Article published In: Chinese Language and Discourse
Vol. 15:1 (2024) ► pp.51–72
对既存并列项的觉察与选择
“反正”的会话分析
Article language: Chinese
Published online: 28 August 2023
https://doi.org/10.1075/cld.23007.jia
https://doi.org/10.1075/cld.23007.jia
摘要
摘要 本文采用会话分析的研究方法,根据汉语自然会话中“反正”引导的话语出现的序列环境和话轮设计方式,证明“反正”作为一种“表明对既存并列项的察觉和选择”的装置(device)在言谈互动中被广泛使用,其基本功能是,交际者在察觉到前文中显性或者隐性地存在着源自不同交际者话语的两个或数个并列项后,通过“反正”引导的话语表明要在其中做出选择的态度。在此基础上,本文还论证了以往研究中提到的“反正”一语所具有的“对不同意见的坚持”“表示让步”“态度指示”“回归话题”和“总结”等功能都是由上述功能衍生而来的。最后,本文明确了“反正”作为互动行为资源,具有“暗示对比”和“实现对话题的控制”等功能。
Abstract
Expressing awareness and choice of existing coordinated elements: ‑fanzheng‑prefaced turns in Chinese conversations
This paper presents a Conversation Analysis of the use of fanzheng (anyway) in Chinese conversations. By employing Conversation Analytic methods, the study shows that fanzheng (anyway) is frequently used to express an interactant’s awareness and choice of existing coordinated elements in a conversation. Functionally, fanzheng (anyway) can express interactants’ attitude and choice when they are aware of the explicit or implicit presence of two or more coordinated elements in the utterances of different interactants in the context. Based on previous studies on fanzheng (anyway), this study also shows other conversational functions derived from fanzheng (anyway), such as expressing persistence toward disaffiliation, displaying downgrading disaffiliation, marking an attitude, marking a resumption, and articulating a concluding remark, etc. This study concludes that fanzheng (anyway) serves as an interactional resource in conversation.
Article outline
- 1.引言
- 2.“反正” 研究文献概览
- 3.研究对象
- 4.“反正” 的功能
- 4.1意识到观点冲突并从中做出选择,表明态度
- 4.2意识到两个或多个观点并列并从中做出选择,表明态度
- 4.3意识到信息的并存并进行选择
- 4.4由“表明对既存并列项的察觉和选择”衍生的“态度指示”“消弭相异立场”“回归”“总结”功能
- 4.5“例外”情况分析
- 5.作为互动行为资源的“反正”
- 5.1暗示对比
- 5.2实现对话题的控制
- 6.总结
- 致谢
- 笔记
参考文献
References (16)
Dong, Zhengcun 董正存. “Qingtai fuci ‘fanzheng’ de yongfa ji xiangguan wenti yanjiu 情态副词“反正”的用法及相关问题研究 [Study on the Usage of Modal Adverb ‘Fanzheng’ and Related Issues]”, Linguistic Research 语文研究 2008, 21:12-16+22.
Gao, Hua, and Tao, Hongyin. 2021. Fanzheng ‘anyway’ as a discourse pragmatic particle in Mandarin conversation: Prosody, locus, and interactional function, Journal of Pragmatics, 1731:148–166.
Kärkkäinen, Elise. 2003. Epistemic stance in English conversations: A description of its interactional functions, with a focus on I think. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Benjamins.
Li, Hong 李宏. “Fuci ‘fanzheng’ de yuyi yuyong fenxi 副词“反正”的语义语用分析 [Semantic and Pragmatic Analysis of adverb ‘FanZheng’]”, Language Teaching and Linguistic Studies 语言教学与研究 1999, 41:118–127.
Lü, Shuxiang 吕叔湘. “Xiandai hanyu babai ci 现代汉语八百词 [Eight Hundred Words in Modern Chinese]”. 1980. Beijing: The Commercial Press 北京: 商务印书馆.
Nishizaka, Aug, Hayano, Kaoru, Sunaga, Masafumi, Kuroshima Satomi & Iwata Natsuho 西阪仰・早野薫・須永将史・黒嶋智美・岩田夏穂. “Kyoukan no gihou 共感の技法 [Technologies of Empathy]”. 2013. Tokyo: keisoshobo 東京:勁草書房.
Qi, Chunhong 齐春红. “Xiandai hanyu yuqi fuci yanjiu 现代汉语语气副词研究 [Research on Modern Chinese Modal Adverbs]”, 2008. Kunming: Yunnan People’s Publishing House 昆明: 云南人民出版社.
Tao, Hongyin, & Gao, Hua 陶红印、高华. “‘Fanzheng’: hanyu ziran huihua zhong de duoneng ‘shunshi kunjing tiaojie zhuangzhi ’“反正”:汉语自然会话中的多能“瞬时困境调节装置” [Fanzheng ‘anyway’ as a mitigator in adversity in Mandarin conversational interaction]”, Language Teaching and Linguistic Studies 语言教学与研究 2022(4): 68–78.
Xu, Yameng 许雅萌. “Hanyu huihua zhong de ‘fanzheng’ – zuowei jifang guandian chenshu de biaoji ”汉语会话中的“反正”——作为己方观点陈述的标记 [Fanzheng(反正) in Mandarin Chinese Conversations: ‘My Side’ perspetive Display Token]”, 2018. Master’s degree thesis of Shanxi University 山西大学硕士学位论文.
Yao, Shuangyun 姚双云. “Ziran kouyu zhong de guanlian biaoji yanjiu 自然口语中的关联标记研究 [Research on Connective Markers in Spoken Chinese]”, 2012. Beijing: China Social Sciences Press 北京:中国社会科学出版社.
Zhao, Manka 赵曼卡. “Xiandai hanyu ‘fanzheng’ lei yuqi fuci yanjiu 现代汉语“反正”类语气副词研究 [Study on Modal Adverbs like ‘Fanzheng(反正)’ of Modern Chinese]”, 2014. Master’s degree thesis of Central China Normal University华中师范大学硕士学位论文.
Zeng, Dan 曾丹. “Fanyi fuheci xingcheng yanbian de renzhi yanjiu 反义复合词形成演变的认知研究 [A Cognitive Study on the formation and evolution of opposite compounds]”, 2007. Doctoral dissertation of Zhejiang University浙江大学博士学位论文.
Zong, Shouyun, & Gao Xiaoxia 宗守云、高晓霞. “‘Fanzheng’ de yupian gongneng “反正”的语篇功能 [The Textual Function of ‘反正’]”, Journal of Zhangjiakou Teachers College 张家口师专学报 1999(1):15–20.
