Article published In: International Journal of Chinese Linguistics
Vol. 11:2 (2024) ► pp.280–312
崔世珍笔下的明代中期北京话
Article language: Chinese
Published online: 5 December 2024
https://doi.org/10.1075/ijchl.00031.wan
https://doi.org/10.1075/ijchl.00031.wan
Abstract
The Beijing dialect of the mid-Ming dynasty as depicted by Cui Shizhen
Cui Shizhen (1468–1542), a prolific writer, recorded and discussed a vast array of lexical and phonological
phenomena of the Beijing dialect during the mid-Ming Dynasty. This period marked a critical phase in the integration of northern
and southern Mandarin, a time when local records of the Beijing dialect were exceedingly rare. Thus, the colloquial data recorded
by Cui Shizhen are uniquely invaluable, offering profound insights into the historical formation of the Beijing dialect. This
paper primarily addresses four questions: (1) whether the data recorded by Cui indeed represent the Beijing dialect; (2) the
characteristics of the data recorded by Cui; (3) the integration of northern and southern Mandarin lexicon during the mid-Ming
Dynasty as reflected in Cui’s recordings; and (4) the survival and disappearance of the mid-Ming Beijing dialect vocabulary in
modern Beijing dialect.
Keywords: Cui Shizhen, mid-Ming dynasty, Beijing dialect, lexicon, phonology
Article outline
- 一、绪论
- 二、崔世珍所记是不是北京话
- 第一, “崔世珍们”学习汉语口语的目的。
- 第二, 崔世珍是有机会到北京去“质正”的。
- 第三, 不得已而去辽东质正,也是向精通汉语的硕学鸿儒质正,而不是一般的辽东人。
- 第四, 除了面对面质正学习外,崔世珍还拥有丰富的书面资料可供参考。
- 三、崔世珍所记资料的特点
- 四、从崔世珍所记看明代中期南北官话词汇的融合
- 1.沿用大都话
- 2.大都话被淘汰
- 3.融入南方话
- 例1 立-站
- 例2 赤根菜-菠䔖菜/菠菜
- 例3 伴当-火伴/舍人
- 五、明代中期的北京话词汇在现代北京话里的留存与消亡
- 致谢
- 笔记
参考文献
References (38)
Chen, Li 陈莉 (2006). “Xunshipinghua” cihui yanjiu 训世评话词汇研究 [Vocabulary Study of ‘Xunshipinghua’]. Nanjingdaxue shuoshi xuewei lunwen 南京大学硕士学位论文 [Nanjing University Master’s Thesis].
Ding, Feng 丁锋 (1995). Liuhanduiyin yu Mingdai guanhuayin yanjiu 琉汉对音与明代官话音研究 [Study on the Phonetic Comparison between Ryukyuan and Mandarin of
the Ming Dynasty]. Beijing: China Social Sciences Press.
Dong, Shuren 董树人 (2010). Xinbian
Beijing fangyan cidian 新编北京方言词典 [New
Compilation of Beijing Dialect
Dictionary]. Beijing: The Commercial Press.
Geng, Zhensheng 耿振生 (2007). Cong lishi
shang de renkou bianqian kan jindai Beijinghua de dishan yanxu 从历史上的人口变迁看近代北京话的递嬗延续 [The Continuity of Modern Beijing Dialect from the
Perspective of Historical Population Changes]. Jindai
guanhua yuyin yanjiu 近代官话语音研究 [Research on Early Mandarin Phonology].
(2007). Jindai
guanhua yuyin yanjiu 近代官话语音研究 [A Study
on the Phonology of Early
Mandarin]. Beijing: Language & Culture Press.
Guo, Rui 郭锐, Zhai, Yun 翟赟 and Xu, Jingjing 徐菁菁 (2017). Hanyu
putonghua cong nali lai? — cong nanbei guanhua chayi kan putonghua cihui, yufa laiyuan 汉语普通话从哪里来?——从南北官话差异看普通话词汇、语法来源 [Where Does Mandarin Come From?
— A Look at the Vocabulary and Grammar Origins from the Differences between Northern and Southern
Mandarin]. Zhongguo yanyu wenhuaxue
yanjiu 中国言语文化学研究 [Journal of Chinese
Language and Culture] 61.
He, Liang 何亮 (2023). Hanyu
fangyan “bangwan”, “yewan” yi shiwei yusu de gongshi fenbu yu lishi kaocha 汉语方言傍晚、夜晚义时位语素的共时分布与历时考察 [Synchronic and Diachronic Examination of the
‘evening and night’ in Chinese Dialects]. 待刊 [to be
published].
(2017). Hanyu
fangyan rinei shijian de biaoda geju jiqi chengyin tanxi 汉语方言日内时间的表达格局及其成因探析 [Analysis of the Patterns and Causes for Expressing
Time of Day in Chinese Dialects]. Hanyushi
xuebao 汉语史学报 [Journal of Chinese
Language History] 171.
Hirata, Shouji 平田昌司 (2016). Wenhua
zhidu he hanyushi 文化制度和汉语史 [Cultural
Systems and Chinese Language
History]. Beijing: Peking University Press.
Ji, Yonghai 季永海 (1999). Hanyu
“erhuayin” de fasheng yu fazhan — jian yu Li Sijing xiansheng shangque 汉语儿化音的发生与发展——兼与李思敬先生商榷 [The Emergence and Development of the ‘Erhua’ Sound
in Chinese — A Discussion with Mr. Li Sijing]. Minzu
yuwen 民族语文 [Minority Languages of
China] 51.
Li, Shunmei 李顺美 (2009). Shi
“jiaotou” “kong” “jia” 释“角头” “控” “家” [An Explanation on “jiaotou” “kong” and “jia”]. Minzu yuwen 民族语文 [Minority Languages
of China] 41.
Li, Wuwei 李无未 and Zhang, Hui 张辉 (2014). Chaoxianchao hanyu guanhua “zhizheng” zhidu kaolun — yi “Chaoxianwangchaoshilu” wei yiju 朝鲜朝汉语官话质正制度考论——以朝鲜王朝实录为依据 [A Study on Joseon Dynasty Chinese
Mandarin “zhizheng” System-On the basis of the ‘Annals of the Joseon Dynasty’]. Guhanyu yanjiu 古汉语研究 [Research In Ancient Chinese Language] 11.
Li, Xinkui 李新魁 (1980). Lun jindai
hanyu gongtongyu de biaozhunyin 论近代汉语共同语的标准音 [On the Standard Pronunciation of Modern Chinese Common
Language]. Yuwen yanjiu 语文研究 [Linguistic
Research] 11.
Lin, Tao 林焘 (1987). Beijing
guanhua suyuan 北京官话溯源 [Tracing the Origins of Beijing Mandarin]. Zhongguo
yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese
Language] 31.
Lin, Yimeng 林祎萌 (2023). Shuo fuci
“hai” duyin de yanbian 说副词“还”读音的演变 [The Evolution of the Adverb “hai” Pronunciation]. 待刊 [to be
published].
Lu, Guoyao 鲁国尧 (1985). Mingdai
guanhua jiqi jichu fangyan wenti — du “Limadouzhongguozhaji” 明代官话及其基础方言问题——读利玛窦中国札记 [Mandarin of the Ming Dynasty and Its Basic Dialect
Issues — Reading ‘Matteo Ricci’s China Notes’]. Nanjingdaxue
xuebao (zhexue renwenkexue shehuikexue) 南京大学学报(哲学·人文科学·社会科学) [Journal of Nanjing University(Philosophy, Humanities and
Social Sciences)] 41.
Ota, Tatsuo 太田辰夫 (1994). “Yanshanconglu” ni miru mingdai Beijingyu 燕山丛录に见る明代北京语 [Ming Dynasty Beijing Dialect as Seen in the
‘Yanshanconglu’]. Zhongguoyu
yanjiu 中国语研究 [Studies in the Chinese
Language] 361.
(1991). Guanyu
“haneryanyu” — shilun baihua fazhanshi 关于汉儿言语——试论白话发展史 [About “haneryanyu” — An Attempt to Discuss the History of
Verbal Chinese Development]. Hanyushi
tongkao 汉语史通考 [Comprehensive
Examination of Chinese Language History].
(2003). Zhongguoyu
lishi wenfa 中国语历史文法 [Historical
Grammar of Chinese Language]. Beijing: Peking University Press.
Wang, Hongjun 王洪君, Guo, Rui 郭锐 and Liu, Yunzong 刘云总 (2018). Zaoqi
Beijinghua zhenben dianji jiaoshi yu yanjiu 早期北京话珍本典籍校释与研究 [Annotated Research on Early Beijing Dialect
Classics]. Beijing: Peking University Press.
Wang, Weihui 汪维辉 (2018). Jindai
guanhua cihui xitong de xingcheng — yi “Xunshipinghua” yu “Laoqidayanjie” “Piaotongshiyanjie” de bijiao wei
chufadian 近代官话词汇系统的形成——以训世评话与老乞大朴通事的比较为出发点 [The Formation of the Modern Mandarin
Vocabulary System — Starting from a Comparison between ‘Xunshipinghua’ and
‘Laoqida’‘Piaotongshi’]. Nankai yuyan
xuekan 南开语言学刊 [Nankai
Linguistics] 11.
(2022a). Chaoxian
shidai hanyu jiaokeshu shizhong huiji 朝鲜时代汉语教科书十种汇辑 [A Compilation of Ten Types of Chinese Language Textbooks in Joseon
Dynasty]. Shanghai: Shanghai Educational Publishing House.
(2022b). Zai tan
“gei” de laiyuan — yu Zhao Kuixin xiansheng shangque jian lun zici guanxi de fuzaxing 再谈“给(gěi)”的来源——与赵葵欣先生商榷兼论字词关系的复杂性 [The Origin of “gei”
Revisited: A Discussion with Mrs. Zhao Kuixin and Some lssuesof the Complexity of the Character-word
Relation]. Fangyan 方言 [Dialect] 31.
Wang, Weihui 汪维辉 and Akidani Hiroyuki 秋谷裕幸 (2010). Hanyu
“zhanli” yi ci de xianzhuang yu lishi 汉语“站立”义词的现状与历史 [Synchronic Distribution and Diachronic Development of the
Words with the Meaning “to stand” in Chinese]. Zhongguo
yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese
Language] 41.
Wang, Weihui 汪维辉 and Ju, Minhui 具民惠 (2022). “赤根菜”与“시금치”——韩语中的汉语借词研究之一 [“chigencai” and “시금치” — A Study on Chinese
Loanwords in Korean]. Yuyan
yanjiu 语言研究 [Studies in Language and
Linguistics] 11.
Wang, Weihui 汪维辉 and Xu, Junwei 许峻玮 (2018). “Yanshanconglu·changanliyu” zhong de wanming Beijinghua 燕山丛录·长安里语中的晚明北京话 [Late Ming Beijing Dialect in
‘Yanshanconglu·Changanliyu’]. Yuyanxue
luncong 语言学论丛 [Essays on
Linguistics] 581.
Yang, Jianqiao 杨剑桥 (2003). Chaoxian
“Sishengtongjie” zai hanyushi yanjiu shang de jiazhi 朝鲜四声通解在汉语史研究上的价值 [The Value of Korean ‘Sishengtongjie’ in the Study of the
History of the Chinese Language]. Fudan xuebao(shehuikexue
ban) 复旦学报(社会科学版) [Fudan Journal(Social
Sciences Edition)] 61.
Yao, Weijia 姚伟嘉 (2017). Chenghuaben
“Baituji” zhong beifang suyuci zhaji 成化本白兔记中北方俗语词札记 [Notes on Northern Vernacular Words in the Chenghua Edition
‘Baituji’]. Zhongguoyuxue
kaipian 中国语学·开篇 [Chinese Language
Studies: Beginning] 351.
Yao, Xiaoping 姚小平 (2020). Jindai
Beijinghua yu Nanjinghua: 17–19 shiji xishi bixia de beinan guanhua zhi zheng 近代北京话与南京话:17―19世纪西士笔下的北南官话之争 [Premodern Dialects of Beijing
and Nanjing: Rivalry between the Two Major Branches of Mandarin as Described by Westerners during the 17–19th
Centuries]. Zhongguo yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese
Language] 41.
Yin, Xiaojie 殷晓杰, Chen, Chunxue 陈春雪 and Chen, Ji a陈佳 (2017). Zai lun
“zhu” yu “kuai(zi)” de lishi tihuan ji xiangguan wenti 再论“箸”与“筷(子)”的历时替换及相关问题 [Again on the Diachronic Replacement of “zhu” and
“kuai(zi)” and Related Issues]. Hanyushi
xuebao 汉语史学报 [Journal of Chinese
Language History] 171.
Yu Chi, Zhiping 尉迟治平 (1990). “Laoqida
Piaotongshi yanjie” hanziyin de yuyin jichu 老乞大、朴通事谚解汉字音的语音基础 [The Phonological Basis of Sino-Korean in ‘Laoqidayanjie’
and ‘Piaotongshiyanjie’]. Yuyan
yanjiu 语言研究 [Studies in Language and
Linguistics] 11.
Yu, Min 俞敏 (1984). Beijing
yinxi de chengzhang he ta shou de zhouwei yingxiang 北京音系的成长和它受的周围影响 [The Growth of the Beijing Phonological System and Its
External Influences]. Fangyan 方言 [Dialect] 41.
Zhang, Weidong 张卫东 (1998). Beijingyin
heshi chengwei hanyu guanhua biaozhunyin 北京音何时成为汉语官话标准音 [When Beijing Sounds Became the Standard Sound Systemof
Chinese Mandarin?]. Shenzhendaxue xuebao (renwen shehuikexue
ban) 深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版) [Journal of
Shenzhen University(Humanities & Social Sciences)] 41.
Zhang, Yulai 张玉来 and Yin, Yu 尹瑀 (2021). Mingdai
laihua ouzhou chuanjiaoshi suo ji hanyu — fei Mingdai hanyu guanhua “Nanjing biaozhunyin
shuo” 明代来华欧洲传教士所记汉语——非明代汉语官话“南京标准音说” [A Study on the Nature of Mandarin Recorded by European Missionaries in the MingDynasty: Nanjing Dialect Was Not
the Standard Pronunciation of Mandarin in the Ming Dynasty]. Dongfang luntan — Qingdaodaxue xuebao (shehui kexue ban) 东方论坛——青岛大学学报(社会科学版) [Eastern Forum-Journal of Qingdao University(Social Science
Edition)] 51.
Zhao, Kuixin 赵葵欣 (2021). Mingqing
Beijing guanhua wenxian zhong biao jiyuyi de “gei” de duyin 明清北京官话文献中表给予义的“给[kei]”的读音 [The Pronunciations of the GlVE Verb “gei” in
Mandarin Literatures in Ming and Qing Dynasties]. Fangyan 方言 [Dialect] 31.
Zhou, Jianshe 周建设 (2014–2015). Ming,
Qing, Minguo shiqi zhenxi lao Beijinghua lishi wenxian zhengli yu yanjiu 明、清、民国时期珍稀老北京话历史文献整理与研究 [Compilation and Research on Rare Historical Documents of
Old Beijing Dialect from the Ming, Qing, and Republic of China
Periods]. Beijing: Beijing Capital Normal University Press.
