In:History, Discourse, and Policy in Modern Turkey
Alper Çakmak
[Discourse Approaches to Politics, Society and Culture 95] 2021
► pp. 147–186
Chapter 5Discourse and policy
Between utopia and reality
Published online: 26 October 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/dapsac.95.c5
https://doi.org/10.1075/dapsac.95.c5
Abstract
Discourse is a reflection of ideological underpinnings regarding “what ought to be.” It is sometimes too fabulous to be practiced. It is, in one way, among many others, a perspective into a rhetorician’s utopia. It is sometimes wholly emancipated and produced independently from the real world, where policy is the outcome produced, or “what it is.” The relationship between political discourse and policy is complicated and dependent on various conditions. The preceding chapters have shown how discourse systematically deconstructs the dominant ideology and reconstructs its own as an alternative and situates the self as the appropriate teller and doer. However, no investigation has been directed to how reconstructed political discourse is translated into policy. This chapter illuminates the modus operandi that underlies the relationship between discourse and policy and that can be applied in the study of other case countries and politicians with respect to domestic and foreign policy. The chapter introduces the following terms to explicate the association: incremental discourse, avulsive discourse, incremental policy, avulsive policy, normative/moralist realm, realpolitik realm, and structural limits of power and domination.
Article outline
- 5.1The hypothesis for the modus operandi of the relationship between discourse and policy
- 5.1.1Discourse and policy on the presidential system of government
- 5.1.2Discourse and policy: “Mon chers”
- 5.2Discourse and policy: Moralism without outer limits
- 5.2.1Discourse on Syrian refugees and Syrian refugees policy
- 5.2.2Discourse on the victory of Malazgirt: Reflection of the ideational world (discourse) and policy
- 5.2.3Discourse on the execution of Motiur Rehman Nizami and policy
- 5.2.4Ottoman language course: Discourse and policy
- 5.3Discourse and policy: Moralism with outer limits
- 5.3.1Discourse on the Lausanne Treaty: Reflection of the ideational world (discourse) and official statement (policy)
- 5.3.2Discourse on the Uyghur Turks in Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region: Reflection of the ideational world (discourse) and official statement (policy)
- 5.3.3Discourse on the military presence in the region: Concurring discourse and policy
- 5.3.4Discourse and policy: Turkey – Israel relations
- 5.3.5Discourse and policy: The Ottoman military barracks, Taksim Mosque and Atatürk Cultural Center in Taksim
- 5.3.6Discourse and policy: Al-Quds (Jerusalem) question and relations with Israel
Notes
