane & Marie-Aude Lefer
Ishikawa, Shin’ichiro
Meunier, Fanny, Isa Hendrikx, Amélie Bulon, Kristel Van Goethem & Hubert Naets
Paquot, Magali & Nicole Tracy‐Ventura
Yang, Ting-Yu, Hui-Mei Yang, Wei-Jei Lee, Chen-Yu Liu & Howard Hao-Jan Chen
Bikelienė, Lina, Rita Juknevičienė, Nida Poderienė, Joana Pribušauskaitė & Aurelija Tamulionienė
Chen, Jianhua & Xiaopeng Zhang
Du, Hang
Du, Hang
2022. Building a corpus of spoken Chinese interlanguage and some results of preliminary analyses. Chinese as a Second Language (漢語教學研究—美國中文教師學會學報). The journal of the Chinese Language Teachers Association, USA 57:3 ► pp. 238 ff.
Dutra, Deise Prina, Bárbara Malveira Orfanò, Annallena de Souza Guedes, Jessica Ceritello Alves & João Gabriel Fekete
Fandrych, Christian & Franziska Wallner
Ferreira Cabrera, Anita Alejandra, Jessica Elejalde Gómez & Lorena Blanco San Martín
Forti, Luciana
2022. Review of Lu (2017): A Corpus Study of Collocation in Chinese Learner English. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 8:1 ► pp. 144 ff.
Forti, Luciana
2024. Proficiency-rated learner corpora. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 10:1 ► pp. 216 ff.
Götz, Sandra, Christoph Wolk & Katja Jäschke
2022. Contextualizing fluency in advanced spoken learner language. In Complexity, Accuracy and Fluency in Learner Corpus Research [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 104], ► pp. 273 ff.
Karges, Katharina, Thomas Studer & Nina Selina Hicks
Kekki, Niina & Ilmari Ivaska
2022. The use of synonymous adjectives by learners of Finnish as a second language. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 8:1 ► pp. 67 ff.
Laporte, Samantha & Bert Cappelle
Leńko-Szymańska, Agnieszka & Sandra Götz
2022. Complexity, accuracy and fluency in learner corpus research. In Complexity, Accuracy and Fluency in Learner Corpus Research [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 104], ► pp. 1 ff.
Lozano, Cristóbal
Lozano, Cristóbal & Paloma Fernández-Mira
Rojo, Guillermo, Ignacio Palacios, María Sampedro Mella & Aurélie Marsily
Schönström, Krister & Johanna Mesch
2022. Second language acquisition of depicting signs. Language, Interaction and Acquisition 13:2 ► pp. 199 ff.
Vuuren, Sanne van, Janine Berns & Marketa Bank
2022. Strategies of clausal postmodification in learner English. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 8:2 ► pp. 157 ff.
Breindl, Eva
Chung, Tieu-Thuy, Luyen-Thi Bui & Peter Crosthwaite
Deng, Fei & Timothy V. Rasinski
Ferreira, Anita, Lorena Blanco & Jessica Elejalde
Hasselgård, Hilde
Larsson, Tove, Magali Paquot & Douglas Biber
2021. On the importance of register in learner writing. In Corpus-based approaches to register variation [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 103], ► pp. 235 ff.
Sampedro Mella, María
Schönström, Krister
Shadrova, Anna, Pia Linscheid, Julia Lukassek, Anke Lüdeling & Sarah Schneider
Wolk, Christoph, Sandra Götz & Katja Jäschke
Yildiz, Mustafa & Ümit Deniz Turan
Appel, Randy
Appel, Randy & Lewis Murray
Bell, Philippa, Laura Collins & Emma Marsden
Cabrera, Anita Ferreira & Jessica Elejalde Gómez
Ferreira Cabrera, Anita & Jessica Elejalde Gómez
Díez-Bedmar, María Belén & Pascual Pérez-Paredes
2020. Noun phrase complexity in young Spanish EFL learners’ writing. International Journal of Corpus Linguistics 25:1 ► pp. 4 ff.
Gilquin, Gaëtanelle
Gilquin, Gaëtanelle
Gilquin, Gaëtanelle
Ionin, Tania & María Belén Díez-Bedmar
Ivaska, Ilmari & Silvia Bernardini
Larsson, Tove, Marcus Callies, Hilde Hasselgård, Natalia Judith Laso, Sanne van Vuuren, Isabel Verdaguer & Magali Paquot
2020. Adverb placement in EFL academic writing. International Journal of Corpus Linguistics 25:2 ► pp. 156 ff.
Meriläinen, Lea
Möller, Verena
Navarro Gil, Noelia & Helena Roquet Pugès
2020. Linking or delinking of ideas?. Revista Española de Lingüística Aplicada/Spanish Journal of Applied Linguistics 33:2 ► pp. 505 ff.
Polio, Charlene & Hyung-Jo Yoon
Smirnova, Elizaveta & Svetlana Strinyuk
Van Mensel, Luk, Amélie Bulon, Isa Hendrikx, Fanny Meunier & Kristel Van Goethem
2020. Effects of input on L2 writing in English and Dutch. Journal of Immersion and Content-Based Language Education 8:2 ► pp. 173 ff.
Werner, Valentin, Robert Fuchs & Sandra Götz
Biel, Albert
2019. Complexity and qualitative lexical knowledge. In Learner Corpora and Language Teaching [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 92], ► pp. 51 ff.
Dutra, Deise Prina, Bárbara Malveira Orfanó & Valdenia Carvalho Almeida
D’Arienzo, Meredith
2019. Cohesion or coesione?. In Learner Corpora and Language Teaching [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 92], ► pp. 75 ff.
Lee, Lung-Hao, Yuen-Hsien Tseng & Li-Ping Chang
Lorenz, Eliane & Peter Siemund
Lozano, Cristóbal & Ana Díaz-Negrillo
2019. Using learner corpus methods in L2 acquisition
research. Revista Española de Lingüística Aplicada/Spanish Journal of Applied Linguistics 32:1 ► pp. 82 ff.
Puga, Karin
2019. English intonation of advanced learners. In Learner Corpora and Language Teaching [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 92], ► pp. 191 ff.
Romano, Francesco
Rosen, Anna
2019. The use of smallwords in the speech of German learners of English. In Learner Corpora and Language Teaching [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 92], ► pp. 219 ff.
Rosen, Anna
2019. The use of smallwords in the speech of German learners of English. In Learner Corpora and Language Teaching [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 92], ► pp. 219 ff.
Torres, René Edgardo Oportus & Anita Alejandra Ferreira Cabrera
Xu, Jiajin
Zhang, Yan
Appel, Randy & Andrzej Szeib
Liu, Dilin
2018. A corpus study of Chinese EFL learners’ use of circumstance, demand, and significant
. Journal of Second Language Studies 1:2 ► pp. 310 ff.
Przewozny-Desriaux, Anne
Pérez-Guerra, Javier
Riera, R., V.M. Tuset, R. Betancur-R, A. Lombarte, C. Marcos & A. Pérez-Ruzafa
Romero-Trillo, Jesús
Crosthwaite, Peter, Lisa Cheung & Feng (Kevin) Jiang
Gablasova, Dana, Vaclav Brezina & Tony McEnery
Gablasova, Dana, Vaclav Brezina & Tony McEnery
2019. The Trinity Lancaster Corpus
. In Learner Corpora and Language Teaching [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 92], ► pp. 7 ff.
Gablasova, Dana, Vaclav Brezina & Tony McEnery
Granger, Sylviane
Granger, Sylviane
Granger, Sylviane
2018. Tracking the third code. In The Corpus Linguistic Discourse [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 87], ► pp. 185 ff.
Granger, Sylviane
Granger, Sylviane
2024. From early to future learner corpus research. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 10:2 ► pp. 247 ff.
Larsson, Tove
Paquot, Magali & Luke Plonsky
2017. Quantitative research methods and study quality in learner corpus research. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 3:1 ► pp. 61 ff.
Raksangob Wijitsopon
Werner, Valentin
Alonso-Ramos, Margarita
2016. Spanish learner corpus research. In Spanish Learner Corpus Research [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 78], ► pp. 3 ff.
Buyse, Kris, Lydia Fernández Pereda & Katrien Verveckken
2016. The Aprescrilov corpus, or broadening the horizon of Spanish language learning in Flanders. In Spanish Learner Corpus Research [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 78], ► pp. 143 ff.
Campillos Llanos, Leonardo
2016. PoS-tagging a Spanish oral learner corpus. In Spanish Learner Corpus Research [Studies in Corpus Linguistics, 78], ► pp. 89 ff.
Crosthwaite, Peter
Lee, Lung-Hao, Li-Ping Chang & Yuen-Hsien Tseng
Vyatkina, Nina
2016. TheKansas Developmental Learner corpus(KANDEL). International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 2:1 ► pp. 101 ff.
Ivaska, Ilmari
2015. Longitudinal changes in academic learner Finnish. International Journal of Learner Corpus Research 1:2 ► pp. 210 ff.
Lin, Yen-Liang
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 12 december 2025. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.
