In:Latin Literatures of Medieval and Early Modern Times in Europe and Beyond: A millennium heritage
Edited by Francesco Stella
[Comparative History of Literatures in European Languages XXXIV] 2024
► pp. 507–522
Chapter 31The art of letter-writing
A medieval Latin invention
Published online: 2 July 2024
https://doi.org/10.1075/chlel.34.31bar
https://doi.org/10.1075/chlel.34.31bar
Abstract
This essay contains, in the first part, a chronological excursus (late 11th-late
13th century) dedicated to the ars dictandi, the medieval ars that teaches
epistolography and the editing of prose texts; the most significant masters and the most important works are
illustrated, from Alberico di Montecassino to Pier della Vigna and Tommaso di Capua. In the second part, on the basis
of contemporary studies, a panorama of comparative research carried out or to be carried out on the materials of
ars dictandi is traced; these researches demonstrate the richness of the epistolographic texts
and the possibility of analysis from different perspectives, for example from the historical, sociological, juridical,
documentary, rhetorical-literary, linguistic point of view and so on. The bibliography, necessarily selective, is
however attentive to the new editiones principes and the most recent essays.
Article outline
- The artes dictandi : Structure and content
- Letter collections
- The golden age of the Latin ars dictandi (twelfth and thirteenth centuries). A selection of authors and texts
- The dictamen amid critical debate: Suggestions for comparative research
- The dictamen as a European discipline
- Dictamen and rhetoric
- Dictatores and power
- Dictamen and the history of medieval teaching
- Dictamen and the ars notaria
- Dictamen and historiography
- Love and death
- Letters and women writers
Notes References
References (107)
Sources
. 2016.
Maria
natare, montes transire: l’amore nei modelli epistolari latini del XII
secolo, Interfaces 2: 97–131.
Beyer, Hans J. (ed.). 1973. Die
Aurea Gemma Ihr Verhältnis zu den frühen Artes
dictandi. Bochum: Ruhr Universität.
Beyer, Hans J. (ed). 1999. Die
Lombardische Briefsammlung. [URL]. (MGH Briefe d. dt.
Kaiserzeit).
Camargo, Martin (ed). 2019. Tria
sunt: An Art of Poetry and Prose. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Campbell, Alphonso, and Pini, Virgilio (eds). 2000. Magistri
Guidonis Fabae Rota Nova ex codice manuscripto Oxoniensi New College 255 nunc primum prodit
curantibus. Bologna: Istituto per la Storia dell’Università di Bologna
Cartellieri, Alexander (ed). 1898. Ein
Donaueschinger Briefsteller. Lateinische stilübungen des XII. jahrhunderts aus der Orléans’schen
Schule. Innsbruck: Wagner Universität.
D’Angelo, Edoardo (ed
and dir), Boccia, Alessandro, De Angelis, Teofilo, Delle Donne, Fulvio, and Gamberini Roberto (eds). 2014. L’epistolario
di Pier della Vigna. Soveria Mannelli: Rubbettino Editore.
de Kegel, Rolf (ed). 1995. “Aurea
Gemma Oxoniensis.” In Die jüngere Hildesheimer
Briefsammlung, 193–241. Briefe d. dt.
Kaiserzeit,
7. München: MGH.
Ferrante, Joan. 2014. Epistole.
Medieval Women’s Letters. [URL]
Gaudenzi, Augusto (ed). 1890. “Guido
Faba, Ars dictaminis”. In Il
Propugnatore 3/
13–14: 287–338; 3/16–17: 345–99.
(ed). 1892b. “Guido
Faba, Dictamina Rhetorica”. In Il
Propugnatore 5/
25–26: 86–129;5/28–29: 58–109.
Hödl, Günther, and Classen, Peter (eds). 1983. Die
Admonter Briefsammlung: nebst ergänzenden Briefen. Briefe d. dt. Kaiserzeit,
6. München: MGH.
Kristeller, Paul O. (ed). 1961. “Un’Ars
dictaminis di Giovanni del Virgilio”. In Italia
medioevale e
umanistica 4: 179–200.
Odebrecht, Botho (ed). 1936. “Die
Briefmuster des Henricus Francigena”. In Archiv
fur
Urkundenforschung 14: 231–261.
Peek, Friedel (ed). 1952. Die
Reinhardsbrunner Briefsammlung. MGH Epp. sel.
5. Weimar: Hermann Böhlau.
Rockinger, Ludwig (ed). 1863–1864a. “Hugo
Bononiensis, Rationes dictandi”. In Briefsteller
und Formelbücher des 11. bis 14.
Jahrunderts, 53–94. München: Georg Franz.
(ed). 1863–1864b. “Rationes
dictandi”. In Briefsteller und Formelbücher des
11. bis 14.
Jahrunderts, 94–116. München: Georg Franz.
Schmale, Josef F. (ed). 1961. Adalbertus
Samaritanus, Praecepta dictaminum. MGH QQ zur Geistesgesch.
3. Weimar: Hermann Böhlau.
Sutter, Carl (ed). 1849. Aus
Leben und Schriften des Magisters Boncompagno, ein Beitrag zur italienischen Kulturgeschichte im
dreizehnten Jahrhundert. Freiburg and Leipzig: Freiburg, Akademische Verlagsbuchhandlung von J. C. B. Mohr.
Thumser, Matthias, and Frohmann, Jakob (eds). 2011. Die
Briefsammlung des Thomas von
Capua, Berlin: MGH Digital [URL]
Wight, Steven (ed). 1999a. “Aurea
Gemma gallica”. In Medieval Diplomatic and the
Ars dictandi. [URL]
(ed). 1999b. “Boncompagnus
de Signa,
Boncompagnus
.” In Medieval
Diplomatic and the Ars dictandi. Los Angeles: [URL]
(ed) 1998a. Boncompagnus
de Signa, Oliva
. Medieval Diplomatic and the Ars
dictandi. Los Angeles: [URL]
(ed) 1998b. Boncompagnus
de Signa, Cedrus
. Medieval Diplomatic and the Ars
dictandi. Los Angeles: [URL]
Wight, Steven (ed) 1998c. Boncompagnus
de Signa, Mirra
. Medieval Diplomatic and the Ars
dictandi. Los Angeles: [URL]
Wight, Steven (ed) 1998d. Boncompagnus
de Signa, Rhetorica Novissima
. Medieval Diplomatic and the
Ars dictandi. Los Angeles: [URL]
Secondary literature
Alessio, Gian Carlo. 1979. “Brunetto
Latini e Cicerone (e i dettatori).” Italia medioevale e
umanistica 22: 123–69.
. 2006. “Su
Bonfiglio d’Arezzo.” In 750 anni degli Statuti
universitari aretini, ed. by Francesco Stella, 163–86. Firenze: Sismel.
. 2006. Bonfiglio
d’Arezzo: Dictamina. Edizione digitale [URL]
Artifoni, Enrico. 1986. “I
podestà professionali e la fondazione retorica della politica
comunale.” In Quaderni
Storici, 63: 687–719.
. 2002. “Boncompagno
da Signa, i maestri di retorica e le città comunali nella prima metà del
Duecento”, In Il pensiero e l’opera di
Boncompagno da Signa Atti del Primo Convegno Nazionale (Signa 23–24 febbraio
2001) ed. by Baldini, Massimo, 23–36. Signa: Allegri.
. 2011. “L’oratoria
politica comunale e i laici rudes et modice
literati.” In Zwischen Pragmatik und Performanz:
Dimensionen mittelalterlicher Schriftkultur, ed. by Dartmann, Christoph, Scharff, Thomas, and Weber, Christoph F., 237–62. Turnhout: Brepols.
Battista, Francesca. 2015. “Il
Formulario della Regina Kunhuta e la retorica epistolare in Boemia nel XIII
secolo”. In Le dictamen dans tous ses
états: 257–83.
Beach, Alison. 2002. “Voices
from a didtant Land. Fragments of a Twelfth-Century Nuns’ Letter
Collection.” In Speculum 77: 34–54.
Bottazzi, Maria Luisa. 2016. “La
lettera dei Romani all’Imperatore Corrado
III”. In Art de la lettre, lettre d’art.
Épistolaire politique
III, 211–28. Trieste: CeRM.
. 2010. “Special
Delivery. Were Medieval Letter Writers trained in
Performance?”, in Rhetoric beyond Words. Delight
and Persuasion in the Arts of Middle Ages, ed. by M. Carruthers, Cambridge: CUP.
. 2015. “La
déclamation épistolaire. Lettres modèles et performance dans les écoles anglaises
médiévales”, in Le Dictamen dans tous ses
états, 287–308.
Cammarosano, Paolo. 2015. “Lettere
fittizie e lettere autentiche nel medioevo italiano sec.
XII–XIV.” In Medieval Letters between Fiction and
Document, 63–72.
Carlin, Martha, and Crouch, David (eds). 2013. Lost
Letters of Medieval Life (English Society
1200–1250). Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Davide, Miriam (ed). 2013. La
corrispondenza epistolare in Italia 1. Secoli xii-xv / Les correspondances en Italie 1.
XIIe-XVe siècle. Atti del Convegno di studio, Trieste, 28–29 maggio
2010, Trieste: CeRM.
Delle Donne, Fulvio. 2010. Per
scientiarum haustum et seminarium doctrinam. Storia dello Studium di Napoli in età
sveva. Bari: Mario Adda.
. 2015. “Le
Dictamen capouan: écoles rhétorique et conventions
historiographiques.” In Le Dictamen dans tous ses
états: 191–208.
Delle Donne, Fulvio, Garbini, Paolo, and Zabbia, Marino (eds). 2020. Scrivere
storia nel medioevo. Regolamentazione delle forme e delle pratiche nei secoli
XII-XV, Roma: Viella.
Fälschungen im
Mittelalter. 1988. Internationaler Kongreß der Monumenta
Germaniae Historica, München, 16–19 September 1986. I: Kongressdaten und Festvorträge; Literatur und
Fälschung; II: Gefälschte Rechtstexte; Der bestrafte Fälscher; III: Diplomatische Fälschungen (I); IV:
Diplomalische Fälschungen (II); V: Fingierte Briefe; Frömmigkeit und Fälschung.
Realienfälschungen. Hannover: Hansche.
Garbini, Paolo. 2019. “Die
Handschriftenüberlieferung als Gradmesser der Rezeption. Die Beispiele des Boncompagnus und der Rhetorica
novissima Boncompagnos da Signa.” In Ars
dictaminis.
Handbuch: 348–351.
Gioanni, Stéphane, and Cammarosano, Paolo (eds). 2013. La
corrispondenza epistolare in Italia 2. Forme, stili e funzioni della scrittura epistolare nelle
cancellerie italiane (secoli V–XV) Les correspondances en Italie 2. Formes, styles et fonctions de
l’écriture épistolaire dans les chancelleries italiennes (Ve-XVe siècle). Convegno
di studio, Roma, 20–21 giugno
2011. Roma: CeRM.
Grévin, Benoît. 2008. Rhétorique
du povoir médiéval: les letters de Pierre de la Vigne et la formation du language politique européen
XIII-XV
siècle. Roma: EFR.
. 2015. “Perspectives
de recherches sur la théorie et la pratique de l'ars dictaminis (XI–XV
siècles).” in Le dictamen dans tous ses
états. 10–25. Turnhout: Brepols:
. 2020. Al
di là delle fonti ‘classiche’- Le Epistole dantesche-e la prassi duecentesca dell’ars
dictaminis. Venezia: Ca’ Foscari Press.
Grévin, Benoît, and Turcan Verkerk, Anne Marie (eds). 2015. Le
dictamen dans tous ses
états. Turnhout: Brepols.
Hartmann, Florian. 2013. Ars
dictaminis. Briefsteller und verbale Kommunikation in den italinischen Stadtkommunen des 11. bis 13.
Jahrhunderts. Stuttgart: Jan Thorbecke.
Hartmann, Florian, and Grévin, Benoît (eds). 2019. Ars
dictaminis. Handbuch der mittelalterlichen
Briefstillehre, Stuttgart: Anton Hiersemann.
Hartmann, Martina. 2012. Das
Briefbuch abt Wibalds von Stablo un Corvey. Briefe d. dt. Kaizerzeit
9. Hannover: MGH.
Høgel, Christian, and Bartoli, Elisabetta (eds). 2015. Medieval
Letters between Fiction and Document, praef. by Stella, Francesco, Mortensen, Lars B. Turnhout: Brepols.
Krautter, Konrad. 1982. “Ac
si ore ad os. Eine mittelalterliche Theorie des Briefs und ihr antiker
Hintergrund”. In Antike und
Abendland 28: 155–68.
McKitterick, Rosamond (ed). 1994. Books,
Scribes and Learning in the Frankish Kingdoms, Sixth to Ninth
Centuries. Aldershot: Variorum.
Montefusco, Antonio, and Milani, Giuliano (eds). 2020. Le
lettere di Dante. Ambienti culturali, contesti storici e circolazione dei
saperi. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Morenzoni, Franco. 1994. “Epistolografia
e artes dictandi”. In Lo spazio letterario del
Medioevo. La circolazione del
testo, II: 443–64 dir.
By Cavallo, Guglielmo, Leonardi, Claudio, and Menestò, Enrico. Roma: Salerno.
von Moos, Peter. 1971. Consolatio.
Studien zur mittellateinischen Trostliteratur über den Tod und zum Problem der christlichen
Trauer. München: Fink.
. 2005. “L’ars
arengandi » italienne du XIIIe siècle. Une école de la communication” in
Id. Entre histoire et littérature. Communication et culture au Moyen
Age, 389–415. Firenze: Sismel.
Murphy, James. 1974. Rhetoric
in the Middle Ages: A History of Rhetorical Theory from Saint Augustine to the
Renaissance. Berkley-Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Polak, Emil J. 1993. Medieval and
Renaissance Letter Treatises and Form Letters: A Census of Manuscripts Found in Part of Western Europe,
Japan, and the United States of
America. Leiden: Brill.
1994. Medieval and
Renaissance Letter Treatises and Form Letters: A Census of Manuscripts Found in Part of Eastern Europe and
the former
USSR. Leiden: Brill.
2015. Medieval and
Renaissance Letter Treatises and Form Letters. A Census of Manuscripts Found in Part of Europe. The Works
on Letter Writing from the Eleventh through the Seventeenth Century Found in Albania, Austria, Bulgaria,
France, Germany, and Italy. Leiden and Boston: Brill.
Poster, Carol, and Mitchell, Linda. 2007. Letter-writing
Manuals and Instruction from Antiquity to the
Present. Columbia: South Caroline University Press.
Schaller, Dieter. 1988. “Erotische
und Sexuelle Thematik in Musterbriefsammlungen des XII.
Jahrhunderts.” In Fälschungen im
Mittelalter 5: 63–77.
Schaller, Hans Martin, Stöbener, Kristina, Thumser, Matthias. 2017. Handschriftenverzeichnis
Zur Briefsammlung Des Thomas Von
Capua. Wiesbaden: Harrasowitz Verlag.
Sivo, Vito. 2015a. “La
poesia nel dictamen. Prosa e versi nel Registrum di Paolo
Camaldolese.” In Le Dictamen dans tous ses
états: 123–144.
. 2015b. “Prosa
e versi nel Registrum di Paolo
Camaldolese.” In Medieval Letters between Fiction
and Document, 131–152.
Stella, Francesco. 2010. “Chi
scrive le mie lettere? La funzione autore nelle raccolte mediolatine di epistole
modello.” In Auctor et auctoritas in latinis
medii aevi litteris. Atti del Convegno (Benevento- Napoli 9–13 novembre
2010), ed. by. D’Angelo, Edoardo, Ziolkowski, Jan, 1071–1096. Firenze: Sismel.
. 2014. “Generic
constants and Chronological Variations in Statistical Linguistics on Latin
Epistolography.” In Analysis of Ancient and
Medieval Texts and Manuscripts: Digital Approaches, ed.
by Andrews, Tara, and Macé, Caroline, 159–79. Turnhout, Brepols.
. 2015. “Recuperare
una fonte storica: i modelli di lettera.” In Le
dictamen dans tous ses états: 161–78.
Thumser, Matthias. 2015. “Les
grandes collections de lettres de la curie
pontificale.” In Le dictamen dans tous ses
états: 209–56.
Turcan Verkerk, Anne Marie. 2010. “Le
Liber artis omnigenum dictaminum de Maître Bernard.
I.” In Revue d’Histoire des
Texts n.s. 5: 99–157.
. 2011. “Le
Liber artis omnigenum dictaminum de Maître Bernard.
II.” In Revue d’Histoire des
Texts n.s. 6: 261–327.
. 2015. “La
Théorisation progressive du cursus et sa terminologie entre le Xie et la fin du XIVe
siècle”. In Archivium Latinitatis Medii
Aevii 73: 179–259.
Vulliez, Charles. 1990. L’apprentissage
de la rédaction des documents diplomatiques à travers l'ars dictaminis français (et spécialement ligérien)
du XIIe siècle, in Cancelleria e cultura nel Medio
Evo. Comunicazioni presentate nelle giornate di studio della Commissione,
Stoccarda, 29–30 agosto 1985. 16 congresso internazionale di Scienze Storiche, Commission Internationale
de Diplomatique Gualdo, Germano (ed). – Città del Vaticano, 76–95.
. 2015. “De
la théorie à la pratique. Les recueils de lettres rattachés au nom de Bernard de
Meung.” In Le Dictamen dans tous ses
états: 145–160.
Witt, Ronald. 2005. “The
Ars of Letter-writing”. In The Cambridge History
of Literary Criticism II: Middle Ages, ed. by Alastair Minnis and Ian Johnson, 69–83. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
. 2012. The
two latin Cultures and the Foundation of Renaissance Humanism in Medieval
Italy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
. 2015. “Ars
dictaminis: Victim of ars notarie?” In Medieval
letters between Fiction and
Document: 359–368.
Woods, Marjorie Curry. 2010. Classroom
Commentaries: Teaching the Poetria Nova Across Medieval and Renaissance
Europe. Columbus: The Ohio State University Press.
